Case study: Vijay was Deputy Commissioner of remote district of Hilly Northern State of the country for the last two years.
List every realistic option, weigh the merits and costs of each against duty, law and conscience, and then commit to one reasoned course; a case study is not answered until a choice is defended.
Common trap: Most answers pick an extreme: Vijay either abandons the district or coldly ignores his mother's rites. A top answer notices the timing in the case (the renewed rains, the cut roads, the elder sister abroad) and resolves the dilemma through a proper handover and sequencing, not a binary choice.
SyllabusEthical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance.
The case
Vijay was Deputy Commissioner of remote district of Hilly Northern State of the country for the last two years. In the month of August heavy rains lashed the complete state followed by cloud burst in the upper reaches of the said district. The damage was very heavy in the complete state especially in the affected district. The complete road network and telecommunication were disrupted and the buildings were damaged extensively. People’s houses have been destroyed and they were forced to stay in open. More than 200 people have been killed and about 5000 were badly injured. The Civil Administration under Vijay got activated and started conducting rescue and relief operations. Temporary shelter camps and hospitals were established to provide shelter and medical facilities to the homeless and injured people. Helicopter services were pressed in, for evacuating sick and old people from remote areas. Vijay got a message from his hometown in Kerala that his mother was seriously sick. After two days Vijay received the unfortunate message that his mother has expired. Vijay has no close relative except one elder sister who was US citizen and staying there for last several years. In the meantime, the situation in the affected district deteriorated further due to resumption of heavy rains after a gap of five days. At the same time, continuous messages were coming on his mobile from his hometown to reach at the earliest for performing last rites of his mother. (a) What are the options available with Vijay? (b) What are the ethical dilemma being faced by Vijay? (c) Critically evaluate and examine each of these options identified by Vijay. (d) Which of the options, do you think, would be most appropriate for Vijay to adopt and why?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitUnder Section 25 of the Disaster Management Act, 2005, the Collector, District Magistrate or Deputy Commissioner chairs the District Disaster Management Authority. Vijay leads a response that worsens as heavy rains resume after a five-day gap, just when his mother's last rites await him in Kerala.
- Over 200 dead, about 5,000 badly injured
- Rains resume after a five-day gap
- Roads and telecom disrupted
- Two years' knowledge of the district
- Mother has passed away in Kerala
- Only close relative: elder sister in the US
- Repeated calls to perform last rites
- Personal grief and guilt
(a) Options available with Vijay
- Option 1: Leave for Kerala at once, handing charge to the next senior officer of the district.
- Option 2: Stay on and ask others in his hometown to perform the last rites without him.
- Option 3: Inform the State Government, request that the rites be briefly deferred, and leave only after a formal handover once the immediate rescue phase stabilises.
- Option 4: Stay in the district and join the rites remotely, travelling later for the remaining ceremonies.
(b) Ethical dilemmas faced by Vijay
- Public duty vs filial duty: Responsibility for hundreds of lives in a deteriorating disaster collides with a son's duty, with no close relative in India, to perform his mother's last rites.
- Emotion vs judgement: Suppressing grief may cloud his decisions; yielding to it at the peak of the crisis may cost lives.
- Leadership by example: Subordinates anxious about their own families watch whether their head puts duty first.
- Indispensability vs institution: Institutions, not one indispensable individual, should carry a crisis.
(c) Critical evaluation of each option
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Leave immediately | Honours filial duty without delay | Leadership vacuum as rains resume; cut roads make travel uncertain; successor lacks his local knowledge |
| 2. Stay, rites by others | Uninterrupted command of rescue | No close relative to perform the rites; lasting guilt; may strain his judgement |
| 3. Defer briefly, hand over, then travel | Lives first, then the mother; transparent and institutional | Rites delayed; depends on a capable replacement and on the hometown agreeing to wait |
| 4. Join remotely | Keeps command; some participation | Telecom is disrupted; may not satisfy custom or his own conscience |
(d) Most appropriate option and why
- Choose Option 3: It reconciles both duties instead of sacrificing one; the dilemma is resolved by sequencing and arrangement, not abandonment.
- Concrete steps: Inform the Chief Secretary at once; brief the Additional Deputy Commissioner, Superintendent of Police and line departments; ask the hometown to preserve the body and keep his elder sister informed; take short sanctioned leave only after a replacement formally takes charge.
- Ethical basis: This reflects the Gita's ideal of nishkama karma, duty done without attachment to its fruits or to personal comfort.
- Institutional lesson: District disaster plans should name a second-in-command so that no officer is indispensable.
Integrity in a crisis is shown not by grand renunciation but by steady judgement. By staying through the critical hours and leaving through a proper handover, Vijay serves the living without dishonouring his mother, modelling the empathetic yet duty-bound leadership a civil servant owes to citizens.
Read more — sources
- OfficialDisaster Management Act, 2005 — Sections 25 and 30 (District Disaster Management Authority)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 3rd Report — Crisis Management: From Despair to Hope (2006)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report — Ethics in Governance (2007)
- OfficialNational Disaster Management Plan, NDMA (2016, revised 2019)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.