Case study: You are working as an executive in a nationalised bank for several years.
Answer all three sub-parts in order: identify the ethical issues, judge the manager's conduct by more than one ethical lens, and state your own concrete, practical response.
Common trap: Many answers either praise the manager's kindness or demand immediate dismissal. A top answer separates motive from means, recognises the absent depositor as a stakeholder, and gives a graded response: counsel regularisation first, report if that fails.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance.)
The case
You are working as an executive in a nationalised bank for several years. One day one of your close colleagues tells you that her father is suffering from heart disease and needs surgery immediately to survive. She also tells you that she has no insurance and the operation will cost about ₹ 10 lakh. You are also aware of the fact that her husband is no more and that she is from a lower middle class family. You are empathetic about her situation. However, apart from expressing your sympathy, you do not have the resources to fund her. A few weeks later, you ask her about the well-being of her father and she informs you about his successful surgery and that he is recovering. She then confides in you that the bank manager was kind enough to facilitate the release of ₹ 10 lakh from a dormant account of someone to pay for the operation with a promise that it should be confidential and be repaid at the earliest. She has already started paying it back and will continue to do so until it is all returned. (a) What are the ethical issues involved? (b) Evaluate the behaviour of the bank manager from an ethical point of view. (c) How would you react to the situation?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitOfficers of a nationalised bank are public servants under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and every deposit they handle is held in trust. Moving ₹10 lakh out of a stranger's dormant account, however noble the purpose and however faithful the repayment, turns that trust into a private favour.
- Surgery needed urgently to save a life
- Colleague widowed, uninsured, lower middle class
- Repayment promised and already begun
- The money belonged to an absent depositor
- No authority or depositor's consent
- Secrecy hides the debit from audit
- A precedent for tapping dormant accounts
(a) Ethical issues involved
- Compassion versus integrity: The need was real, but kindness with someone else's money is not charity; it is breach of trust.
- Duty to the absent depositor: The dormant account holder is a voiceless stakeholder; using that money without consent treats the depositor merely as a means, which Kant's formula of humanity forbids.
- Rule of law: An unauthorised debit from a customer's account is, on its face, criminal breach of trust by a banker under section 409 of the IPC and misappropriation under section 13(1)(a) of the PC Act as amended in 2018; good intention and repayment do not erase it.
- Secrecy and accountability: Confidentiality here exists to escape audit; what cannot be done openly should not be done.
- My own dilemma: Loyalty to a colleague who confided in me versus my duty not to conceal a known irregularity.
(b) Evaluating the bank manager's behaviour
| Lens | Assessment |
|---|---|
| Motive | Compassionate, with no personal gain stated in the case; this mitigates but does not justify. |
| Means | Abuse of position to use a third party's deposit without authority or consent. |
| Consequences | A life was saved, but the depositor bears a hidden risk of loss and the bank's credibility is exposed. |
| Leadership | A supervisor should point a distressed employee to lawful help, not draw her into an irregular act. |
- Verdict: Outcome-based reasoning partly favours the manager; duty-based and virtue ethics condemn the means. The act is well-meant but ethically and legally wrong, and the demand for secrecy makes the colleague complicit too.
(c) How I would react
- Empathise first: Acknowledge her relief and honesty in repaying; she acted under acute distress.
- Urge self-correction: Advise her and the manager to regularise the transaction at once, for example by converting it into a formal personal loan or any staff advance the bank permits, and restoring the dormant account in full.
- Mobilise lawful help: Help her raise the balance quickly through family, colleagues or a regular loan.
- Report if not regularised: I cannot keep this confidence indefinitely; if they refuse, I would report it to the bank's vigilance officer or under the CVC's PIDPI Resolution, 2004, pointing out the mitigating circumstances.
- Fix the system: Suggest maker-checker alerts on dormant-account debits.
Compassion is a civil-service value, but it must travel through legitimate channels. The right response keeps faith with both people involved: help the colleague find lawful money to close the gap quickly, and refuse to let a depositor's trust be quietly spent, because a bank runs on that trust.
Read more — sources
- OfficialPrevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (as amended in 2018), sections 2(c) and 13
- OfficialIndian Penal Code, 1860, section 409 (criminal breach of trust by public servant, or by banker, merchant or agent)
- OfficialCentral Vigilance Commission: Public Interest Disclosure and Protection of Informers (PIDPI) Resolution, 2004
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, Fourth Report: Ethics in Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.