"The situation today is far different to that prevalent fifty years back when the Indus Water Treaty was signed." Highlight the complexity of the current challenges on both sides of the border in this regard. Do you think that a review of the Treaty is in India's best interests?
Bring out the new challenges on the Indian and Pakistani sides since 1960, then take a reasoned position on whether reviewing the Treaty serves India.
Common trap: Emotive answers call for scrapping the Treaty. A balanced answer gives the Treaty's architecture, the disputes (Baglihar, Kishenganga, Tulbul), challenges on both sides, and argues that full use of India's rights within the Treaty is wiser than a unilateral review.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — India's relations with neighbouring countries; international treaties
Model answer
25 marks · 250-word limitThe Indus Waters Treaty, signed in September 1960 by Nehru and Ayub Khan with World Bank mediation, gave the eastern rivers Ravi, Beas and Sutlej to India and the western rivers Indus, Jhelum and Chenab largely to Pakistan. It has survived wars, but population growth, climate change and hydro projects have created far more complex challenges than in 1960.
- J&K cannot use western rivers fully
- Eastern river water still flows west
- Storage limited by Treaty
- Project delays from objections
- Extreme dependence on Indus basin
- Fears over Indian dams
- Siltation and groundwater stress
- Water used in political rhetoric
Treaty architecture
- Allocation: India gets about 20 per cent of the system's flow; on the western rivers it may use water for domestic needs, limited irrigation and run-of-the-river hydropower with restricted storage.
- Mechanism: A Permanent Indus Commission meets regularly; disputes go to a neutral expert or a Court of Arbitration.
Challenges on India's side
- Jammu and Kashmir: The state assembly in 2003 sought a review, arguing the Treaty denies it irrigation and power from its own rivers.
- Unused rights: Delays in projects such as Shahpur Kandi mean some eastern-river water still flows into Pakistan.
- Legal contests: Pakistan challenged Baglihar, where the neutral expert largely upheld India in 2007, and Kishenganga, now before a Court of Arbitration; the Tulbul navigation project is suspended.
- Security: Cross-border terrorism has created public pressure to use water as leverage.
Challenges on Pakistan's side
- Dependence: Pakistan's agriculture depends overwhelmingly on the Indus system, and per capita water availability is falling fast.
- Perception: Many Indian run-of-river projects on the Chenab and Jhelum are portrayed as threats to timing of flows, feeding militant propaganda.
- Internal mismanagement: Inefficient canal irrigation, waterlogging, siltation of Tarbela and Mangla and inter-provincial disputes worsen scarcity.
Is a review in India's interest?
- Against: Abrogation would damage India's image as a responsible upper riparian and weaken its position as a lower riparian to China on the Brahmaputra, while the Treaty already permits more use than India makes.
- For: The Treaty ignores climate change, groundwater and environmental flows, and its technical design limits are outdated.
- Middle path: Fully exploit permitted storage and hydropower, fast-track eastern-river projects, and seek joint studies on glacier melt within the Permanent Indus Commission.
A unilateral review is not in India's best interest in 2012; maximum use of rights within the Treaty and cooperative management of new risks are. (Later: India sought modification of the Treaty in 2023 and, after the Pahalgam attack, placed it in abeyance in April 2025.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialThe Indus Waters Treaty, 1960 (text, Ministry of External Affairs / World Bank)
- OfficialNeutral Expert's Determination on the Baglihar Plant (February 2007)
- ReportUS Senate Foreign Relations Committee Majority Staff Report, Avoiding Water Wars: Water Scarcity and Central Asia's Growing Importance (2011)
- BookRamaswamy R. Iyer, Water: Perspectives, Issues, Concerns (Sage, 2003)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.