“BRICS acts as a powerful counterweight in global governance, actively amplifying the voice and influence of the Global South.” Explain the role of BRICS in projecting itself as an alternative to other groupings.
Set out how or why something happens, with the mechanism made explicit.
Common trap: The directive is Explain, so the premise is largely conceded — but 'alternative to other groupings' invites explicit comparison. Name the groupings you are contrasting against, or the comparison stays implicit and unmarked.
SyllabusImportant International institutions, agencies and fora — their structure, mandate; bilateral, regional and global groupings involving India.
Model answer
166 words · 150-word limitBRICS presents itself less as an anti-Western bloc than as a demand for revised representation: its central claim is that post-1945 institutions under-represent the states now generating much of world growth.
It builds the alternative institutionally. The New Development Bank, established in 2015, lends without the conditionality associated with Bretton Woods institutions, and the Contingent Reserve Arrangement offers a liquidity backstop parallel to the IMF. Local-currency settlement reduces single-currency dependence, and it consistently advocates UN Security Council reform and IMF quota realignment.
The appeal lies in its form — consensus-based, non-treaty, imposing no alliance commitment or governance conditionality, which suits states practising strategic autonomy and lets members simultaneously belong to the G-20, SCO and the Quad.
The limits are real: India and China contest a boundary, China's weight risks capture, NDB lending remains modest, and with no secretariat outcomes stay largely declaratory.
BRICS is a credible counterweight in agenda-setting and a limited one in delivery — for India an instrument of multipolarity, not of bloc alignment.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide
Open with: BRICS positions itself less as an anti-Western bloc than as a demand for revised representation — its distinctive claim is that the post-1945 institutions under-represent the states that now generate much of world growth.
How it builds an alternative
- Financial architecture — New Development Bank (2015, Shanghai) lending without the conditionality associated with Bretton Woods institutions
- Contingent Reserve Arrangement as a liquidity backstop parallel to the IMF
- Local-currency trade settlement and payment-system discussions reducing dependence on a single reserve currency
- Expansion beyond the original five, widening its claim to speak for the Global South
- Consistent advocacy of UN Security Council reform and IMF quota realignment
Why it appeals as an alternative
- Consensus-based and non-treaty — no binding obligations, no alliance commitment, attractive to states practising strategic autonomy
- No conditionality on domestic governance, unlike Western development finance
- Agenda set by members rather than inherited from 1945
- Complements rather than replaces membership of G-20, IBSA, SCO and the Quad
The limits of the claim
- Internal divergence — India and China contest a boundary; Brazil, India and South Africa are democracies, others are not
- Asymmetry of weight: China's economy dwarfs the rest, raising the risk of the platform amplifying one member's voice
- NDB lending volumes remain modest against the World Bank and ADB
- No secretariat, no enforcement, and outcomes limited to declaratory summitry
- Enlargement raises coherence costs as preferences diversify
India's specific stake
- Uses BRICS for multipolarity and reform advocacy, not for bloc alignment
- Resists framing BRICS as anti-Western, which would collide with the Quad and I2U2
Draw: A comparison table — BRICS against G-7 and G-20 on membership basis, decision rule, finance instrument and conditionality.
Close with: BRICS is a credible counterweight in agenda-setting and a limited one in delivery — its alternative status rests on representation, not yet on capability.
Read more — sources
- NCERTContemporary World Politics (Class XII) — Ch. 4, Alternative Centres of Power; Ch. 9, Globalisation
- BookMEA BRICS Summit declarations; New Development Bank annual report
- EdiShorts appMains GS-2 — IR: International Institutions
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 2 2026
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.