Case study: An elevated corridor is being constructed to reduce traffic congestion in the capital of a particular state.
Answer each of the four parts in turn: the options, the dilemmas, the professional challenges with a response to each, and the consequences of ignoring the inspection.
Common trap: Answers often stop at refusing the chief engineer. The four parts need separate treatment: options, dilemmas, challenges with responses, and consequences, including human, legal, financial and institutional costs. A top answer also proposes how to cut the delay without cutting safety.
SyllabusPublic/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: Status and problems; ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance.
The case
An elevated corridor is being constructed to reduce traffic congestion in the capital of a particular state. You have been selected as project manager of this prestigious project on your professional competence and experience. The deadline is to complete the project in next two years by 30 June, 2021, since this project is to be inaugurated by the Chief Minister before the elections are announced in the second week of July 2021. While carrying out the surprise inspection by inspecting team, a minor crack was noticed in one of the piers of the elevated corridor possibly due to poor material used. You immediately informed the chief engineer and stopped further work. It was assessed by you that minimum three piers of the elevated corridor have to be demolished and reconstructed. But this process will delay the project minimum by four to six months. But the chief engineer overruled the observation of inspecting team on the ground that it was a minor crack which will not in any way impact the strength and durability of the bridge. He ordered you to overlook the observation of inspecting team and continue working with same speed and tempo. He informed you that the minister does not want any delay as he wants the Chief Minister to inaugurate the elevated corridor before the elections are declared. Also informed you that the contractor is far relative of the minister and he wants him to finish the project. He also gave you hint that your further promotion as additional chief engineer is under consideration with the ministry. However, you strongly felt that the minor crack in the pier of the elevated corridor will adversely affect the health and life of the bridge and therefore it will be very dangerous not to repair the elevated corridor. (a) Under the given conditions, what are the options available to you as a project manager? (b) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by the project manager? (c) What are the professional challenges likely to be faced by the project manager and his response to overcome such challenges? (d) What can be the consequences of overlooking the observation raised by the inspecting team?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitA pier is the part of an elevated corridor that cannot be quietly patched later. With a 30 June 2021 deadline, an inauguration timed before the elections are announced in July, a contractor related to the minister and a promotion dangled, the project manager must decide whether the corridor is built for a ribbon-cutting or for the next fifty years.
- Poor material used in piers
- Crack noticed in surprise inspection
- Order to overlook and keep pace
- Weakened piers carry live traffic
- Collapse, loss of life, criminal liability
(a) Options available to the project manager
| Option | Assessment |
|---|---|
| 1. Obey the chief engineer and continue | Meets the deadline, pleases the minister; endangers lives and makes me complicit |
| 2. Resume work but record dissent | Covers me on paper but the unsafe piers remain |
| 3. Insist on testing and reconstruction, escalating through proper channels | Safe and lawful; delays the project four to six months and may cost the promotion |
| 4. Resign or seek transfer | Personal conscience clear; someone else may simply continue the work |
- Preferred option: Option 3: seek a written order from the chief engineer, get independent material tests, and if he persists, escalate to the department head and the state vigilance commission.
(b) Ethical dilemmas
- Public safety versus political deadline: Lives of future commuters weigh against an inauguration before the elections are announced in the second week of July 2021.
- Obedience versus conscience: Hierarchy demands compliance with the chief engineer; professional conscience says the cracked pier will shorten the bridge's life.
- Self-interest versus duty: The hint about promotion to additional chief engineer tempts silence.
- Conflict of interest: The contractor is the minister's relative, so the pressure may be about shielding poor material, not just about speed.
(c) Professional challenges and response
- Being overruled by a superior: Ask for the instruction in writing, as service conduct rules require for oral orders, and record the inspecting team's observation on file.
- Delay and the deadline: Propose a parallel plan: test the material, reconstruct the three piers while work continues on other spans, and present the revised schedule honestly.
- Political and contractor pressure: Hold the contractor to the contract, recover reconstruction costs under the contract and keep all communication official.
- Career risk and isolation: Accept that the promotion may be lost; build support with technical evidence, not confrontation.
(d) Consequences of overlooking the observation
- Human: A weakened corridor carrying traffic could collapse; the under-construction Vivekananda Road flyover in Kolkata killed over two dozen people in 2016.
- Legal: Officials and the contractor could face prosecution for causing death by negligence under IPC s.304A and for corruption.
- Financial: Later rebuilding would cost far more than three piers now.
- Institutional: Public trust would erode and deadline-over-safety would become the norm.
A delayed corridor can still be inaugurated; a collapsed one leaves only an inquiry. The project manager's loyalty is owed to the people who will drive on the corridor, and integrity means accepting a few months' delay for a structure safe for its whole life.
Read more — sources
- OfficialIndian Penal Code, 1860 — Section 304A (causing death by negligence)
- OfficialCentral Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 — Rule 3 (written confirmation of oral directions from superiors)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, Fourth Report: Ethics in Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2021
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.