“Development and welfare schemes for the vulnerable, by its nature, are discriminatory in approach.” Do you agree? Give reasons for your answer.
Take a clear position and defend it with reasons and examples on both sides; the answer must say plainly whether, and in what sense, targeted welfare is discriminatory.
Common trap: The trap is to answer only 'yes, they discriminate' or only 'no, they are equality'. Separate discrimination in form (classification, which the Constitution permits) from unfair discrimination in effect (exclusion errors, elite capture, rivalry among groups), and end with a reasoned verdict.
SyllabusWelfare schemes for vulnerable sections of the population by the Centre and States and the performance of these schemes; mechanisms, laws, institutions and Bodies constituted for the protection and betterment of these vulnerable sections.
Model answer
15 marks · 250-word limitEvery targeted scheme draws a line between those who receive and those who do not. The Constitution permits this: Article 14 allows reasonable classification, and Articles 15(4), 16(4) and 46 direct special care for weaker sections. The real question is whether such classification corrects inequality or creates a new one.
- Classifies by caste, gender, income
- Excludes the non-eligible
- Creates cut-offs and categories
- Substantive, not formal, equality
- Corrects historical disadvantage
- Article 14 reasonable classification
Why they appear discriminatory
- Selection by identity or income: Stand-Up India (2016) is reserved for SC, ST and women entrepreneurs, and Ujjwala (2016) for women of poor households, so similarly placed others are left out.
- Exclusion and inclusion errors: Targeting through lists such as SECC 2011, used by Ayushman Bharat PM-JAY, misses the newly poor and the undocumented while some ineligible households enter.
- Elite capture within groups: Benefits concentrate among better-off sections of beneficiary groups, which is why the creamy-layer rule exists for OBCs and the Rohini Commission (report submitted in July 2023) examined OBC sub-categorisation.
- Social friction: Rival demands for inclusion, such as agitations by the Jats, Patidars and Marathas, show how categories can deepen group competition.
Why they are not unjust discrimination
- Constitutional design: In State of Kerala v N.M. Thomas (1976) and Indra Sawhney (1992) the Supreme Court treated special provisions as a facet of equality, not an exception to it.
- Equal treatment of unequals is unfair: Universal rules ignore caste, gender and disability barriers; protective discrimination aims at equality of outcome and dignity.
- Designs that reduce bias: Self-selecting schemes like MGNREGA, near-universal coverage under the National Food Security Act 2013 (up to 75% rural and 50% urban population) and the Janhit Abhiyan (2022) ruling upholding EWS quota show welfare can be broadened without losing focus.
- Since then: In State of Punjab v Davinder Singh (August 2024) the Supreme Court allowed sub-classification within Scheduled Castes to reach the least advantaged.
I agree only in a formal sense: welfare for the vulnerable must classify, but that is the positive discrimination the Constitution intends. Unfairness arises from poor design, not from targeting itself, so regular data updates, sub-categorisation, sunset reviews and graduation out of benefits keep schemes just.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 14, 15(4), 16(4) and 46
- OfficialSupreme Court of India — Indra Sawhney v Union of India (1992); Janhit Abhiyan v Union of India (2022)
- NCERTIndian Constitution at Work (Class XI) — Ch. 2, Rights in the Indian Constitution
- OfficialNational Food Security Act, 2013 — coverage provisions
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.