EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2020GS Paper 4 (Ethics)QQ8 (Case Study) · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: The Chairman of Bharat Missiles Ltd (BML) was watching a program on TV wherein the Prime Minister was addressing the nation on the necessity of developing a self-reliant India.

DirectiveGive your views
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

Respond in the role assigned, as Chairman of BML, with a reasoned personal position; part (b) then asks for a crisp list of exactly five factors.

Common trap: Weak answers either moralise against all arms sales or cheer export targets. A top answer accepts exports as legitimate, names the specific risks (end use, diversion, conflict, corruption), lists exactly five factors as asked, and speaks as Chairman, including the duty to the Indian Army and BML's own people.

SyllabusEthics in public administration: ... ethical issues in international relations and funding; corporate governance.

The case

The Chairman of Bharat Missiles Ltd (BML) was watching a program on TV wherein the Prime Minister was addressing the nation on the necessity of developing a self-reliant India. He subconsciously nodded in agreement and smiled to himself as he mentally reviewed BML’s journey in the past two decades. BML had admirably progressed from producing first generation anti-tank guided missiles (ATGMs) to designing and producing state of the art ATGM weapon systems that would be the envy of any army. He sighed in reconciliation with his assumptions that the government would probably not alter the status quo of a ban on export of military weaponry. To his surprise, the very next day he got a telephone call from the Director General, Ministry of Defence, asking him to discuss the modalities of increasing BML production of ATGMs as there is a possibility of exporting the same to a friendly foreign country. The Director General wanted the Chairman to discuss the details with his staff at Delhi next week. Two days later, at a press conference, the Defence Minister stated that he aims to double the current weapons export levels within five years. This would give an impetus to financing the development and manufacture of indigenous weapons in the country. He also stated that all indigenous arms manufacturing nations have a very good record of international arms trade. As Chairman of BML, what are your views on the following points? (a) As an arms exporter of a responsible nation like India, what are the ethical issues involved in arms trade? (b) List five ethical factors that would influence the decision to sell arms to foreign governments.

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Arms are not ordinary exports: the anti-tank guided missile that earns revenue and funds indigenous research can, in the wrong hands, kill civilians. As Chairman of BML, I welcome the chance to export, but only within a framework of restraint that befits a responsible nation and a self-reliant defence industry.

Sell ATGMs abroad?
  • Buyer's human rights record
  • Risk of diversion
  • Regional peace
  • India's export-control commitments
  • Clean, transparent deal
  • Indian Army's needs first
  • Revenue for indigenous R&D
What should shape a decision to export ATGMs

(a) Ethical issues involved in arms trade

  • Responsibility for end use: An exporter shares moral responsibility if its weapons are used against civilians or for internal repression; Kant's rule that persons must be treated as ends, never merely as means, applies to buyers' citizens too.
  • Profit versus peace: A target to double exports within five years creates pressure to sell to anyone who pays, which can feed arms races or prolong wars.
  • Diversion and proliferation: Weak stockpile control or re-export can put missiles in the hands of terrorists and insurgents.
  • Legitimate goods: Exports give the scale, jobs and research funding that sustain indigenous production, and help friendly states exercise the right of self-defence recognised in Article 51 of the UN Charter.
  • Corruption and secrecy: Defence deals attract middlemen and kickbacks, and secrecy weakens parliamentary and public accountability.

(b) Five ethical factors influencing the decision to sell arms

FactorQuestion BML and the Ministry must answer
1. Buyer's human rights and humanitarian law recordCould the ATGMs be turned on civilians or protesters?
2. Risk of diversion or re-exportAre binding end-user certificates and post-delivery checks possible?
3. Effect on regional peaceIs the buyer at war, under a UN Security Council arms embargo, or likely to spark an arms race?
4. Consistency with India's commitments and foreign policyDoes the sale meet SCOMET licensing and the guidelines of the Wassenaar Arrangement, which India joined in 2017?
5. Integrity and transparency of the dealIs it government-to-government, free of agents and kickbacks, and open to audit?

My views as Chairman of BML

  • Indian Army first: Higher output must not delay deliveries to our own forces; I will assess capacity, supply chains and quality before committing.
  • Due diligence before Delhi: My team will seek clarity on the end user, licensing and contract terms so that the meeting with the Director General settles safeguards, not just volumes.
  • People and safety: A rapid scale-up must not dilute safety norms for handling explosives or the welfare of workers.
  • Self-reliance with responsibility: Export earnings should be ploughed into next-generation research, so that exports serve the self-reliant India the Prime Minister spoke of.

A responsible arms exporter is judged less by the volume it sells than by where its weapons end up. Though India has not signed the Arms Trade Treaty, exporting ATGMs under strict end-use controls can strengthen national capability and friendly nations' defence without making India complicit in another country's abuses.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 425 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialCharter of the United Nations (1945) — Article 51
  • OfficialWassenaar Arrangement on Export Controls for Conventional Arms and Dual-Use Goods and Technologies — India admitted December 2017
  • OfficialDirectorate General of Foreign Trade, ITC(HS) Schedule 2 — SCOMET list (Category 6, Munitions List)
  • OfficialUnited Nations, Arms Trade Treaty (2013)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2020

QQ1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss the role of ethics and values in enhancing the following three major components of Comprehensive National Power (CNP) viz. human capital, soft power (culture and policies) and social harmony.
Comprehensive National Power, a concept developed by Chinese strategists, measures a state's strength as the sum of its hard and soft capabilities. Its non-material…
Read the model answer →
QQ1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
“Education is not an injunction, it is an effective and pervasive tool for all round development of an individual and social transformation”. Examine the New Education Policy, 2020 (NEP, 2020) in light of the above statement.
An injunction is a command imposed from outside; education, in the statement's sense, draws out the whole person and changes society from within. The National Education…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
‘Hatred is destructive of a person’s wisdom and conscience that can poison a nation’s spirit.’ Do you agree with this view? Justify your answer.
Hatred is a settled hostility that wishes harm to another person or group. Unlike passing anger, it clouds judgement and silences conscience, and when cultivated…
Read the model answer →
QQ2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What are the main components of emotional intelligence (EI)? Can they be learned? Discuss.
Emotional intelligence is the ability to perceive, understand, use and manage one's own and others' emotions. Peter Salovey and John Mayer framed the concept in 1990,…
Read the model answer →
QQ3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
What teachings of Buddha are most relevant today and why? Discuss.
Gautama Buddha (c. 6th–5th century BCE) traced human suffering to craving and ignorance and offered a practical, reason-based path out of it. In an age of consumerism,…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.