EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2021EssayTopic 8 · 125 marksModel answer

There are better practices to "best practices".

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The phrasing is abstract but the subject is social and political: graders reward a clear reading, Indian evidence in every section, a fair counter-view and a balanced, forward-looking conclusion.

Common trap: The trap is praising best practices or rejecting them outright. The topic says there is something better than copying a "best" model: adapting to context, iterating and learning locally. The top essay shows failures of blind replication, successes of contextual adaptation, and frames the better practice as continuous, problem-driven learning — while still valuing standards that genuinely travel.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Contextual: what works in one place may fail in another; better practice adapts ideas to local conditions.
  • Dynamic: "best" freezes a practice in time, while better practice keeps improving — kaizen rather than a fixed benchmark.
  • Participatory: practices designed with the people who use them beat those imported from outside.
  • Learning-system (strongest): the better practice is a process — problem-driven experimentation, feedback and adaptation — not a template to copy.
Dimensions to cover

Limits of best practices

  • Isomorphic mimicry — copying the form of successful institutions without their function (Pritchett, Andrews, Woolcock)
  • Foreign urban models imposed without local fit — debates around Chandigarh and smart cities
  • Green Revolution's Punjab model and its water and soil costs when universalised

Context-driven success in India

  • Kerala's Kudumbashree built on local social capital
  • Odisha's cyclone preparedness built on its own experience and community volunteers
  • Indore's cleanliness drive — repeatedly topping Swachh Survekshan through local innovation

Adaptation and iteration

  • Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) — data-driven, local competition and adaptation
  • Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (PDIA) in development practice
  • Kaizen — continuous improvement rather than a fixed best

Participation and local knowledge

  • Traditional water systems — johads in Rajasthan revived by communities
  • Gram sabha planning under Panchayati Raj
  • Beneficiary feedback and social audits in MGNREGA

When best practices do travel

  • Surgical safety checklists reduce errors across contexts (Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto)
  • Mid-day meals spread from Tamil Nadu nationwide with adaptations
  • Bihar's bicycle scheme for schoolgirls adopted by other states

The counter-view

  • Best practices save time and resources; not every place should reinvent the wheel
  • Standards matter for safety, quality and accountability
  • Endless local experimentation can become an excuse for inaction
Structure

Opening. Open with a district collector handed a "best practice" manual from another state — and finding that the scheme which worked in a canal-irrigated plain fails in her drought-hit hills.

Body. Show the limits of best practices, then contrasting successes of context, iteration and participation, and finally the cases where best practices genuinely travel.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the value of standards and to the risk of reinventing the wheel.

Conclusion. Conclude that the better practice is a learning system — borrow ideas, adapt them, test them, and keep improving. Return to the collector, now running her own pilot.

Examples to use
  • Aspirational Districts Programme (2018) — Adaptive, data-driven local governance
  • Problem-Driven Iterative Adaptation (Andrews, Pritchett, Woolcock) — Theory of better practices
  • Indore and Swachh Survekshan — Local innovation outperforming templates
  • Kudumbashree, Kerala — Context-rooted success that is hard to copy blindly
  • Tamil Nadu's noon meal scheme and national mid-day meals — A best practice that travelled with adaptation
  • Atul Gawande, The Checklist Manifesto (2009) — Counter-view: standards that work everywhere
Pitfalls
  • Rejecting best practices entirely — the topic argues for something better, not for nothing
  • Using only corporate examples; governance gives the topic depth
  • Not defining what makes a practice "better"

More from Essay 2021

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.