The real is rational and the rational is real.
1000–1200 words, 125 marks. One topic from each Section. The essay is graded on interpretation, structure and range of illustration — not on reaching a particular conclusion. Declare your reading early and sustain it.
Common trap: This is Hegel's dictum from the Philosophy of Right, and most candidates either avoid explaining it or write vaguely about rationality. The top essay explains its two halves, shows its double edge — conservative (whatever exists is justified) and progressive (what is irrational will not last) — tests it against history and Indian reform, and admits the stubborn irrationalities of the real world.
Essay brief
1000–1200 words · 125 marks- Hegelian: history is the unfolding of reason; what truly endures has a rational basis, and reason eventually realises itself in institutions.
- Conservative: if the real is rational, existing institutions are justified — a reading used to defend the status quo.
- Progressive: if only the rational is truly real, irrational institutions such as slavery and untouchability are destined to fall.
- Critical-synthetic (strongest): reality contains much that is irrational, but human reason can and should reshape it; the dictum is best read as a task, not a description.
Understanding the dictum
- Hegel: reason works through history; reality develops through contradictions
- Distinction between mere existence and "actuality" — what is fully developed
- Right Hegelians saw justification of the Prussian state; Young Hegelians and Marx saw a call to change
The rational becoming real
- Abolition of slavery and of sati (1829) — reason overturning custom
- Article 17 abolishing untouchability; universal adult franchise from 1950
- Navtej Singh Johar (2018) — law brought into line with constitutional reason
The real that is rational
- Scientific laws — nature behaves rationally and predictably
- Customs that seem irrational may encode rational adaptations — traditional water harvesting
- Markets and institutions that survive often solve real problems
The irrational in the real
- Wars, genocides and prejudice persist despite reason
- Behavioural economics — people are predictably irrational (Kahneman, Thaler)
- Superstition and misinformation spreading faster than facts
Reason as a public task
- Constitutional morality as a rational standard for real society
- Scientific temper as a Fundamental Duty — Article 51A(h)
- Evidence-based policy and deliberative democracy
The counter-view
- Reason itself has been used to justify colonialism and eugenics
- Emotion, faith and tradition hold value that pure reason misses
- Reality is too complex for any single rational scheme — the failure of rigid planning
Opening. Open with 1829: sati was "real" — practised, defended as custom — until Ram Mohan Roy's reasoned campaign helped make its abolition real. Which was rational, the custom or its abolition?
Body. Explain Hegel's dictum plainly, then test both directions — the rational becoming real, and the real that is rational — before confronting the irrational in the real and the role of reason as a public task.
Counter-view. Give a full paragraph to reason's own failures — its use to justify empire and eugenics — and to the value of emotion and tradition.
Conclusion. Conclude that the dictum works best as an aspiration: a just society keeps making the rational real. Return to sati, an example of reason winning.
- Hegel, Philosophy of Right (1820) — Source of the dictum — explain it, do not merely name it
- Abolition of sati (1829) — Opening example of reason reshaping reality
- Article 17 — abolition of untouchability — Constitutional reason confronting social reality
- Navtej Singh Johar v Union of India (2018) — Law aligned with rational constitutional morality
- Behavioural economics (Kahneman, Thaler) — Evidence of persistent irrationality
- Marx and the Young Hegelians — Progressive reading of the dictum
- Failing to explain what the dictum means and where it comes from
- Taking only the conservative reading or only the progressive one
- Ignoring the persistence of the irrational in the real world
More from Essay 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.