Case study: In line with the Directive Principles of State Policy enshrined in the Indian Constitution, the government has a constitutional obligation to ensure…
Take a reasoned position on whether the welfare end justifies the ecological means, examine the challenges under each named head, and propose workable alternatives; balance and practical policy earn marks, not a one-sided verdict.
Common trap: Weak answers frame it as housing versus trees. The tribal and nomadic livelihoods in the case make it a conflict between two under-privileged groups. A top answer tests each of the administration's four arguments, notes that the hideout claim is only alleged, and shows housing does not need this forest.
SyllabusEthical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance.
The case
In line with the Directive Principles of State Policy enshrined in the Indian Constitution, the government has a constitutional obligation to ensure basic needs – “Roti, Kapda aur Makan (Food, Clothes and Shelter)” – for the under-privileged. Pursuing this mandate, the district administration proposed clearing a portion of forest land to develop housing for the homeless and economically weaker sections of the society. The proposed land, however, is an ecologically sensitive zone densely populated with age-old trees, medicinal plants and vital biodiversity. Besides, these forests help to regulate micro-climate and rainfalls; provide habitat for wildlife, support soil fertility and prevent land/soil erosion and sustain livelihoods of tribal and nomadic communities. Inspite of the ecological and social costs, the administration argues in favour of the said proposal by highlighting that this very initiative addresses fundamental human rights as a critical welfare priority. Besides, it fulfils the government’s duty to uplift and empower the poor through inclusive housing development. Further, these forest areas have become unsafe due to wild-animal threats and recurring human-wild life conflicts. Lastly, clearing forest-zones may help to curb anti-social elements allegedly using these areas as hideouts, thereby enhancing law and order. (a) Can deforestation be ethically justified in the pursuit of social welfare objectives like, housing for the homeless? (b) What are the socio-economic, administrative and ethical challenges in balancing environmental conservation with human development? (c) What substantial alternatives or policy interventions can be proposed to ensure that both environmental integrity and human dignity are protected?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitShelter is part of the right to life under Article 21, as the Supreme Court held in Chameli Singh v. State of U.P. (1996); yet Article 48A and Article 51A(g) bind the State and citizens to protect forests. Here, housing for one vulnerable group would erase the livelihoods of tribal and nomadic communities.
- Homeless: shelter and dignity
- Tribal and nomadic livelihoods
- Age-old trees and medicinal plants
- Micro-climate and rainfall
- Soil fertility, erosion control
- Wildlife habitat and human safety
- Future generations
(a) Can deforestation be ethically justified?
- The welfare case: Housing the homeless serves DPSP goals under Articles 38 and 39 and the utilitarian aim of the greatest good, so the end is legitimate.
- Why the means fail: The zone is ecologically sensitive and the loss irreversible, and the cost falls on tribal and nomadic communities; Rawls' difference principle judges a policy by its effect on the least advantaged, and they are among them.
- Testing the other arguments: Wild-animal threats and human-wildlife conflict call for wildlife management, and anti-social elements are only allegedly present, a policing matter; neither justifies felling age-old trees.
- Verdict: Clearing could be defensible only as a last resort, with no alternative land, after forest rights are settled and the gram sabha consulted, as in the Niyamgiri case (2013); the case shows neither.
(b) Socio-economic, administrative and ethical challenges
| Dimension | Challenges |
|---|---|
| Socio-economic | Scarce, costly land for housing; loss of forest produce, medicinal plants and grazing for tribals and nomads; housing far from jobs stays empty |
| Administrative | Forest diversion approval under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, renamed the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam in 2023; compensatory afforestation under the CAF Act, 2016 cannot replace old-growth forest; silos between housing, forest and police departments |
| Ethical | Rights against rights; intergenerational equity; human-centred versus nature-centred values; whether those who lose the forest have any voice |
(c) Alternatives and policy interventions
- Alternative land: Use government land banks, degraded or waste land and vacant public plots, and build vertically to save land.
- Existing schemes: Converge with PMAY-Urban 2.0 (2024), PMAY-Gramin, in-situ slum redevelopment and Affordable Rental Housing Complexes (2020).
- Secure the forest and its people: Recognise individual and community rights under the Forest Rights Act, 2006, notify the area for conservation and promote community-managed harvest of medicinal plants.
- Solve the stated problems directly: Tackle human-wildlife conflict with early-warning systems, barriers and rapid-response teams, and verify the alleged anti-social activity through patrolling.
- Participatory planning: Hold an environmental and social impact assessment with public hearings involving both the homeless and the gram sabha.
Welfare that destroys the commons on which the poorest depend only relocates misery. The administration should house the homeless on alternative land and keep the forest under community stewardship, treating environmental integrity and human dignity as twin constitutional obligations rather than rivals.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Articles 21, 38, 39, 48A and 51A(g)
- OfficialScheduled Tribes and Other Traditional Forest Dwellers (Recognition of Forest Rights) Act, 2006
- OfficialOrissa Mining Corporation v. Ministry of Environment and Forests, Supreme Court (2013)
- OfficialForest (Conservation) Act, 1980 (Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 since 2023) and Compensatory Afforestation Fund Act, 2016
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.