EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2021EssayTopic 7 · 125 marksModel answer

History repeats itself, first as a tragedy, second as a farce.

DirectiveEssay
Marks125
Word limit1000–1200
PaperEssay
What the examiner wants

1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.

Common trap: Most essays just list repeated events. The line comes from Marx's The Eighteenth Brumaire, where he contrasted Napoleon with his nephew Louis Napoleon. The top essay explains the idea — the repetition is a pale, absurd imitation of the original — tests it on Indian and global history, asks why societies repeat mistakes, and concludes that history does not repeat by fate but because we fail to learn.

Essay brief

1000–1200 words · 125 marks
Ways to read the topic
  • Marxian: great historical events reappear as imitation; the first is tragic in its weight, the second farcical in its emptiness.
  • Institutional-failure: societies repeat errors because they forget or ignore lessons, and the repetition is absurd because it was avoidable.
  • Cyclical: patterns — booms and busts, empires overreaching, pandemics — recur in new forms.
  • Agency (strongest): history is not destiny; repetition is a failure of memory and institutions, and learning societies break the cycle.
Dimensions to cover

Understanding the line

  • Marx, Eighteenth Brumaire (1852) — Napoleon I's coup versus Louis Napoleon's
  • Tragedy: high stakes and genuine conviction; farce: imitation without substance
  • Repetition as parody — slogans and costumes borrowed from the past

Global repetitions

  • Afghanistan — Britain, the Soviet Union and the US all withdrew after costly interventions
  • Financial bubbles — tulip mania, 1929, 2008
  • Pandemics — 1918 influenza and COVID-19, with similar failures of preparedness

Indian repetitions

  • Communal violence recurring along fault lines laid down by Partition
  • Floods and droughts with the same relief-centred responses
  • Colonial-era laws such as sedition outliving their purpose

Why we repeat

  • Forgetting — weak historical education and institutional memory
  • Vested interests and short electoral cycles
  • Hubris — believing "this time is different"

Learning from history

  • Odisha's cyclone preparedness after 1999
  • Germany's culture of remembrance after the Holocaust
  • Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa

The counter-view

  • History does not repeat exactly; contexts differ, and analogies mislead
  • Some repetitions are tragic both times — famines, genocides
  • Determinism risks fatalism; progress is real
Structure

Opening. Open with Kabul in August 2021 — scenes of a superpower's withdrawal that echoed the Soviet exit of 1989 and Britain's disastrous 1842 retreat; the tragedy of the first, the farce of the third.

Body. Explain Marx's line and its origin, then test it on global and Indian history, before asking why societies repeat and how some have learned.

Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to the objection that history never repeats exactly, and that some repetitions remain tragic.

Conclusion. Conclude that repetition is not fate but forgetfulness; institutions of memory and learning are the cure. Return to Kabul as a warning.

Examples to use
  • Marx, The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte (1852) — Source and meaning of the line
  • Afghanistan: British (1842), Soviet (1989) and US (2021) withdrawals — Opening example of repetition
  • 1918 influenza and COVID-19 — Repeated failures of preparedness
  • Financial crises of 1929 and 2008 — Economic repetition
  • Odisha cyclone preparedness after 1999 — Learning that broke the cycle
  • Germany's culture of remembrance — Institutional memory as prevention
Quotes
  • “Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it.” — George Santayana, The Life of Reason
Pitfalls
  • Listing repeated events without explaining tragedy versus farce
  • Not knowing or explaining the line's Marxian origin
  • Fatalism — the examiner rewards an argument about learning and agency

More from Essay 2021

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.