EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2013GS Paper 3Q10 · 10 marksEconomyModel answer

Discuss the rationale for introducing Goods and Services Tax (GST) in India. Bring out critically the reasons for the delay in roll out for its regime.

DirectiveDiscuss / Bring out critically
Marks10
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 3
What the examiner wants

Explain the economic case for replacing the existing indirect taxes with GST, and then analyse, with the actual Centre–state disputes, why its rollout kept being postponed.

Common trap: Weak answers say GST is 'one nation one tax'. A top answer explains cascading and the multiplicity of levies, the destination principle, then names the real causes of delay: states' revenue and autonomy fears, unpaid CST compensation, inclusion of petroleum and alcohol, the dispute settlement authority and the Constitution amendment needed.

SyllabusIndian Economy and issues relating to planning, mobilization of resources, growth, development and employment.

Model answer

10 marks · 200-word limit

India's indirect taxes in 2013 were split between the Centre (excise, service tax, customs duties) and the states (VAT, central sales tax, entry tax, octroi, luxury and entertainment taxes). The Goods and Services Tax, first proposed by the Kelkar Task Force in 2004 and promised for April 2010, would replace most of them with a dual, destination-based tax on value added.

Present system (2013)
  • Many Central and state levies
  • Tax on tax: cascading
  • Central sales tax on inter-state trade
  • Check-posts and entry taxes
vs
Proposed GST
  • Dual CGST plus SGST
  • Full input tax credit
  • IGST on inter-state supply
  • One common national market
Indirect tax regime: present versus GST

Rationale for GST

  • End cascading: Credit for excise cannot be set off against VAT and vice versa, and CST is non-creditable, so tax is paid on tax and prices rise.
  • Common market: Inter-state taxes and check-posts fragment the economy; a uniform GST would cut logistics costs and waiting time at borders.
  • Wider base: Taxing goods and services together removes classification disputes and brings more of the services economy into the net.
  • Compliance and growth: A self-policing input credit chain reduces evasion, and studies commissioned by the Thirteenth Finance Commission expected a gain in GDP and exports.

Reasons for the delay

  • Revenue fears: States, especially manufacturing states such as Gujarat and Tamil Nadu, fear losses from a destination-based tax and want assured compensation.
  • Trust deficit: Arrears of compensation promised when CST was cut from 4% to 2% made states doubt future guarantees.
  • Fiscal autonomy: States see the power to set their own rates as a core federal right; the proposed dispute settlement authority was opposed as an intrusion.
  • Scope: Disagreement over keeping petroleum products, alcohol and tobacco inside or outside GST, and over rates and thresholds.
  • Legal and technical: A constitutional amendment needs two-thirds majorities and ratification by half the states, and the GST Network IT system was only being set up in 2013.

GST is the most important indirect tax reform since independence, and the delay is mainly about cooperative federalism rather than economics. A credible compensation mechanism, a joint Centre-state council and phased inclusion of difficult items can unlock it. (Later: the 101st Amendment of 2016 created the GST Council, and GST began on 1 July 2017.)

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 322 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialThe Constitution (115th Amendment) Bill, 2011 and the Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Finance (2013)
  • OfficialEmpowered Committee of State Finance Ministers, First Discussion Paper on Goods and Services Tax in India (2009)
  • ReportReport of the Task Force on Implementation of the FRBM Act (Kelkar Task Force), 2004 — GST proposal
  • OfficialReport of the Thirteenth Finance Commission (2010–15), chapter on GST

More from GS Paper 3 2013

Q1·10 marks·200 words·Economy
With a consideration towards the strategy of inclusive growth, the new Companies Bill, 2013 has indirectly made CSR a mandatory obligation. Discuss the challenges expected in its implementation in right earnest. Also discuss other provisions in the Bill and…
The Companies Bill, 2013 (passed by Parliament in August 2013, replacing the Companies Act, 1956) made India the first major economy to legislate corporate social…
Read the model answer →
Q2·10 marks·200 words·Economy
What were the reasons for the introduction of Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management (FRBM) Act, 2003? Discuss critically its salient features and their effectiveness.
The FRBM Act, 2003 was India's first statutory fiscal rule. It aimed to bind the Union government to a time-bound path of lower deficits and debt, with transparency,…
Read the model answer →
Q3·10 marks·200 words·Economy
What is the meaning of the term 'tax expenditure'? Taking housing sector as an example, discuss how it influences the budgetary policies of the government.
Tax expenditure is the revenue a government gives up through exemptions, deductions, concessional rates and deferrals in the tax law. It is spending done through the…
Read the model answer →
Q4·10 marks·200 words·Agriculture
Food Security Bill is expected to eliminate hunger and malnutrition in India. Critically discuss various apprehensions in its effective implementation along with the concerns it has generated in WTO.
The National Food Security Bill, enacted in September 2013, converts food from a welfare scheme into a legal right. It covers up to 75% of the rural and 50% of the…
Read the model answer →
Q5·10 marks·200 words·Agriculture
What are the different types of agriculture subsidies given to farmers at the national and at state levels? Critically analyse the agricultural subsidy regime with reference to the distortions created by it.
Indian farm policy since the Green Revolution has relied on cheap inputs and assured output prices to raise production and protect small farmers. The result is a large,…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.