EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2023GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ8 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: A landslide occurred in the middle of the night on 20th July, 2023 in a remote mountain hamlet, approximately 60 kilometres from Uttarkashi.

DirectiveCase study
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Identify the ethical issues, then evaluate each option open to the DM on its merits and demerits and arrive at a reasoned, implementable choice.

Common trap: Weak answers simply say save the life, ignoring that unscreened blood can also harm. A top answer pursues evacuation and transfusion in parallel, insists on consent and documentation, and has the DM take formal responsibility so the doctors are protected.

SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance.)

The case

A landslide occurred in the middle of the night on 20th July, 2023 in a remote mountain hamlet, approximately 60 kilometres from Uttarkashi. The landslide was caused by torrential rains and has resulted in large-scale destruction of property and life. You, as District Magistrate of that area, have rushed to the spot with a team of doctors, NGOs, media and police along with numerous support staff to oversee the rescue operations. A man came running to you with a request for urgent medical help for his pregnant wife who is in labour and is losing blood. You directed your medical team to examine his wife. They return and convey to you that this woman needs blood transfusion immediately. Upon enquiry, you come to know that a few blood collection bags and blood group test kits are available in the ambulance accompanying your team. Few people of your team have already volunteered to donate blood. Being a physician who has graduated from AIIMS, you know that blood for transfusion needs to be procured only through a recognized blood bank. Your team members are divided on this issue; some favour transfusion, while some others oppose it. The doctors in the team are ready to facilitate the delivery provided they are not penalized for transfusion. Now you are in a dilemma. Your professional training emphasizes on prioritising service to humanity and saving lives of individuals. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in this case? (b) Evaluate the options available to you, being District Magistrate of the area.

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

The Supreme Court in Parmanand Katara v Union of India (1989) held that preserving life is the paramount duty of a doctor, yet under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 and its Rules, blood may be collected and supplied only by licensed blood banks, because unsafe blood can also kill. The DM must reconcile the two.

  1. Confirm the emergency and that referral cannot be timely
  2. Seek evacuation or blood from a blood bank in parallel
  3. Take informed consent of the woman and her husband
  4. Group and match volunteer donors with the kits
  5. Transfuse under doctors on the DM's written order
  6. Document, refer onward and report to the State
A defensible decision path for the District Magistrate

(a) Ethical issues involved

  • Right to life versus rule-following: Mother and unborn child may die soon; the blood-bank rule exists to protect patients, so applying it rigidly could defeat its purpose.
  • Patient safety: Field blood cannot be screened, as a licensed blood bank must, for HIV, hepatitis B and C, syphilis and malaria, so the transfusion itself carries risk.
  • Informed consent: The woman, if able, and her husband must understand and accept that risk first.
  • Leadership and accountability: The doctors want protection from penalty; leadership means the DM takes responsibility for the decision instead of passing it down.
  • Role conflict: As a physician the DM is drawn to treat; as DM, the duty is a lawful, documented decision without neglecting other victims, in full view of the media.

(b) Evaluation of the options

OptionMeritsDemerits
Refuse transfusion and wait for blood from a recognised blood bankFully lawful; no transfusion riskIn a remote hamlet at night after torrential rain, delay may cost two lives
Evacuate her to the nearest hospital or blood bank by road or airSafe, screened blood and proper obstetric careMay not be possible in time from a landslide-hit area
Transfuse on the spot from grouped volunteer donors, with consentImmediate; kits, donors and willing doctors are at handBlood is not screened for infections; a technical breach of the law
Leave it to the doctorsMedical judgementAbdicates responsibility; doctors have asked for cover
  • Preferred course: Pursue options two and three together: seek air or road evacuation through the state control room while the team groups the donors; if help cannot arrive in time, issue a written order for emergency transfusion with consent and full records.
  • Legal and moral basis: Sections 81 and 88 of the IPC protect acts done in good faith to prevent greater harm or for a consenting person's benefit, and section 73 of the Disaster Management Act, 2005 protects officers acting in good faith.
  • Follow-up: Shift mother and newborn to hospital, arrange follow-up testing, report to the Chief Medical Officer and push for blood storage in disaster kits for hill districts.

Rules on blood safety exist to save lives, and in this emergency their letter would defeat their spirit. A DM who acts openly, with consent, documentation and personal responsibility, and then closes the preparedness gap the episode exposed, honours both the purpose of the law and the duty to save life.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 447 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialDrugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 and Drugs and Cosmetics Rules, 1945 (provisions on blood banks/blood centres)
  • OfficialDisaster Management Act, 2005, sections 30, 34 and 73
  • OfficialSupreme Court of India, Parmanand Katara v Union of India (1989)
  • OfficialIndian Penal Code, 1860, Chapter IV (General Exceptions), sections 81 and 88

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2023

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What do you understand by ‘moral integrity’ and ‘professional efficiency’ in the context of corporate governance in India? Illustrate with suitable examples.
Corporate governance is the system by which a company is directed and controlled in the interest of shareholders and wider stakeholders. Moral integrity supplies its…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
‘International aid’ is an accepted form of helping ‘resource-challenged’ nations. Comment on ‘ethics in contemporary international aid’. Support your answer with suitable examples.
International aid rests on a moral claim that affluence carries obligations to those in need, a case Peter Singer made in Famine, Affluence, and Morality (1972) and…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“Corruption is the manifestation of the failure of core values in the society.” In your opinion, what measures can be adopted to uplift the core values in the society?
Corruption, the misuse of entrusted power for private gain, persists despite strong laws because laws punish after the act while values prevent it. India scored 40 out…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
In the context of work environment, differentiate between ‘coercion’ and ‘undue influence’ with suitable examples.
Both coercion and undue influence destroy free consent. The Indian Contract Act, 1872 treats coercion (Section 15) as committing or threatening an unlawful act to force…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Given below are three quotations of great thinkers. What do each of these quotations convey to you in the present context? “The simplest acts of kindness are by far more powerful than a thousand heads bowing in prayer.” — Mahatma Gandhi
Gandhi, a deeply religious man, held that God is best served through service of humanity. The quotation says that one practical act of compassion, feeding the hungry or…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.