Do you think that China's emergence as one of the largest trading partners of India has adversely affected the settlement of the outstanding border problem?
Take a clear position on whether booming trade has hurt or helped the boundary settlement, and support it with evidence from both tracks of the relationship.
Common trap: Weak answers either say 'trade makes peace' or 'China is an enemy'. A strong answer shows that the two tracks were deliberately delinked in 1988–2005, that trade has neither solved nor worsened the boundary question by itself, and that the trade imbalance has instead created a new irritant.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — India's relations with neighbouring countries
Model answer
25 marks · 250-word limitBy 2008 China had become India's largest trading partner in goods, and bilateral trade crossed about US$70 billion in 2011. Yet the 3,488-km boundary remains undefined. The evidence suggests trade has not adversely affected the settlement; rather, the two tracks were consciously separated, and trade has neither forced a settlement nor prevented one.
- Largest goods trading partner by 2008
- Trade near US$70 bn (2011)
- Widening deficit for India
- Manufactures in, raw materials out
- 1993 and 1996 peace and CBM agreements
- Special Representatives since 2003
- 2005 Guiding Principles
- WMCC set up in 2012
Why trade has not hurt the settlement
- Deliberate delinking: Rajiv Gandhi's visit of December 1988 agreed to develop ties in other fields while the boundary was negotiated; trade growth followed that formula.
- Peace on the LAC: The 1993 Agreement on Maintenance of Peace and Tranquillity and the 1996 military CBMs have kept the Line of Actual Control largely free of firing since 1975.
- Institutional progress: Special Representatives talks began in 2003, the 2005 Guiding Principles accepted that settled populations would be safeguarded, and a Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination was created in January 2012.
- Stake in stability: Interdependence raises the cost of conflict for both, encouraging crisis management rather than escalation.
Why trade has not helped either
- Hardening positions: China has since 2006 publicly claimed the whole of Arunachal Pradesh, issued stapled visas to residents of Jammu and Kashmir and objected to an ADB loan for Arunachal in 2009.
- Leverage asymmetry: India's large and widening deficit, dominated by Chinese electronics and machinery against Indian iron ore and cotton, gives Beijing economic leverage without a matching incentive to concede territory.
- Strategic rivalry: Infrastructure build-up in Tibet, ties with Pakistan and the Indian Ocean presence keep the security dilemma alive regardless of trade.
Assessment
- Real problem: The boundary is stuck on core claims, Aksai Chin in the west and Arunachal, especially Tawang, in the east, not on commerce.
- New irritant: Trade has added a second problem, imbalance, market access for Indian pharma and IT, and dumping cases, rather than worsening the first.
Trade has not adversely affected the boundary settlement; it has kept the relationship stable while political will on the core claims is lacking. India should use its market as leverage, rebalance trade, build border infrastructure and keep the Special Representatives track moving. (Later: the Depsang, Doklam and Galwan standoffs of 2013–2020 showed that trade alone cannot guarantee peace on the LAC.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs, Agreement on the Political Parameters and Guiding Principles for the Settlement of the India-China Boundary Question (April 2005)
- OfficialMinistry of Commerce and Industry, Export-Import Data Bank — India–China trade
- BookRajiv Sikri, Challenge and Strategy: Rethinking India's Foreign Policy (Sage, 2009)
- BookMohan Guruswamy and Zorawar Daulet Singh, India China Relations: The Border Issue and Beyond (2009)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.