“The states in India seem reluctant to empower urban local bodies both functionally as well as financially.” Comment.
Give a reasoned opinion on the statement with evidence; show where it holds, where it is overstated, and what follows.
Common trap: Answers often describe the 74th Amendment. The question asks why devolution stalls: the discretionary wording of Article 243W, parastatals, weak finance commissions and delayed elections, with data, plus a fair note on ULBs' own capacity gaps.
SyllabusFunctions and responsibilities of the Union and the States, issues and challenges pertaining to the federal structure, devolution of powers and finances up to local levels and challenges therein.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitThe 74th Amendment (1992) gave urban local bodies constitutional status in Part IXA, but left the transfer of the 18 Twelfth Schedule functions and most taxes to state law. Three decades on, cities remain dependent on state governments.
- States devolve few functions and taxes
- Low own revenue, grant dependence
- Poor services and weak staff
- Low citizen trust and tax compliance
- States cite weak capacity to withhold powers
Functional reluctance
- Discretionary devolution: Article 243W says states may, by law, endow municipalities with powers, so transfers vary and are often on paper only.
- Parastatals: Development authorities such as the DDA and water boards control planning, land and water, bypassing councils.
- Weak mayors: Most mayors are indirectly elected with short terms, one year in Delhi, while a state-appointed commissioner holds executive power.
- Delayed elections: Polls to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation, due in 2022, were held only in January 2026, despite the Supreme Court in Suresh Mahajan (2022) directing timely elections.
Financial reluctance
- Thin revenues: The RBI's Report on Municipal Finances (2022) found municipal revenue stagnant at about 1 per cent of GDP for a decade, against 7.4 per cent in Brazil.
- Narrowed tax base: GST (2017) subsumed octroi and entry tax, leaving property tax the main own source.
- Neglected finance commissions: State Finance Commissions under Article 243Y are often late and their reports shelved, so the 15th Finance Commission tied grants to property-tax floor rates and published accounts.
A balanced view
- Capacity deficit: Poor collection, outdated property registers and staff shortages are also ULB failings, as the Second ARC's sixth report (2007) noted.
- Positive signs: Indore's 2023 green bond and Pune's municipal bonds show what empowered bodies can do.
The statement largely holds: states have decentralised elections, not authority. Binding activity mapping, directly elected mayors, regular finance commissions and buoyant local taxes would make cities genuine third-tier governments.
Read more — sources
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 8, Local Governments
- OfficialConstitution of India — Part IXA (Articles 243P–243ZG) and Twelfth Schedule
- ReportReserve Bank of India — Report on Municipal Finances (November 2022)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission — Sixth Report, Local Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.