EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2023GS Paper 2Q17 · 15 marksSocial JusticeModel answer

“Development and welfare schemes for the vulnerable, by its nature, are discriminatory in approach.” Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer.

DirectiveDo you agree?
Marks15
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 2
What the examiner wants

Take a clear position and defend it with reasons and examples on both sides; the answer must say plainly whether, and in what sense, targeted welfare is discriminatory.

Common trap: The trap is to answer only 'yes, they discriminate' or only 'no, they are equality'. Separate discrimination in form (classification, which the Constitution permits) from unfair discrimination in effect (exclusion errors, elite capture, rivalry among groups), and end with a reasoned verdict.

SyllabusWelfare schemes for vulnerable sections of the population by the Centre and States and the performance of these schemes; mechanisms, laws, institutions and Bodies constituted for the protection and betterment of these vulnerable sections.

Model answer

15 marks · 250-word limit

Every targeted scheme draws a line between those who receive and those who do not. The Constitution permits this: Article 14 allows reasonable classification, and Articles 15(4), 16(4) and 46 direct special care for weaker sections. The real question is whether such classification corrects inequality or creates a new one.

Discriminatory in form
  • Classifies by caste, gender, income
  • Excludes the non-eligible
  • Creates cut-offs and categories
vs
Equalising in purpose
  • Substantive, not formal, equality
  • Corrects historical disadvantage
  • Article 14 reasonable classification
Two faces of targeted welfare

Why they appear discriminatory

  • Selection by identity or income: Stand-Up India (2016) is reserved for SC, ST and women entrepreneurs, and Ujjwala (2016) for women of poor households, so similarly placed others are left out.
  • Exclusion and inclusion errors: Targeting through lists such as SECC 2011, used by Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY, misses the newly poor and the undocumented while some ineligible households enter.
  • Elite capture within groups: Benefits concentrate among better-off sections of beneficiary groups, which is why the creamy-layer rule exists for OBCs and the Rohini Commission (report submitted in July 2023) examined OBC sub-categorisation.
  • Social friction: Rival demands for inclusion, such as agitations by the Jats, Patidars and Marathas, show how categories can deepen group competition.

Why they are not unjust discrimination

  • Constitutional design: In State of Kerala v N.M. Thomas (1976) and Indra Sawhney (1992) the Supreme Court treated special provisions as a facet of equality, not an exception to it.
  • Equal treatment of unequals is unfair: Universal rules ignore caste, gender and disability barriers; protective discrimination aims at equality of outcome and dignity.
  • Designs that reduce bias: Self-selecting schemes like MGNREGA, near-universal coverage under the National Food Security Act 2013 (up to 75% rural and 50% urban population) and the Janhit Abhiyan (2022) ruling upholding EWS quota show welfare can be broadened without losing focus.
  • Since then: In State of Punjab v Davinder Singh (August 2024) the Supreme Court allowed sub-classification within Scheduled Castes to reach the least advantaged.

I agree only in a formal sense: welfare for the vulnerable must classify, but that is the positive discrimination the Constitution intends. Unfairness arises from poor design, not from targeting itself, so regular data updates, sub-categorisation, sunset reviews and graduation out of benefits keep schemes just.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 329 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 14, 15(4), 16(4) and 46
  • OfficialSupreme Court of India — Indra Sawhney v Union of India (1992); Janhit Abhiyan v Union of India (2022)
  • NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 2, Rights in the Indian Constitution
  • OfficialNational Food Security Act, 2013 — coverage provisions

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 2 2023

Q1·10 marks·150 words·Polity
“Constitutionally guaranteed judicial independence is a prerequisite of democracy.” Comment.
Democracy is more than elections; it needs an umpire who can tell the majority it has broken the rules. The Constitution therefore insulates judges from the executive…
Read the model answer →
Q2·10 marks·150 words·Polity, Social Justice
Who are entitled to receive free legal aid? Assess the role of the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) in rendering free legal aid in India.
Article 39A, inserted by the 42nd Amendment (1976), directs the State to provide free legal aid so that justice is not denied for economic or other disabilities. The…
Read the model answer →
Q3·10 marks·150 words·Polity
“The states in India seem reluctant to empower urban local bodies both functionally as well as financially.” Comment.
The 74th Amendment (1992) gave urban local bodies constitutional status in Part IXA, but left the transfer of the 18 Twelfth Schedule functions and most taxes to state…
Read the model answer →
Q4·10 marks·150 words·Polity
Compare and contrast the British and Indian approaches to Parliamentary sovereignty.
A.V. Dicey (1885) described the British Parliament as able to make or unmake any law, with no body entitled to override it. India borrowed the Westminster model but…
Read the model answer →
Q5·10 marks·150 words·Polity
Discuss the role of Presiding Officers of state legislatures in maintaining order and impartiality in conducting legislative work and in facilitating best democratic practices.
The Speaker of a Legislative Assembly (Article 178) and the Chairman of a Legislative Council (Article 182) are the guardians of the House. Their rulings shape debate,…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.