Case study: You hold a responsible position in a ministry in the government.
Examine the ethical issues raised by social media in this case from several angles, then weigh the arguments for and against your own counter-video and arrive at a balanced view.
Common trap: Most answers praise the counter-video as standing up for truth. A top answer notices that it names children as likely perpetrators, against the son's plea, and that legal and institutional remedies existed; it also separates a public servant's private vindication from official conduct.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Ethics and Human Interface: Essence, determinants and consequences of Ethics in human actions; ethics in private and public relationships. Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas.)
The case
You hold a responsible position in a ministry in the government. One day in the morning you received a call from the school of your 11-year-old son that you are required to come and meet the Principal. You proceed to the school and find your son in the Principal’s office. The Principal informs you that your son had been found wandering aimlessly in the grounds during the time classes were in progress. The class teacher further informs you that your son has lately become a loner and did not respond to questions in the class, he had also been unable to perform well in the football trials held recently. You bring your son back from the school and in the evening, you along with your wife try to find out the reasons for your son’s changed behaviour. After repeated cajoling, your son shares that some children had been making fun of him in the class as well as in the WhatsApp group of the students by calling him stunted, duh and a frog. He tells you the names of a few children who are the main culprits but pleads with you to let the matter rest. After a few days, during a sporting event, where you and your wife have gone to watch your son play, one of your colleague’s son shows you a video in which students have caricatured your son. Further, he also points out to the perpetrators who were sitting in the stands. You purposefully walk past them with your son and go home. Next day, you find on social media, a video denigrating you, your son and even your wife, stating that you engaged in physical bullying of children on the sports field. The video became viral on social media. Your friends and colleagues began calling you to find out the details. One of your juniors advised you to make a counter video giving the background and explaining that nothing had happened on the field. You, in turn posted a video which you have captured during the sporting event, identifying the likely perpetrators who were responsible for your son’s predicament. You have also narrated what has actually happened in the field and made attempts to bring out the adverse effects of the misuse of social media. (a) Based on the above case study, discuss the ethical issues involved in the use of social media. (b) Discuss the pros and cons of using social media by you to put across the facts to counter the fake propaganda against your family.
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitSocial media first amplified the bullying of an 11-year-old and then manufactured a lie about his family. The same tool that spreads truth at scale spreads cruelty and falsehood at scale, so a public official's reply must be judged by its means as well as its ends.
- Teasing in class
- Name-calling in the students' WhatsApp group
- Caricature video of the son
- Fake video alleging physical bullying
- Viral spread; colleagues call
- Counter-video identifying likely perpetrators
(a) Ethical issues in the use of social media
- Cyberbullying and dignity: Calling a child stunted and a frog in a group chat, then caricaturing him, follows him beyond school and has made him a withdrawn loner.
- Truth versus virality: A fabricated video travelled faster than any check; sharers became partners in defamation, an offence under sections 499 and 500 of the IPC.
- Anonymity and accountability: Creators hide behind accounts, while the IT Rules, 2021 require platforms' grievance officers to acknowledge complaints within 24 hours and resolve them within 15 days.
- Privacy and consent: A child and a spouse were mocked and exposed online without consent.
- Children as perpetrators: The bullies are minors too, so schools and parents share responsibility for digital literacy and empathy.
(b) Pros and cons of my counter-video
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Truth | Puts facts before the same audience at the same speed | Turns a private hurt into a public spectacle |
| Reputation | Defends the family and the credibility of my office | May look like a senior official using his stature against children |
| Children involved | Exposes the harm of misuse and may deter bullies | Identifying likely perpetrators, all children, on suspicion risks the same bullying for them |
| My son | Validates his suffering | Ignores his plea to let it rest; makes him more visible |
| Conduct rules | Rule 19 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules permits vindicating private character | Requires a report to the authority; must avoid any official resources |
| Due process | Quick | Bypasses school, police and platform; risks vigilantism |
A better course
- Use the law: Report the fake video on cybercrime.gov.in or helpline 1930, to the platform and to the police for defamation.
- Restore, not retaliate: Ask the school to counsel the children involved and hold a meeting with their parents.
- Measured statement: If a public reply is needed, state facts without showing or naming any minor, after informing my department.
- Son first: Arrange counselling and rebuild his confidence with his consent.
Truth deserves a voice, but not one that repeats the harm. A public servant countering falsehood should lean on law, institutions and a measured statement that protects every child involved, including those who erred, because the goal is a safer digital space, not a victory online.
Read more — sources
- OfficialInformation Technology (Intermediary Guidelines and Digital Media Ethics Code) Rules, 2021
- OfficialIndian Penal Code, 1860, sections 499-500 (defamation)
- OfficialCentral Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, Rule 19 (vindication of acts and character)
- OfficialMinistry of Home Affairs: National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (cybercrime.gov.in)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.