EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2014GS Paper 3Q19 · 12.5 marksInternal SecurityModel answer

In 2012, the longitudinal marking for high-risk areas for piracy was moved from 65 degrees east to 78 degrees east in the Arabian Sea by the International Maritime Organization. What impact does this have on India’s maritime security concerns?

DirectiveExamine
Marks12.5
Word limit200
PaperGS Paper 3
What the examiner wants

Explain what the High Risk Area for piracy is and what moving its eastern limit to 78°E did, then examine its economic, legal, security and diplomatic consequences for India, and what India should do.

Common trap: Students often describe Somali piracy in general. A top answer focuses on the effect of the 78°E line: India's west coast and Lakshadweep fell inside the High Risk Area, raising insurance costs, bringing armed guards and floating armouries close to India's coast, leading to incidents like the Enrica Lexie case (2012) and the Seaman Guard Ohio detention (2013), and stretching the Navy and Coast Guard.

SyllabusSecurity challenges and their management in border areas; various security forces and agencies and their mandate.

Model answer

12.5 marks · 200-word limit

As Somali pirates, using captured mother ships, struck further east, the shipping industry's Best Management Practices (BMP4, 2011), taken note of at the IMO, extended the piracy High Risk Area (HRA) from 65°E to 78°E. This line brought the entire Arabian Sea up to India's west coast, including Lakshadweep, within the HRA, even though Indian waters themselves had few attacks.

  1. 2008Indian Navy begins Gulf of Aden escort patrols
  2. 2010–11Pirate attacks near Lakshadweep; Operation Island Watch
  3. 2011HRA eastern limit pushed to 78°E
  4. Feb 2012Enrica Lexie guards kill two Kerala fishermen
  5. Oct 2013MV Seaman Guard Ohio held off Tuticorin
  6. 2015 (later)HRA limit rolled back from India's coast
Piracy High Risk Area and India

Economic impact

  • Insurance costs: Ships calling at Indian west-coast ports such as Kochi, Mangaluru and Mumbai had to pay war-risk and piracy premiums, raising freight costs for Indian exports and imports.
  • Port competitiveness: Indian ports and the planned Vizhinjam and Kochi transhipment ambitions looked riskier than Colombo, which lay outside the zone.

Security and legal impact

  • Armed guards near coast: Merchant ships began carrying privately contracted armed security personnel close to India's coast, where they could mistake fishermen for pirates.
  • Enrica Lexie: In February 2012 Italian marines on the tanker Enrica Lexie shot dead two Kerala fishermen, creating a long jurisdiction dispute between India and Italy.
  • Floating armouries: The detention of the MV Seaman Guard Ohio with weapons off Tuticorin in October 2013 showed how unregulated arms were moving into Indian waters, a serious risk after 26/11.
  • Stretched forces: The Navy and Coast Guard had to patrol a vast area while also guarding a coastline vulnerable to terrorist infiltration from the sea.

What India should do

  • Diplomacy: Press the IMO and industry bodies to revise the HRA, since India's coast is well policed and pirate attacks had fallen sharply after 2012.
  • Regulation: Frame rules on armed guards and floating armouries entering Indian waters, and strengthen anti-piracy law, as India had no dedicated statute.
  • Capacity: Expand maritime domain awareness through coastal radar chains, AIS tracking for fishing boats, and cooperation with Maldives, Sri Lanka and Seychelles.

The 78°E line treated India's waters as if they were Somali waters, raising trade costs and importing armed risks to its coast. Through sustained diplomacy and stronger maritime surveillance India can show it is a net security provider in the Indian Ocean. (Later, the HRA limit was rolled back from India's coast from December 2015.)

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 340 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 200-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialBest Management Practices for Protection against Somalia Based Piracy, Version 4 (BMP4), 2011 — High Risk Area definition
  • OfficialInternational Maritime Organization, Maritime Safety Committee circulars on privately contracted armed security personnel (2011–12)
  • OfficialIndian Navy, Indian Maritime Doctrine (2009) and Ministry of Defence Annual Reports
  • OfficialSupreme Court of India, Republic of Italy v. Union of India (2013) — Enrica Lexie case

More from GS Paper 3 2014

Q1·12.5 marks·200 words·Economy
Normally countries shift from agriculture to industry and then later to services, but India shifted directly from agriculture to services. What are the reasons for the huge growth of services vis-à-vis industry in the country? Can India become a developed…
The classic Clark-Fisher path runs from agriculture to industry to services, as in Britain, Japan or China. India broke this sequence: services now produce well over…
Read the model answer →
Q2·12.5 marks·200 words·Economy
“While we flaunt India’s demographic dividend, we ignore the dropping rates of employability.” What are we missing while doing so? Where will the jobs that India desperately needs come from? Explain.
India has one of the youngest populations in the world, with a median age under 30 and roughly a million people entering the working-age group every month. But a…
Read the model answer →
Q3·12.5 marks·200 words·Agriculture, Economy
There is also a point of view that Agricultural Produce Market Committees (APMCs) set up under the State Acts have not only impeded the development of agriculture but also have been the cause of food inflation in India. Critically examine.
Agricultural Produce Market Committees were created under State APMC Acts from the 1960s to replace exploitative village trading with regulated mandis, open auctions…
Read the model answer →
Q4·12.5 marks·200 words·Agriculture, Economy
“In the villages itself no form of credit organization will be suitable except the cooperative society.” —All India Rural Credit Survey. Discuss this statement in the background of agricultural finance in India. What constraints and challenges do financial…
The All India Rural Credit Survey (1954), led by A.D. Gorwala, found that moneylenders and traders supplied most rural credit. It concluded that cooperation had failed…
Read the model answer →
Q5·12.5 marks·200 words·Economy, Agriculture
The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 has come into effect from 1st January, 2014. What are the key issues which would get addressed with the Act in place? What implications would it…
The colonial Land Acquisition Act, 1894 allowed the state to take land for a vaguely defined public purpose at low circle rates, with no duty to rehabilitate those…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.