National Urban Transport Policy emphasises on ‘moving people’ instead of ‘moving vehicles’. Discuss critically the success of the various strategies of the Government in this regard.
Explain what 'moving people, not vehicles' means under the 2006 policy, assess each government strategy on evidence of success and failure, and give a verdict with corrective steps.
Common trap: Weak answers list metro projects as success. A top answer judges strategies against the policy's own goal of modal shift, contrasting Ahmedabad's Janmarg with Delhi's BRT, noting flyover-centric spending, weak bus fleets and absent Unified Metropolitan Transport Authorities.
SyllabusInfrastructure: Energy, Ports, Roads, Airports, Railways etc.
Model answer
12.5 marks · 200-word limitThe National Urban Transport Policy (NUTP), 2006 asked cities to plan for people rather than cars: equitable road space, public transport, walking and cycling, integrated land use and transport, and parking charges that reflect land value. Its success can be judged by whether the share of public and non-motorised transport has risen.
- Metro rail networks
- Bus Rapid Transit
- JNNURM city buses
- Walking and cycling space
- Parking and pricing policy
- Unified Metropolitan Transport Authority
Strategies and their successes
- Metro rail: Delhi Metro, opened in 2002, carries millions daily and has inspired metros in Bengaluru, Mumbai, Jaipur and Chennai, after Kolkata's pioneering 1984 line.
- BRTS: Ahmedabad's Janmarg (2009) won international recognition for dedicated lanes, level boarding and integrated fares.
- Bus funding: JNNURM financed thousands of modern low-floor buses for cities, improving fleet quality.
- Planning tools: Comprehensive Mobility Plans and the World Bank-GEF Sustainable Urban Transport Project built capacity in pilot cities.
Where the strategies fell short
- Car-centric spending: Flyovers, road widening and elevated corridors still absorb large budgets, inducing more private traffic.
- Private vehicle boom: Two-wheeler and car registrations grew far faster than bus fleets, and the bus share of trips declined in many cities.
- Delhi BRT: Poor design and opposition from motorists led to the corridor's dismantling (2016), discrediting BRT in public debate.
- Metro gaps: Weak last-mile connectivity and high fares have kept ridership on several lines below projections.
- Pedestrians ignored: Footpaths are encroached and cycle tracks rare, though most poor commuters walk or cycle.
- Fragmented governance: Few cities created a Unified Metropolitan Transport Authority, so metro, bus, traffic police and municipal roads work in silos.
What needs to be done
- Integration: Common ticketing, feeder buses and transit-oriented development around stations.
- Demand management: Realistic parking charges, congestion pricing and road space reallocated to buses and walkers.
NUTP set the right goal, but implementation has favoured visible infrastructure over modal shift. Later initiatives such as the Smart Cities Mission (2015), the Metro Rail Policy (2017) and the Transit Oriented Development Policy (2017) must be judged by one test: more people moving by bus, metro, foot and bicycle.
Read more — sources
- OfficialMinistry of Urban Development, National Urban Transport Policy, 2006
- OfficialJawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM), 2005 — guidelines and bus funding scheme
- OfficialPlanning Commission, Twelfth Five Year Plan — Urban Transport chapter; High Powered Expert Committee on Urban Infrastructure (Isher Ahluwalia), 2011
More from GS Paper 3 2014
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.