Case study: Sunil is a young civil servant and has a reputation for his competence, integrity, dedication and relentness pursuit of difficult and onerous jobs.
Part (a) wants the full range of realistic options; part (b) wants the merits and demerits of each weighed honestly; part (c) wants one reasoned choice with concrete steps.
Common trap: Weak answers either make Sunil a lone hero or quietly send him on transfer. A top answer keeps the drive going but makes it institutional: FIR and protection for the family, action against the leaking staff, and winning over the intimidated tribals so the mafia loses its human shield.
SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance.
The case
Sunil is a young civil servant and has a reputation for his competence, integrity, dedication and relentness pursuit of difficult and onerous jobs. Considering his profile, he was picked up by his bosses to handle a very challenging and sensitive assignment. He was posted in a tribal dominated district notorious for illegal sand mining. Excavating sand from river belt and transporting through trucks and selling them in black market was rampant. This illegal sand mining mafia was operating with the support of local functionaries and tribal musclemen who in turn were bribing selected poor tribals and had kept the tribals under fear and intimidation. Sunil being a sharp and energetic officer immediately grasped the ground realities and the modus operandi followed by the mafia through their devious and dubious mechanism. On making inquiries, he gathered that some of their own office employees are in hand and glove with them and have developed close unholy nexus. Sunil initiated stringent action against them and started conducting raids on their illegal operations of movement of trucks filled with sand. The mafia got rattled as not many officers in the past had taken such strong steps against the mafia. Some of the office employees who were allegedly close to mafia informed them that the officer is determined to clean up the mafia’s illegal sand mining operations in that district and may cause them irrepairable damage. The mafia turned hostile and launched counter-offensive. The tribal musclemen and mafia started threatening him with dire consequences. His family (wife and old mother) were stalked and were under virtual surveillance and thus causing mental torture, agony and stress to all of them. The matter assumed serious proportions when a muscleman came to his office and threatened him to stop raids, etc., otherwise, his fate will not be different than some of his predecessors (ten years back one officer was killed by the mafia). (a) Identify the different options available to Sunil in attending to this situation. (b) Critically evaluate each of the options listed by you. (c) Which of the above, do you think, would be the most appropriate for Sunil to adopt and why?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitSunil was chosen for this district precisely because he would not bend. The muscleman's threat, the stalking of his wife and old mother and the memory of an officer killed ten years ago now test whether courage of conviction can be made safe and sustainable rather than suicidal.
- Sand excavated from river belt
- Sold in black market by truck
- Profits bribe office staff and functionaries
- Musclemen intimidate and buy poor tribals
- Leaks and fear stall enforcement
(a) Options available to Sunil
- Option 1: Stop the raids: Yield to the threat and keep his family out of harm's way.
- Option 2: Seek a transfer: Ask his bosses to move him out on grounds of personal danger.
- Option 3: Continue alone, harder: Intensify raids with his own team, ignoring the threats.
- Option 4: Continue, but institutionally: Report the threat, secure his family, purge the leaking staff, and build support among the tribals and higher authorities before scaling up action.
(b) Critical evaluation of each option
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Stop the raids | Immediate relief for wife and mother | Betrays the trust of the bosses who picked him; the tribals stay exploited; emboldens the mafia and the colluding staff |
| 2. Seek a transfer | Family safe; career intact | Escapism; signals that threats work, as they did with predecessors; the next officer inherits a stronger mafia |
| 3. Continue alone | Shows integrity and resolve | Rash: ignores a credible threat to life and family; leaks from his own office can defeat every raid |
| 4. Continue with institutional backing | Upholds the law, protects family and keeps enforcement credible | Slower; needs cooperation of police and seniors; danger is reduced, not removed |
(c) Most appropriate course and why
- Report and register: Inform his bosses, the District Magistrate and SP in writing, and have an FIR lodged for criminal intimidation under IPC s.506; seek police protection for his wife and mother.
- Clean his own office: Shift the employees suspected of tipping off the mafia away from enforcement duties, start departmental proceedings, and refer the bribery angle to the anti-corruption bureau under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
- Make raids leak-proof: Use joint teams of police, mining and revenue officials with last-minute briefings; register cases for illegal mining under ss.4 and 21 of the MMDR Act, 1957, besides theft under the IPC, which the Supreme Court allowed in State (NCT of Delhi) v. Sanjay (2014).
- Win over the tribals: Through gram sabhas, assure the poor tribals protection, legal sand-mining work and welfare entitlements, so fear and petty bribes no longer bind them to the musclemen.
- Why option 4: It reflects Aristotle's courage, the mean between cowardice and rashness; it honours duty to law and family together and denies the mafia its proven method of removing officers.
Walking away teaches the mafia that intimidation works; marching alone may end with the officer. Sunil serves the district best by turning a personal crusade into a system: protected family, clean office, trusted tribals and enforcement that outlasts his tenure.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 — Sections 4 and 21
- OfficialState (NCT of Delhi) v. Sanjay (2014) 9 SCC 772 — Supreme Court on prosecution of illegal sand mining under the IPC
- OfficialMinistry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Enforcement and Monitoring Guidelines for Sand Mining (2020)
- BookAristotle, Nicomachean Ethics — courage as the mean between cowardice and rashness
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.