There are better practices to "best practices".
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The phrasing is abstract but the subject is social and political: graders reward a clear reading, Indian evidence in every section, a fair counter-view and a balanced, forward-looking conclusion.
Common trap: The trap is praising best practices or rejecting them outright. The topic says there is something better than copying a "best" model: adapting to context, iterating and learning locally. The top essay shows failures of blind replication, successes of contextual adaptation, and frames the better practice as continuous, problem-driven learning — while still valuing standards that genuinely travel.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Contextual: what works in one place may fail in another; better practice adapts ideas to local conditions.
- Dynamic: "best" freezes a practice in time, while better practice keeps improving — kaizen rather than a fixed benchmark.
- Participatory: practices designed with the people who use them beat those imported from outside.
- Learning-system (strongest): the better practice is a process — problem-driven experimentation, feedback and adaptation — not a template to copy.
Limits of best practices
- Isomorphic mimicry — copying the form of successful institutions without their function (Pritchett, Andrews, Woolcock)
- Foreign urban models imposed without local fit — debates around Chandigarh and smart cities
- Green Revolution's Punjab model and its water and soil costs when universalised
Context-driven success in India
- Kerala's Kudumbashree built on local social capital
- Odisha's cyclone preparedness built on its own experience and community volunteers
- Indore's cleanliness drive — repeatedly topping Swachh Survekshan through local innovation
Adaptation and iteration
- Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) — data-driven, local competition and adaptation
- Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (PDIA) in development practice
- Kaizen — continuous improvement rather than a fixed best
Participation and local knowledge
- Traditional water systems — johads in Rajasthan revived by communities
- Gram sabha planning under Panchayati Raj
- Beneficiary feedback and social audits in MGNREGA
When best practices do travel
- Surgical safety checklists reduce errors across contexts (Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto)
- Mid-day meals spread from Tamil Nadu nationwide with adaptations
- Bihar's bicycle scheme for schoolgirls adopted by other states
The counter-view
- Best practices save time and resources; not every place should reinvent the wheel
- Standards matter for safety, quality and accountability
- Endless local experimentation can become an excuse for inaction
Opening. Open with a district collector handed a "best practice" manual from another state — and finding that the scheme which worked in a canal-irrigated plain fails in her drought-hit hills.
Body. Show the limits of best practices, then contrasting successes of context, iteration and participation, and finally the cases where best practices genuinely travel.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the value of standards and to the risk of reinventing the wheel.
Conclusion. Conclude that the better practice is a learning system — borrow ideas, adapt them, test them, and keep improving. Return to the collector, now running her own pilot.
- Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) — Adaptive, data-driven local governance
- Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (Andrews, Pritchett, Woolcock) — Theory of better practices
- Indore and Swachh Survekshan — Local innovation outperforming templates
- Kudumbashree, Kerala — Context-rooted success that is hard to copy blindly
- Tamil Nadu's noon meal scheme and national mid-day meals — A best practice that travelled with adaptation
- Atul Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto (2009) — Counter-view: standards that work everywhere
- Rejecting best practices entirely — the topic argues for something better, not for nothing
- Using only corporate examples; governance gives the topic depth
- Not defining what makes a practice "better"
More from Essay 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.