Philosophy of wantlessness is Utopian, while materialism is a chimera.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.
Common trap: Weak essays pick a side. The topic rejects both extremes: complete wantlessness is unattainable for most, and materialism promises a satisfaction it never delivers. The top essay explains both claims with evidence, then builds a middle path — Buddha's majjhima patipada, Gandhi's limiting of wants, sustainable consumption — rather than ending in either asceticism or consumerism.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Philosophical: total renunciation of desire is an ideal few can live, while endless acquisition is an illusion that never satisfies — both are mirages of different kinds.
- Economic: development needs material growth, but growth as an end in itself does not produce well-being beyond a point.
- Ecological: materialism is a chimera because the planet cannot sustain it; wantlessness is utopian because billions still lack basics.
- Middle-path (strongest): the answer is neither renunciation nor accumulation but mindful sufficiency — meeting needs, restraining greed, and valuing what money cannot buy.
Why wantlessness is utopian
- Human beings have real needs — food, shelter, health, dignity
- Asceticism is a personal path, not a social policy for a poor country
- Romanticising simplicity can justify others' poverty
Why materialism is a chimera
- Easterlin paradox — beyond a point, rising income does not raise happiness proportionately
- Hedonic treadmill — desires grow with acquisition
- Consumer debt, loneliness and status anxiety in affluent societies
The planetary limit
- Overconsumption drives climate change and biodiversity loss
- Gandhi's warning that the world cannot support everyone at Western consumption levels
- Mission LiFE (launched 2022) — lifestyle for environment as a later policy echo
Indian traditions of the middle path
- Buddha rejected both extreme asceticism and indulgence
- Jain aparigraha — non-possessiveness
- Isha Upanishad's "enjoy through renunciation"; the purusharthas balancing artha and kama with dharma
Measuring well-being differently
- Bhutan's Gross National Happiness
- UNDP Human Development Index (from 1990) beyond GDP
- World Happiness Report and well-being budgets
The counter-view
- Material progress lifted hundreds of millions out of poverty — it is no chimera for them
- Desire drives innovation, enterprise and science
- Some people do live contentedly with very little — wantlessness is not wholly utopian
Opening. Open with two images: a sannyasi with a single bowl and a billionaire's child surrounded by objects yet restless — and ask whether either has found what both are looking for.
Body. Explain why wantlessness is utopian and why materialism is a chimera, then bring in the planetary limit, before building the middle path from Indian traditions and new measures of well-being.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the real achievements of material progress and to the truth that some people live contentedly with little.
Conclusion. Conclude with mindful sufficiency as the realistic ideal — needs met, greed restrained — and return to the two figures with the middle path between them.
- Easterlin paradox (1974) — Evidence that materialism does not deliver lasting satisfaction
- The Buddha's middle path — Indian synthesis rejecting both extremes
- Gandhi's simple living and limiting of wants — Practical example of restraint
- Bhutan's Gross National Happiness — Alternative measure of development
- Poverty reduction in India since 1991 — Counter-view: material growth matters
- Mission LiFE (2022) — Later policy echo of sustainable sufficiency
- “Tena tyaktena bhunjitha — enjoy it by renouncing it.” — Isha Upanishad, verse 1
- “A man is rich in proportion to the number of things which he can afford to let alone.” — Henry David Thoreau, Walden
- Choosing one side — the topic criticises both extremes
- Romanticising poverty as "wantlessness"
- Abstract argument without evidence such as the Easterlin paradox or development data
More from Essay 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.