EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2020GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ7 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: Rajesh Kumar is a senior public servant, with a reputation of honesty and forthrightness, currently posted in the Finance Ministry as Head of the Budget Division.

DirectiveDiscuss
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Bring out the ethical issues and the options from several sides, weigh them, and reach a reasoned position; here part (b) also demands a clear yes or no on resignation.

Common trap: Most answers treat this as a simple welfare-versus-growth choice and jump to resignation. A top answer spots the budgetary-law angle (re-appropriation works only within a grant; Parliament must sanction anything more), offers workable alternatives, and shows that frank advice on file, not exit, is the civil servant's first duty.

SyllabusProbity in Governance: Concept of public service; Philosophical basis of governance and probity; ... Utilization of public funds, challenges of corruption.

The case

Rajesh Kumar is a senior public servant, with a reputation of honesty and forthrightness, currently posted in the Finance Ministry as Head of the Budget Division. His department is presently busy in organising the budgetary support to the states, four of which are due to go to the polls within the financial year. This year’s annual budget had allotted ₹8300 crores for National Housing Scheme (NHS), a centrally sponsored social housing scheme for the weaker sections of society. ₹775 crores have been drawn for NHS till June. The Ministry of Commerce had long been pursuing a case for setting up a Special Economic Zone (SEZ) in a southern state to boost exports. After two years of detailed discussions between the centre and state, the Union Cabinet approved the project in August. Process was initiated to acquire the necessary land. Eighteen months ago a leading Public Sector Unit (PSU) had projected the need for setting up a large natural gas processing plant in a northern state for the regional gas grid. The required land is already in possession of the PSU. The gas grid is an essential component of the national energy security strategy. After three rounds of global bidding the project was allotted to an MNC, M/s XYZ Hydrocarbons. The first tranche of payment to the MNC is scheduled to be made in December. Finance Ministry was asked for a timely allocation of an additional ₹6000 crores for these two developmental projects. It was decided to recommend re-appropriation of this entire amount from the NHS allocation. The file was forwarded to Budget Department for their comments and further processing. On studying the case file, Rajesh Kumar realized that this re-appropriation may cause inordinate delay in the execution of NHS, a project much publicized in the rallies of senior politicians. Correspondingly, non-availability of finances would cause financial loss in the SEZ and national embarrassment due to delayed payment in an international project. Rajesh Kumar discussed the matter with his seniors. He was conveyed that this politically sensitive situation needs to be processed immediately. Rajesh Kumar realized that diversion of funds from NHS could raise difficult questions for the government in the Parliament. Discuss the following with reference to this case: (a) Ethical issues involved in re-appropriation of funds from a welfare project to the developmental projects. (b) Given the need for proper utilization of public funds, discuss the options available to Rajesh Kumar. Is resigning a worthy option?

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Diverting ₹6,000 crore, about 72 per cent of the ₹8,300 crore Parliament voted for the National Housing Scheme, would hollow out a promise to the weaker sections. Rajesh Kumar's file pits developmental urgency against social justice, legislative intent and fiscal propriety.

Keep NHS funds intact
  • Houses for weaker sections on time
  • Honours Parliament's vote and public promises
  • No awkward questions in Parliament
vs
Re-appropriate ₹6,000 crore
  • SEZ land acquisition proceeds
  • December payment to the MNC met
  • Energy security and investor confidence
The trade-off on Rajesh Kumar's file

(a) Ethical issues in re-appropriating welfare funds to developmental projects

  • Distributive justice: Funding an export zone and a gas plant by cutting housing for the poor shifts fiscal stress onto those least able to bear it, against Rawls' view that inequalities are just only if they benefit the least advantaged.
  • Legislative intent: Parliament voted the NHS money for a stated purpose; repurposing most of it by executive decision dilutes the control over spending that Articles 113 to 115 give the Lok Sabha.
  • Public trust and expediency: Starving a scheme showcased in rallies, with four states heading to the polls, would mislead citizens.
  • Legitimate counter-claims: A default to M/s XYZ Hydrocarbons, chosen after three rounds of global bidding, would embarrass India, and the gas grid serves energy security.
  • Haste versus due process: Pressure to process the file immediately risks skipping the examination of alternatives that probity requires.

(b) Options available to Rajesh Kumar

OptionMeritsDemerits
Process the file as directedSpeed; projects funded; seniors satisfiedGuts NHS; possible breach of budget rules
Reject the proposal outrightProtects NHSExceeds an advisory role; losses remain
Reasoned note with lawful alternatives, then implement the final decisionCandid advice; decision stays with the accountable executiveMay displease seniors; needs some extra time
ResignPersonal moral clarityLeaves the file to others; protects no beneficiary

Recommended course of action

  • Test legality first: Re-appropriation is allowed only between units within the same grant; if NHS and the two projects sit in different grants, the money needs Parliament's sanction through supplementary demands under Article 115.
  • Size the real need: Separate the December tranche from SEZ land costs that can be phased, and seek savings elsewhere before touching welfare.
  • Put it on record: Write a dated note on the impact on NHS beneficiaries and the parliamentary exposure, so the Finance Minister decides with full facts, and then carry out the lawful decision faithfully, with the integrity and devotion to duty the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 demand.

Is resigning a worthy option?

  • Not at this stage: Welfare versus development is a legitimate policy call for elected leaders; a civil servant advises frankly, not vetoes.
  • Only as a last resort: Resignation becomes worthy only if he is ordered to act illegally, such as spending without parliamentary authority or misstating facts on file, and his written objections are overruled.

Rajesh Kumar's integrity is best shown on the file, not at the exit door: frank advice, lawful alternatives and an honest record. Public money serves the nation when development is pursued without breaking the promise made to the poorest, and with Parliament kept in the loop.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 448 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 112 to 115 (Annual Financial Statement, Demands for Grants, Appropriation Bills, Supplementary Grants)
  • OfficialMinistry of Finance, General Financial Rules, 2017 — Chapter 2, Budget Formulation and Implementation
  • OfficialCentral Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 — Rule 3
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report — Ethics in Governance (2007)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2020

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss the role of ethics and values in enhancing the following three major components of Comprehensive National Power (CNP) viz. human capital, soft power (culture and policies) and social harmony.
Comprehensive National Power, a concept developed by Chinese strategists, measures a state's strength as the sum of its hard and soft capabilities. Its non-material…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“Education is not an injunction, it is an effective and pervasive tool for all round development of an individual and social transformation”. Examine the New Education Policy, 2020 (NEP, 2020) in light of the above statement.
An injunction is a command imposed from outside; education, in the statement's sense, draws out the whole person and changes society from within. The National Education…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
‘Hatred is destructive of a person’s wisdom and conscience that can poison a nation’s spirit.’ Do you agree with this view? Justify your answer.
Hatred is a settled hostility that wishes harm to another person or group. Unlike passing anger, it clouds judgement and silences conscience, and when cultivated…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What are the main components of emotional intelligence (EI)? Can they be learned? Discuss.
Emotional intelligence is the ability to perceive, understand, use and manage one's own and others' emotions. Peter Salovey and John Mayer framed the concept in 1990,…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What teachings of Buddha are most relevant today and why? Discuss.
Gautama Buddha (c. 6th–5th century BCE) traced human suffering to craving and ignorance and offered a practical, reason-based path out of it. In an age of consumerism,…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.