In the context of Assisted Reproductive Technologies, India has emerged as a hub of commercial surrogacy. What key biological, legal and ethical issues merit consideration while framing the regulation to govern surrogacy in India?
Identify the biological, legal and ethical issues separately that a law on surrogacy in India must address.
Common trap: Keep the three heads distinct and cite the ICMR Guidelines of 2005, the draft ART Bill and the Baby Manji case; mention that the surrogate's welfare and the child's rights come first.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): Developments in Science and Technology — biotechnology, health and their social implications
Model answer
10 marks · 100-word limitCommercial surrogacy has been permitted in India since about 2002, and low costs and skilled clinics made India a destination for foreign couples. Regulation rests only on the ICMR Guidelines of 2005, while a draft ART (Regulation) Bill is pending.
- Health of the surrogate
- Embryo transfer limits
- Parentage and citizenship
- Enforceable contracts
- Consent and exploitation
- Rights of the child
Biological issues
- Surrogate's health: Hormone treatment, multiple embryo transfer, repeated pregnancies and caesarean deliveries carry risks; limits on embryos and on the number of surrogacies are needed.
- Screening: Gestational surrogacy, with no genetic link to the surrogate, and screening for HIV and genetic disease protect both mother and child.
Legal issues
- Parentage and citizenship: Baby Manji Yamada (2008) and the Jan Balaz twins case before the Gujarat High Court left children stateless when home countries did not recognise surrogacy.
- Contracts: Compensation, insurance, abandonment of a child by the commissioning couple, and accreditation of clinics need statutory backing.
Ethical issues
- Commodification: Poor, often less literate women may be induced by money, raising questions of genuine informed consent and the 'renting of wombs'.
- Child's welfare: The child's right to identity and care must override contractual disputes.
A comprehensive law should protect surrogates and children first, licence clinics and settle parentage in advance. (Later: the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 banned commercial surrogacy and allowed only altruistic surrogacy.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialICMR–NAMS, National Guidelines for Accreditation, Supervision and Regulation of ART Clinics in India (2005)
- OfficialLaw Commission of India, 228th Report: Need for Legislation to Regulate ART Clinics and Rights and Obligations of Parties to a Surrogacy (2009)
- OfficialBaby Manji Yamada v. Union of India, (2008) 13 SCC 518
More from GS Paper II (old) 2012
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.