Case study: You have just been appointed as Additional Director General of Central Public Works Department.
Answer all three sub-parts in order: identify the ethical issues, set out options that save both the project and Seema, and give your personal response to her along with institutional measures to prevent recurrence.
Common trap: Many answers move Seema off the project or rush to punish the Chief Architect. A top answer treats his insecurity with emotional intelligence, secures his legacy and her credit together, and adds organisation-wide safeguards rather than a one-off fix.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Emotional intelligence-concepts, and their utilities and application in administration and governance. Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; strengthening of ethical and moral values in governance.)
The case
You have just been appointed as Additional Director General of Central Public Works Department. The Chief Architect of your division, who is to retire in six months, is passionately working on a very important project, the successful completion of which would earn him a lasting reputation for the rest of his life. A new lady architect, Seema, trained at Manchester School of Architecture, UK joined as Senior Architect in your division. During the briefing about the project, Seema made some suggestions which would not only add value to the project, but would also reduce completion time. This has made the Chief Architect insecure and he is constantly worried that all the credit will go to her. Subsequently, he adopted a passive and aggressive behaviour towards her and has become disrespectful to her. Seema felt it embarrassing as the Chief Architect left no chance of humiliating her. He would very often correct her in front of other colleagues and raise his voice while speaking to her. This continuous harassment has resulted in her losing confidence and self-esteem. She felt perpetually tensed, anxious and stressed. She appeared to be in awe of him since he has had a long tenure in the office and has vast experience in the area of her work. You are aware of her outstanding academic credentials and career record in her previous organisations. However, you fear that this harassment may result in compromising her much needed contribution in this important project and may adversely impact her emotional well-being. You have also come to know from her peers that she is contemplating tendering her resignation. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) What are the options available to you in order to complete the project as well as to retain Seema in the organization? (c) What would be your response to Seema’s predicament? What measures would you institute to prevent such occurrences from happening in your organization?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitSeema's suffering stems from a senior colleague's insecurity, not from any fault of hers. As Additional Director General, I owe three duties at once: protect her dignity, deliver an important public project on time, and help a retiring Chief Architect leave with honour rather than resentment.
- Seema's value-adding, time-saving suggestions
- Chief Architect fears losing the credit
- Public correction, raised voice, humiliation
- Seema loses confidence; anxiety and stress
- Resignation contemplated
- Project risks losing talent and time
(a) Ethical issues involved
- Dignity at work: Humiliating a colleague before peers treats her as an obstacle, not a person, against Kant's principle that people are ends in themselves; it is also conduct unbecoming of a government servant under Rule 3 of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
- Ego versus public interest: Resisting ideas that add value and cut completion time puts personal credit above public money and public service.
- Abuse of seniority: Her awe of his tenure creates a power gap that lets harassment go unchallenged.
- Duty of care and inclusion: The organisation risks a talented woman professional's health and career, and a wrong signal to others.
- Leadership accountability: Knowing of it and doing nothing would make me complicit.
(b) Options to complete the project and retain Seema
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Ignore; wait for his retirement | No confrontation | Harassment continues; Seema likely resigns |
| Shift Seema to another project | Ends friction at once | Punishes the victim; project loses her ideas |
| Immediate disciplinary action | Clear zero-tolerance message | Humiliates him at career's end; may stall work |
| Counsel him and restructure roles with shared credit | Keeps both talents; dignified | Needs his cooperation and close monitoring |
- Preferred option: Choose the last one: in a private, empathetic talk, assure him the project's success will carry his name as leader, and make clear that humiliation stops now.
- Credit by design: Record Seema's design workstream and contributions in project documents, and have both present progress jointly to me.
- Legacy through mentoring: Frame his last six months as handing over to the next generation, with Seema as a key successor.
- Escalate if needed: If the behaviour continues, issue a written warning and then take disciplinary steps.
(c) Response to Seema and preventive measures
- Meet her privately: Listen, affirm her record, assure confidentiality and my support, and ask her not to decide on resignation in haste.
- Support: Offer counselling, a senior mentor and direct access to me during the project.
- Dignity-at-work policy: Define bullying and incivility, set up a time-bound grievance committee and protect complainants from reprisal.
- Capacity building: Run training in emotional intelligence, the idea popularised by Daniel Goleman in 1995, and respectful supervision, through Mission Karmayogi (2020) courses.
- Systems: Institute team-based recognition, regular anonymous staff feedback and succession planning before senior officers retire.
A project is built by people before it is built in concrete. Protecting Seema's dignity while letting the Chief Architect leave with honour turns a clash of egos into a handover of excellence, which is what ethical public leadership looks like.
Read more — sources
- OfficialCentral Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964
- BookDaniel Goleman, Emotional Intelligence (1995)
- OfficialDepartment of Personnel and Training: Mission Karmayogi, National Programme for Civil Services Capacity Building (2020)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2023
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.