Case study: Rajesh is a Group A officer with nine years of service.
Lay out every realistic option with its merits and demerits, name the ethical issues precisely, and then defend one option with concrete steps; each of (a), (b) and (c) must be answered separately.
Common trap: Most answers miss the twist that the boss who named the vendor is also Rajesh's ACR reporting officer and the very authority whose sanction is needed above Rs 30 lakh. A top answer routes one proposal to him lawfully, insists on competitive purchase and handles him tactfully, instead of only refusing.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Probity in Governance: Codes of Conduct, Work culture, Utilization of public funds, challenges of corruption.)
The case
Rajesh is a Group A officer with nine years of service. He is posted as Administrative Officer in an Oil Public Sector undertaking. As an Administrative Officer he is responsible for managing and coordinating various administrative tasks to ensure smooth functioning of office. He also manages office supplies, equipment etc. Rajesh is now sufficient senior and is expecting his next promotion in JAG (Junior Administrative Grade) in the next one or two years. He knows that promotion is based on examination of ACRs/Performance Appraisal of last few years (5 years or so) of an officer by a DPC (Departmental Promotion Committee) and an officer lacking requisite grading of ACRs may not be found fit for promotion. Consequences of losing promotion may entail financial and reputational loss and set-back for career progression. Though he also puts his best efforts in official discharge of his duties, yet he is unsure of assessment by his superior officer. He is now putting extra efforts so that he gets thumping report at the end of financial year. As Administrative Officer, Rajesh is regularly interacting with his immediate boss, who is his reporting officer for writing his ACR. One day he calls Rajesh and wants him to buy computer-related stationery on priority from a particular vendor. Rajesh instructs his office to initiate action for procuring these items. During the day, the dealing Assistant brings an estimate of Rupees Thirty Five Lakhs covering all stationery items from the same vendor. It is noticed that as per delegated financial powers, as provided in the GFR (General Financial Rules) as applicable in that Organisation, expenditure for office items exceeding Rupees Thirty Lakhs requires sanction of the next higher authority (boss in the present case). Rajesh knows that immediate superior would expect all these purchases should be done at his level and may not appreciate such lack of initiative on his part. During discussions with office, he learns that common practice of splitting of expenditure (where large order is divided into a series of smaller ones) is followed to avoid obtaining sanction from higher authority. This practice is against the rules and may come to the adverse notice of Audit. Rajesh is perturbed. He is unsure of taking decision in the matter. (a) What are the options available with Rajesh in the above situation? (b) What are the ethical issues involved in this case? (c) Which would be the most appropriate option for Rajesh and why?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitGFR 2017 (Rule 157) bars dividing a demand into piecemeal purchases to avoid the sanction its total value requires. Rajesh's Rs 35 lakh estimate exceeds his Rs 30 lakh power, and the sanctioning authority is the same boss who named the vendor and writes his ACR.
- Boss is his ACR reporting officer
- Boss must sanction above Rs 30 lakh
- Vendor chosen by the boss
- JAG promotion rests on ACRs before the DPC
- Office habit of splitting orders
- Audit scrutiny of PSU spending
(a) Options available with Rajesh
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Split the estimate into orders below Rs 30 lakh, as the office usually does | Quick supply; boss need not sign; ACR seems safe | Breaches Rule 157; audit objection; Rajesh, who signs, is answerable |
| Trim the order to Rs 30 lakh and buy at his own level | Within his power on paper | Lawful only if the rest is truly not needed now; otherwise a disguised split |
| Put up one Rs 35 lakh proposal to the boss for sanction, through competitive purchase | Rule-compliant, transparent, audit-proof; need met | Boss may read it as lack of initiative; short delay |
| Refuse to act and complain to vigilance at once | Rules upheld firmly | Premature without proof; stalls genuine work |
(b) Ethical issues involved
- Self-interest versus duty: Fear of a weak ACR before the JAG DPC tempts Rajesh to bend a rule he knows.
- Conflict of interest of the superior: One officer names the vendor, must sanction the spend and grades Rajesh, so the ACR can become an instrument of pressure.
- Favouritism and value for money: Buying from a pre-chosen vendor without competition risks overpaying with a PSU's public money.
- Normalised deviance: A common practice of splitting does not make an irregular act right; it hollows out delegated financial powers.
- Accountability and moral courage: Expecting the purchase at Rajesh's level shifts responsibility downward; the test is whether he can speak truth to power politely.
(c) Most appropriate option and why
- Option three: Process the full requirement as one proposal, marked priority, and route it to the boss as the competent sanctioning authority.
- Open competition: Buy through the Government e-Marketplace (GeM) or a tender under the PSU's procurement rules, so the named vendor may compete but is not favoured.
- Tactful briefing: Explain to the boss that splitting would invite audit objection against both; his signature now protects him.
- Paper trail: If told orally to split, seek the direction in writing and record his note; approach the Chief Vigilance Officer only if pressure persists.
- Why: An ACR earned through irregularity can become a charge-sheet; besides, the Supreme Court in Dev Dutt v. Union of India (2008) required ACR entries to be communicated, so Rajesh can represent against an unfair grading.
Initiative in public service means finding the fastest lawful route, not a shortcut around the law. By sending one transparent proposal to the right authority, Rajesh protects public money, shields his superior from audit and quietly begins to end an office habit of gaming financial rules.
Read more — sources
- OfficialGeneral Financial Rules, 2017 — Chapter 6, Procurement of Goods (Rule 157, bar on splitting of demand)
- OfficialDev Dutt v. Union of India, Supreme Court of India (2008) — communication of ACR entries
- OfficialCentral Vigilance Commission — Vigilance Manual and guidelines on public procurement
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report — Ethics in Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.