Examine the impact of liberalization on companies owned by Indians. Are they competing with the MNCs satisfactorily? Discuss.
Probe the effects of the 1991 reforms on Indian-owned firms with sector examples, and then judge, sector by sector, whether they now compete with multinationals on equal terms.
Common trap: Answers often give a one-sided yes or no. A top answer shows the early shake-out (the Bombay Club, brand sell-outs), the rise of globally competitive sectors (IT, generics, auto components, steel acquisitions) and the sectors where MNCs still dominate (consumer electronics, cars, FMCG), linking the gap to R&D, capital cost and infrastructure.
SyllabusEffects of liberalization on the economy, changes in industrial policy and their effects on industrial growth.
Model answer
10 marks · 200-word limitThe New Industrial Policy of July 1991 abolished most industrial licensing, diluted the MRTP Act and opened India to foreign investment. Indian firms that had grown in a protected market suddenly faced global rivals, and their fortunes since then have varied widely by sector.
- IT services: TCS, Infosys, Wipro
- Generic drugs: Cipla, Dr Reddy's
- Two-wheelers and tractors
- Steel, telecom services
- Consumer electronics and phones
- Passenger cars
- Soft drinks and many FMCG brands
- High-end machinery
Impact of liberalisation on Indian companies
- Initial shock: In 1993 industrialists of the 'Bombay Club' sought a level playing field, fearing MNCs with cheaper capital and stronger brands.
- Sell-outs: Some firms sold brands, as Parle sold Thums Up and Limca to Coca-Cola in 1993.
- Restructuring: Others cut costs, upgraded technology, raised quality to global standards and focused on core businesses.
- Going global: Indian firms became acquirers: Tata Steel bought Corus (2007), Hindalco bought Novelis (2007) and Tata Motors bought Jaguar Land Rover (2008).
- New sectors: IT, telecom, aviation and private banking grew rapidly, creating new Indian champions such as Bharti Airtel and HDFC Bank.
Are they competing satisfactorily?
- Yes, in some fields: Indian IT services and generic pharma compete globally, and Bajaj, Hero and Mahindra hold strong positions in two-wheelers and tractors.
- No, in others: Consumer electronics and mobile phones are led by Samsung, LG and Nokia, and the car market by Maruti Suzuki and Hyundai.
- Structural handicaps: Low R&D spending, high cost of capital, weak infrastructure, power shortages and complex labour and land rules raise costs.
- Policy issues: An inverted duty structure in some goods and slow approvals hurt domestic manufacturers more than importers.
Liberalisation made the best Indian companies more efficient and global, but competitiveness is uneven and concentrated in services and a few industries. Raising R&D, easing factor markets and building infrastructure will decide whether Indian manufacturers can match MNCs across the board.
Read more — sources
- OfficialStatement on Industrial Policy, Government of India, July 1991
- BookUma Kapila (ed.), Indian Economy Since Independence — chapters on industrial policy and liberalisation
- BookRamesh Singh, Indian Economy — chapter on industry and economic reforms
More from GS Paper 3 2013
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.