China and Pakistan have entered into an agreement for development of an economic corridor. What threat does this pose for India’s security? Critically examine.
Set out the security threats the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor poses to India, then test how serious they really are against the corridor's own weaknesses, and end with a reasoned verdict and India's response.
Common trap: Weak answers list threats in one breath. A top answer separates the sovereignty issue (the route through Gilgit-Baltistan in PoK), military-strategic threats (Gwadar, collusion, two-front war) and internal-security risks, then critically notes the corridor's vulnerabilities (Baloch insurgency, Pakistan's finances) and India's counters such as Chabahar.
SyllabusRole of external state and non-state actors in creating challenges to internal security; security challenges and their management in border areas.
Model answer
12.5 marks · 200-word limitChina and Pakistan signed an MoU on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC) in July 2013, planning roads, railways, pipelines and power plants from Kashgar in Xinjiang to the Chinese-run Gwadar port on the Arabian Sea. For India the project is not only economic: it runs through territory India claims and deepens an 'all-weather' strategic partnership on two of its borders.
- Route through Gilgit-Baltistan (PoK)
- Gwadar as possible Chinese naval base
- China-Pakistan two-front collusion
- Chinese stake in Pakistan's stability
- Baloch insurgency and terror risks
- Pakistan's debt and weak economy
- Commercial doubts about Gwadar
- India's Chabahar and INSTC options
Threats to India's security
- Sovereignty: The Karakoram Highway and CPEC pass through Gilgit-Baltistan, part of Jammu and Kashmir that India claims under the 1994 Parliament resolution; Chinese investment there tends to legitimise Pakistan's occupation.
- Chinese presence in PoK: Chinese engineers and security units near the Line of Control create a direct Chinese stake in the Kashmir dispute.
- Maritime encirclement: Gwadar, near the Strait of Hormuz, could host Chinese naval ships and adds to the 'string of pearls' around India with Hambantota and Chittagong.
- Two-front threat: Better road and rail links let China and Pakistan move forces and supplies faster, raising the risk of coordinated pressure on India's western and northern borders.
- Diplomatic shield: With large investments at stake, China is more likely to shield Pakistan in forums such as the UN Security Council's sanctions committee on terrorists.
A critical view
- Vulnerabilities: The Baloch insurgency, attacks in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Pakistan's weak finances may slow or scale down the corridor.
- Economic logic: Much of CPEC is power and road projects for Pakistan's needs; a more stable Pakistan could, in theory, reduce space for extremism.
- Chinese caution: China seeks stability for its investments and may restrain Pakistan from adventurism that disrupts the corridor.
India's response
- Diplomacy: Consistently register objection over the PoK route while keeping dialogue open with China on the boundary and trade.
- Connectivity: Develop Chabahar port in Iran and the International North-South Transport Corridor to reach Afghanistan and Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan.
- Capability: Speed up border roads in Ladakh, strengthen the Navy in the Arabian Sea and deepen ties with the United States, Japan and Iran.
CPEC's threat to India is real but long-term: it challenges India's sovereignty claim and binds China more firmly to Pakistan, though its execution faces serious hurdles. India's best answer is firm diplomacy, its own connectivity projects and stronger defence capability. (Later, CPEC was formally launched with a large investment package in April 2015, and India declined to join China's Belt and Road Forum in 2017.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs, statements on the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor and Jammu & Kashmir (2013–15)
- OfficialParliament of India, Resolution of 22 February 1994 on Jammu & Kashmir
- BookShivshankar Menon, Choices: Inside the Making of India's Foreign Policy (2016)
- BookAndrew Small, The China-Pakistan Axis: Asia's New Geopolitics (2015)
More from GS Paper 3 2014
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.