Should the pursuit of carbon credits and clean development mechanisms set up under UNFCCC be maintained even though there has been a massive slide in the value of a carbon credit? Discuss with respect to India’s energy needs for economic growth.
Explain why carbon credit prices collapsed, weigh the case for and against India continuing to pursue CDM and carbon credits, and tie the verdict to India's need for growing, affordable energy.
Common trap: Many answers just define CDM. A top answer explains the price crash (EU ETS oversupply, recession, weak Kyoto second period), argues that CDM's value for India lies beyond credit prices (technology, finance, MRV capacity), links it to domestic market tools such as PAT and RECs, and stays honest about India's coal-based growth needs.
SyllabusConservation, environmental pollution and degradation, environmental impact assessment; Infrastructure: Energy.
Model answer
12.5 marks · 200-word limitThe Clean Development Mechanism (Article 12, Kyoto Protocol) lets projects in developing countries earn Certified Emission Reductions (CERs) that developed countries buy to meet their targets. India became the second-largest host of CDM projects after China, but CER prices collapsed from over €10 in 2008 to well under one euro by 2012–13, raising the question of whether the effort is still worth it.
- Low-carbon technology and finance
- Co-benefits: cleaner air, efficiency
- Builds MRV and carbon-market skills
- Readiness for future global markets
- Credit prices near zero
- Weak demand after 2012
- High transaction costs
- Coal still needed for growth
Why credit values crashed
- Oversupply: The EU Emissions Trading Scheme, the main buyer, was flooded with allowances after the 2008 recession cut industrial output.
- Policy limits: From 2013 the EU accepted new CERs mainly from least developed countries, and the Kyoto second commitment period (Doha, 2012) saw weak participation after Canada's withdrawal and Japan and Russia staying out.
- Credibility doubts: Questions over additionality, especially in HFC-23 projects, reduced buyer confidence.
Why India should still stay engaged
- Beyond price: CDM brought finance and technology to wind, solar, biomass, waste-heat recovery and efficient cement and steel, which also cut fuel bills.
- Energy security: Every unit saved or generated from renewables reduces dependence on imported coal, oil and gas, supporting the National Solar Mission (2010).
- Domestic markets: Skills built under CDM support India's own instruments: Perform, Achieve and Trade (PAT) energy-saving certificates and Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs), and the clean energy cess on coal (2010).
- Negotiating position: Active participation strengthens India's claim, under common but differentiated responsibilities, that developed countries must finance mitigation.
Balancing with India's growth needs
- Development first: With low per-capita emissions and many households still without reliable electricity, India cannot cap total emissions; coal will remain the base load for years.
- Smart approach: India should pursue only projects with real co-benefits, cut paperwork costs, and use credits as a bonus rather than the main reason for clean investment.
Carbon credits should be treated as a tool, not a goal: India should keep using market mechanisms where they bring technology and efficiency, while pushing for strong global demand in the post-2020 regime. (Later, Article 6 of the Paris Agreement of 2015 created successor mechanisms, and India notified a domestic Carbon Credit Trading Scheme in 2023.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialKyoto Protocol to the UNFCCC (1997), Article 12 — Clean Development Mechanism
- OfficialNational Action Plan on Climate Change (2008) — National Mission for Enhanced Energy Efficiency and the Perform, Achieve and Trade scheme
- ReportWorld Bank, State and Trends of Carbon Pricing (2014)
- OfficialUNFCCC, CDM project and CER issuance database (cdm.unfccc.int)
More from GS Paper 3 2014
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.