What do you understand by Umpire Decision Review System in Cricket? Discuss its various components. Explain how silicone tape on the edge of a bat may fool the system?
Describe what the review system is and how a review works, explain the science behind each technology, and give the physical reason why a silicone-taped edge can escape detection.
Common trap: This tested science in everyday life, not cricket trivia. A top answer explains the physics of each component (infrared thermal imaging for Hot Spot, sound-wave matching for Snicko, multi-camera triangulation for ball-tracking) and links the silicone tape issue to reduced frictional heat seen by Hot Spot during the 2013 Ashes.
SyllabusScience and Technology- developments and their applications and effects in everyday life.
Model answer
10 marks · 200-word limitThe Umpire Decision Review System, first tried in Test cricket in 2008 and adopted by the ICC in 2009, lets a team challenge an on-field umpire's decision. The third umpire then checks it with broadcast technology, and each team has a limited number of unsuccessful reviews per innings.
- On-field decision given
- Player signals a review (T sign)
- Third umpire checks replays
- Hot Spot and Snicko for edges
- Ball-tracking for lbw
- Decision upheld or reversed
Components of the system
- Television replays: Slow-motion footage from multiple cameras checks catches, run-outs and no-balls.
- Hot Spot: Infrared thermal-imaging cameras detect the heat produced by friction when the ball strikes bat or pad, showing a bright spot.
- Snickometer: A stump microphone's sound wave is matched frame by frame with video to see whether a sound coincides with the ball passing the bat.
- Ball-tracking: Hawk-Eye or Virtual Eye triangulates the ball from several high-speed cameras and predicts its path to judge lbw, with an 'umpire's call' margin.
- Limits: The BCCI opposed universal use because predictions and fine edges are not fully reliable.
How silicone tape may fool the system
- Physics: Hot Spot depends on a visible rise in temperature from friction at the point of contact.
- Effect of silicone: A smooth silicone layer lowers friction and conducts heat poorly, so a faint edge produces too little heat to appear on the infrared image.
- The 2013 Ashes: Reports during the 2013 Ashes suggested that batsmen used silicone tape on bat edges, which raised doubts about Hot Spot; the use of Vaseline was also alleged.
- Remedy: Combining Hot Spot with sound-based Snicko and checking bats reduces the chance of deception.
DRS shows how infrared imaging, acoustics and computer vision support human judgement in everyday life. Its value depends on combining technologies and accepting their error margins rather than treating any single tool as infallible.
Read more — sources
- OfficialICC Standard Test Match Playing Conditions — Appendix: Decision Review System (2013)
- NCERTNCERT Class XI Physics — Ch. 11 Thermal Properties of Matter (heat transfer and radiation)
- NCERTNCERT Class XI Physics — Ch. 5 Laws of Motion (friction)
More from GS Paper 3 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.