Discuss the contentious issues that have caused the prolonged constitutional logjam in Nepal.
Identify and explain each contentious issue behind Nepal's failure to adopt a constitution, with the positions of the main actors.
Common trap: Most candidates only mention 'federalism'. A top answer names the deadline history (2008–2012), the specific disputes (identity federalism, form of government, judiciary, integration of Maoist combatants) and the actors (Maoists, NC, UML, Madhesi parties).
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — developments in neighbouring countries
Model answer
25 marks · 250-word limitAfter the 2006 Comprehensive Peace Accord ended the Maoist insurgency, Nepal elected a Constituent Assembly in April 2008 and abolished the monarchy. Its mandate was extended four times, but on 27 May 2012 it was dissolved without adopting a constitution because of deep disagreements on the structure of the new state.
- Identity-based federalism
- Number and names of provinces
- Presidential vs parliamentary system
- Electoral system
- Judiciary's independence
- Integration of Maoist combatants
Structure of the state
- Identity federalism: Maoists and Madhesi and Janajati parties wanted provinces based on ethnic or linguistic identity; the Nepali Congress and UML feared fragmentation and preferred multi-ethnic units.
- Provinces: The State Restructuring Commission's majority suggested ten provinces, while others proposed fewer; the names and boundaries, especially of a single Madhes province in the Tarai, were bitterly contested.
- Madhesi demands: Madhesi parties demanded 'One Madhes, One Pradesh' and proportional inclusion in the army and administration.
Form of government and institutions
- Executive: Maoists favoured a directly elected executive president; the NC and UML insisted on a Westminster-style parliamentary system with a ceremonial president.
- Electoral system: Disagreement persisted over the mix of first-past-the-post and proportional representation.
- Judiciary: The Maoist proposal for parliamentary oversight of judges was opposed as a threat to judicial independence.
Peace-process legacies
- Combatants: Integration of about 19,000 verified Maoist combatants in UN-monitored cantonments into the Nepal Army delayed trust; most chose voluntary retirement in 2012.
- Unstable governments: Frequent changes of prime minister between 2008 and 2012 meant parties prioritised power-sharing over drafting.
- Supreme Court deadline: The Supreme Court barred further extensions beyond May 2012, so the Assembly lapsed when consensus failed.
- Trust deficit: Mutual suspicion between the Maoists and the older parties, and the monarchy-era elite's unease with radical restructuring, made every compromise hostage to the next government formation.
The logjam reflects an unresolved contest between inclusion and national unity. For India, a stable, inclusive Nepal matters because of the open border and the Madhes linkages. (Later: a second Assembly elected in 2013 adopted the constitution in September 2015, but Madhesi grievances triggered a border blockade.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialInterim Constitution of Nepal, 2007
- ReportInternational Crisis Group, Nepal's Constitution (I): Evolution Not Revolution and (II): The Expanding Political Matrix (2012)
- BookS.D. Muni, Nepal in Transition: Developments and Prospects
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs, India–Nepal Relations brief
More from GS Paper II (old) 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.