EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2020GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ11 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: Parmal is a small but underdeveloped district.

DirectiveCritically analyse / Give reasons
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Critically analyse asks you to weigh the strengths and the flaws of APW's story on evidence from the case; the second part needs a reasoned verdict, not a yes or no.

Common trap: Most answers praise APW uncritically. A top answer notices the excess electricity use, the dependence of a whole village on one firm and on a tax holiday, and the blurring of state and corporate roles, before giving a qualified verdict.

SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance.

The case

Parmal is a small but underdeveloped district. It has rocky terrain that is not suitable for agriculture, though some subsistence agriculture is being done on small plots of land. The area receives adequate rainfall and has an irrigation canal flowing through it. Amria, its administrative centre, is a medium sized town. It houses a large district hospital, an Industrial Training Institute and some privately owned skill training centres. It has all the facilities of a district headquarters. A trunk railway line passes approximately 50 kilometres from Amria. Its poor connectivity is a major reason for the absence of any major industry therein. The state government offers a 10 years tax holiday as an incentive to new industry. In 2010 Anil, an industrialist, decided to take benefits to set up Amria Plastic Works (APW) in Noora village, about 20 km from Amria. While the factory was being built, Anil hired the required key labour and got them trained at the skill training centres at Amria. This act of his made the key personnel very loyal to APW. APW started production in 2011 with the labour drawn fully from Noora village. The villagers were very happy to get employment near their homes and were motivated by the key personnel to meet the production targets with high quality. APW started making large profits, a sizeable portion of which was used to improve the quality of life in Noora. By 2016, Noora could boast of a greener village and a renovated village temple. Anil liaised with the local MLA to increase the frequency of the bus services to Amria. The government also opened a primary health care centre and primary school at Noora in buildings constructed by APW. APW used its CSR funds to set up women’s self-help groups, subsidize primary education to the village children and procure an ambulance for use by its employees and the needy. In 2019, there was a minor fire in APW. It was quickly extinguished as fire safety protocols were in place in the factory. Investigations revealed that the factory had been using electricity in excess of its authorized capacity. This was soon rectified. The next year, due to a nationwide lockdown, the requirement of production fell for four months. Anil decided that all employees would be paid regularly. He employed them to plant trees and improve the village habitat. APW had developed a reputation of high quality production and a motivated workforce. Critically analyse the story of APW and state the ethical issues involved. Do you consider APW as a role model for development of backward areas? Give reasons.

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

APW turned a tax incentive into jobs, skills and village welfare in a backward district, close to Gandhi's idea of trusteeship, in which wealth is held for the community. Yet the 2019 fire revealed a compliance lapse, so the story must be judged on both its virtues and its blind spots.

Strengths
  • Local hiring and skilling
  • Profits shared with Noora
  • CSR: SHGs, education, ambulance
  • Wages paid during lockdown
  • Fire protocols worked
vs
Gaps
  • Electricity beyond authorised capacity
  • One-firm dependence
  • Tax-holiday driven location
  • Firm building public facilities
  • Environmental impact unaddressed
APW's story: strengths and gaps

Critical analysis of APW's story

  • Inclusive employment: Training key personnel at Amria and drawing all labour from Noora created loyalty, local ownership and quality output without migration.
  • Shared prosperity: Profits and CSR funds went into greening, women's self-help groups, schooling and an ambulance open to the needy, and APW buildings housed the government's primary health centre and school.
  • Care in crisis: Paying all workers through four months of lockdown and using them for tree planting reflected an ethic of care rather than cost-cutting.
  • The lapse: Drawing electricity beyond authorised capacity was a breach of law and a safety risk; the fire was contained by protocols, but the violation was found only after it.
  • Silences in the case: The story says nothing of plastic waste or pollution control, nor of what happens after the tax holiday ends.

Ethical issues involved

  • Profit with responsibility: Stakeholder welfare was placed alongside shareholder return, the essence of corporate social responsibility under the Companies Act, 2013.
  • Compliance versus goodwill: Good works do not excuse rule-breaking; ends do not justify means.
  • Dependence and power: A village reliant on one employer, with its MLA links, risks paternalism and loss of bargaining voice.
  • Inclusive priorities: Spending on a temple from profits is the owner's choice, but welfare must reach every community in Noora equally.

Is APW a role model? Reasons

  • Yes, in its model: Local skilling, fair wages, community investment and crisis loyalty are replicable and fit the aim of balanced regional development.
  • With conditions: Replication needs strict safety, power and environmental compliance, transparent CSR reporting and a diversified local economy so that Noora is not a one-company village.
  • Role of the state: Government must still build connectivity, such as linking Amria to the trunk line 50 km away, rather than leave development to one industrialist.

APW is a promising but imperfect model: its ethic of care and shared prosperity deserves emulation, while its lapse in compliance shows that responsible business must be lawful first and generous second. Backward areas need many such firms, held to rules and supported by public infrastructure.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 380 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialCompanies Act, 2013 — Section 135 and Schedule VII (Corporate Social Responsibility)
  • OfficialElectricity Act, 2003 — provisions on unauthorised use of electricity
  • BookM.K. Gandhi, writings on trusteeship (Harijan, 1930s–40s)
  • BookReport of the High Level Committee on CSR (Injeti Srinivas Committee), Ministry of Corporate Affairs, 2019

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2020

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss the role of ethics and values in enhancing the following three major components of Comprehensive National Power (CNP) viz. human capital, soft power (culture and policies) and social harmony.
Comprehensive National Power, a concept developed by Chinese strategists, measures a state's strength as the sum of its hard and soft capabilities. Its non-material…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“Education is not an injunction, it is an effective and pervasive tool for all round development of an individual and social transformation”. Examine the New Education Policy, 2020 (NEP, 2020) in light of the above statement.
An injunction is a command imposed from outside; education, in the statement's sense, draws out the whole person and changes society from within. The National Education…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
‘Hatred is destructive of a person’s wisdom and conscience that can poison a nation’s spirit.’ Do you agree with this view? Justify your answer.
Hatred is a settled hostility that wishes harm to another person or group. Unlike passing anger, it clouds judgement and silences conscience, and when cultivated…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What are the main components of emotional intelligence (EI)? Can they be learned? Discuss.
Emotional intelligence is the ability to perceive, understand, use and manage one's own and others' emotions. Peter Salovey and John Mayer framed the concept in 1990,…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What teachings of Buddha are most relevant today and why? Discuss.
Gautama Buddha (c. 6th–5th century BCE) traced human suffering to craving and ignorance and offered a practical, reason-based path out of it. In an age of consumerism,…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.