Case study: Ashok is Divisional Commissioner of one of the border districts of the North East State.
Set out the options with their merits and demerits, identify both the ethical and the legal dilemmas, defend the best option, and give specific operational precautions; all four sub-parts must be answered.
Common trap: Answers often treat the group as one, admitting or rejecting all. A top answer separates the injured civilians from the armed soldiers, cites Article 21 and non-refoulement accurately with the law in force in 2025, and gives practical disarm, verify and segregate steps for part (d).
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; ethical issues in international relations and funding.)
The case
Ashok is Divisional Commissioner of one of the border districts of the North East State. A few years back, Military has taken over the neighbouring country after overthrowing the elected civil government. Civil war situation is prevailing in the country especially in last two years. However, internal situation further deteriorated due to rebel groups taking over control of certain populated areas near own border. Due to intense fight between military and rebel groups, civilian casualties has increased manifold in recent past. In the meantime, in one night Ashok got information from the local police guarding the border check post that there are about 200-250 people mainly women and children trying to cross over to our side of the border. There are also about 10 soldiers with their weapons in military uniform part of this group who wants to cross over. Women and Children are also crying and begging for help. A few of them are injured and bleeding profusely need immediate medical care. Ashok tried to contact Home Secretary of the State but failed to do so due to poor connectivity mainly due to inclement weather. (a) What are the options available with Ashok to cope with the situation? (b) What are the ethical and legal dilemmas being faced by Ashok? (c) Which of the options, do you think would be more appropriate for Ashok to adopt and why? (d) In the present situation, what are the extra precautionary measures to be taken by the Border Guarding Police in dealing with soldiers in uniform?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitIndia is not a party to the 1951 Refugee Convention, yet Article 21 protects the life of every person on its soil, and the Supreme Court in NHRC v. State of Arunachal Pradesh (1996) applied it to Chakma refugees. Ashok must save lives tonight without surrendering border security.
- Hold the group at the check post
- Separate armed soldiers from civilians
- Disarm soldiers; guard them apart
- Emergency care for the injured
- Screen, register and shelter civilians
- Report by every channel; await policy
(a) Options available with Ashok
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Turn the whole group back | Strict border control | Likely deaths; against Article 21 values and non-refoulement |
| Admit everyone, soldiers included | Quick and humane | Armed men inside; rebels may slip in |
| Wait until the Home Secretary is reachable | Avoids overstepping authority | The bleeding may die; inaction is itself a decision |
| Treat and shelter civilians in a guarded camp; admit soldiers only disarmed and kept apart | Saves lives while keeping control | Needs resources; must be ratified by government |
(b) Ethical and legal dilemmas
- Compassion versus security: Injured women and children need help, but rebels could slip in among them.
- Law versus life: Entry without valid documents was an offence under the Foreigners Act, 1946 and the Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920 (since replaced by the Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025, in force from 1 September 2025), yet returning people to likely death offends Article 21 and non-refoulement.
- Authority versus initiative: Foreigners and border policy belong to the Union, but no superior is reachable and delay can cost lives.
- Neutrality: Sheltering soldiers of the neighbouring military may be read by the rebels, or the regime, as taking sides.
(c) Most appropriate option and why
- Option four: Rush medical teams to the check post, move the badly injured to hospital, and shelter the rest in a guarded camp away from villages.
- Document and report: Register every entrant, log each decision with reasons, and inform the DGP, Chief Secretary and central agencies by police wireless or any channel.
- Why: It honours the duty to save life, keeps the border under control and leaves their status to the Union Government; temporary humanitarian admission is not asylum.
(d) Extra precautions with soldiers in uniform
- Disarm at the line: Admit them only after they surrender weapons and ammunition; search each person, seal the arms, and refuse anyone who will not disarm.
- Verify identity: A uniform proves nothing: check for deserters or rebels in disguise and hand them to intelligence agencies.
- Segregate and guard: Hold them apart from the civilians under strong guard, as neutral states interned foreign troops under Hague Convention V (1907).
- Avoid escalation and treat humanely: Use restraint, watch for pursuit across the border, give medical care, and return no one without the Union's decision.
Humanity and security are not rivals at the border. By saving lives first, controlling risk rigorously and leaving policy to the Union, Ashok acts as an officer of a civilised state: firm about its sovereignty and faithful to the constitutional promise that every human life matters.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Article 21
- OfficialNational Human Rights Commission v. State of Arunachal Pradesh, Supreme Court of India (1996)
- OfficialForeigners Act, 1946 and Passport (Entry into India) Act, 1920; Immigration and Foreigners Act, 2025 (in force 1 September 2025)
- OfficialHague Convention V (1907) respecting the Rights and Duties of Neutral Powers and Persons in case of War on Land
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2025
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.