Article 244 of the Indian Constitution relates to administration of scheduled areas and tribal areas. Analyse the impact of non-implementation of the provisions of the Fifth schedule on the growth of Left Wing extremism.
Identify the protective provisions of the Fifth Schedule and PESA, show how their non-implementation produced specific grievances among tribals, and trace how Maoists have exploited those grievances, without ignoring other causes.
Common trap: Weak answers list Fifth Schedule features and then LWE facts separately. A top answer draws the causal link: dormant Governor powers and Tribes Advisory Councils, diluted PESA, land alienation and mining leases, forest rights denied, leading to alienation that Maoists convert into support, citing the 2008 Expert Group, the Samatha (1997) and Niyamgiri (2013) judgments.
SyllabusLinkages between development and spread of extremism.
Model answer
10 marks · 200-word limitArticle 244(1) applies the Fifth Schedule to Scheduled Areas in states such as Jharkhand, Chhattisgarh, Odisha, Andhra Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh. It makes the Governor the guardian of tribal interests and, with PESA 1996, promises self-rule and protection of land and resources. Many of these same areas now form the core of the Maoist 'Red Corridor'.
- Fifth Schedule and PESA not enforced
- Land alienation and displacement
- Forest and mineral rights denied
- Exploitation and absent state
- Tribal alienation and anger
- Maoists gain recruits and support
Provisions that were meant to protect
- Governor's powers: The Governor can amend or bar laws in Scheduled Areas and make regulations to prohibit land transfers and control money-lenders, and must report to the President.
- Tribes Advisory Council: A council with three-fourths ST legislators advises on tribal welfare.
- PESA, 1996: Gram sabhas must be consulted on land acquisition and own minor forest produce, with powers over minor minerals, markets and money-lending.
- Judicial backing: The Samatha judgment (1997) barred transfer of tribal land in Scheduled Areas to private miners.
Impact of non-implementation
- Dormant guardians: Governors have rarely used their regulation-making powers, and Tribes Advisory Councils seldom meet.
- Diluted PESA: State laws kept real power with officials, so gram sabhas were bypassed in land acquisition and mining leases.
- Land and displacement: Dams, mines and industry displaced lakhs of tribals with poor rehabilitation, and land was lost through fraud and debt.
- Forest grievances: Restrictions and harassment by forest officials, and slow recognition of claims under the Forest Rights Act, 2006, hurt livelihoods.
- Maoist exploitation: The 2008 Expert Group of the Planning Commission found that such deprivation and the absence of the state let Maoists present themselves as protectors of 'jal, jangal, zameen'.
Balance
- Not the only cause: Maoist violence also has an ideological and organisational logic, and it has targeted development works and tribals themselves.
- Positive signs: The Niyamgiri judgment of 2013 let gram sabhas decide on bauxite mining, showing that consent can be honoured.
The Fifth Schedule is the constitutional answer to the grievances Maoists exploit. Activating the Governor's role and Tribes Advisory Councils, implementing PESA and forest rights in letter and spirit, and fair benefit-sharing from mining can win back trust, alongside firm security action.
Read more — sources
- OfficialConstitution of India — Article 244(1) and the Fifth Schedule
- OfficialPlanning Commission, Report of the Expert Group on Development Challenges in Extremist Affected Areas (2008)
- OfficialPanchayats (Extension to the Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996
- OfficialOrissa Mining Corporation v. Ministry of Environment and Forests, Supreme Court, April 2013 (Niyamgiri)
More from GS Paper 3 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.