“Refugees should not be turned back to the country where they would face persecution or human right violation.” Examine the statement with reference to ethical dimension being violated by the nation claiming to be democratic with open society.
Probe the statement in depth: set out the principle and its basis, identify the ethical values breached when a democracy turns refugees back, and note the competing considerations.
Common trap: Answers often recite the 1951 Convention and stop. The question asks which ethical dimensions a self-proclaimed open democracy violates; a top answer names them (dignity, consistency, compassion, rule of law) and acknowledges security concerns without letting them erase the principle.
SyllabusEthical issues in international relations and funding.
Model answer
10 marks · 150-word limitThe statement expresses non-refoulement, codified in Article 33 of the 1951 Refugee Convention and widely regarded as customary international law. India is not party to the Convention or its 1967 Protocol, yet its courts have read protection of refugees' lives into Article 21, which applies to every person.
- Human dignity
- Right to life
- Compassion
- Consistency and credibility
- Rule of law
- Global solidarity
Ethical dimensions violated
- Human dignity: Kant's demand that persons be treated as ends, never merely as means, is breached when people are returned to torture for convenience.
- Moral hypocrisy: Karl Popper's open society rests on individual rights; a state claiming it while expelling the persecuted loses moral credibility.
- Compassion and justice: Behind John Rawls' veil of ignorance no one would choose to send the persecuted back; Article 14 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights affirms the right to seek asylum.
- Rule of law: In NHRC v State of Arunachal Pradesh (1996) the Supreme Court protected Chakma refugees under Article 21.
Competing concerns
- Security and resources: States cite security, demographic strain and limited capacity; in April 2021 the Supreme Court declined to halt deportation of Rohingya detained in Jammu, subject to due procedure.
- India's own tradition: India sheltered Tibetans from 1959, about ten million East Pakistani refugees in 1971, and in August 2021 created an e-Emergency X-Misc visa for Afghans after the Taliban takeover.
Way forward
- Screening, not expulsion: Case-by-case security vetting and a national asylum law would reconcile safety with duty.
Sovereignty includes control of borders, not a licence to send people to persecution. A democracy that values dignity at home must extend it at its frontier, guided by Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam and a clear, fair asylum framework.
Read more — sources
- OfficialUNHCR — Convention and Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees (1951, 1967)
- OfficialSupreme Court of India — National Human Rights Commission v State of Arunachal Pradesh (1996)
- BookKarl Popper, The Open Society and Its Enemies (1945)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.