Discuss how national security can be balanced with concerns of human rights.
150 words, 10 marks. Define the concept precisely, then apply it to the situation — Ethics rewards the application, not the definition.
Common trap: A generic 'both are important' answer scores poorly. The proportionality test is the specific machinery the question is fishing for — name its limbs.
Model answer
166 words · 150-word limitThe two are usually posed as a trade-off, but security exists in order to protect rights — so a practice that destroys rights has defeated its own purpose.
The tension is genuine. Security demands secrecy, speed and discretion; rights demand transparency, due process and review. Preventive detention and surveillance concentrate discretionary power, and emergency reasoning tends to outlive the emergency.
The framework is largely settled. Article 21's due process after Maneka Gandhi (1978) and judicial review supply the floor, while the proportionality test from Puttaswamy supplies the method — legitimate aim, rational connection, necessity, and balancing. Parliamentary oversight, the NHRC, independent review of detentions and sunset clauses keep exceptional powers exceptional.
Ethically, rights operate as side-constraints rather than interests to be traded — a floor beneath which utility may not reach.
Balance is therefore a discipline, not a midpoint: the least rights-restrictive measure achieving a legitimate aim, subject to review. A state adopting its adversaries' methods forfeits the moral authority that is itself a security asset.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide
Open with: The two are usually posed as a trade-off, but the deeper claim is that security exists to protect rights — so a security practice that destroys rights has defeated its own purpose.
Why the tension is real
- Security requires secrecy, speed and discretion; rights require transparency, due process and review
- Preventive detention, surveillance and special laws such as AFSPA and UAPA concentrate discretionary power
- Emergency reasoning tends to become permanent — exceptional powers outlive the exception
The framework for balance
- Constitutional: Article 21's due process after Maneka Gandhi (1978); Articles 22 and 359 limits; judicial review as the residual check
- Proportionality test from Puttaswamy — legitimate aim, rational connection, necessity, and balancing
- Institutional: parliamentary oversight, NHRC, independent review of detentions, sunset clauses on special powers
- Santhanam and later committees on accountability; Supreme Court guidelines in D.K. Basu on arrest
Ethical grounding
- Rights as side-constraints, not merely interests to be traded — a floor below which utility cannot reach
- Rule of law as the distinguishing feature between a state and its adversaries
- Means-ends: a state that adopts its opponents' methods forfeits its moral authority, which is itself a security asset
Draw: A proportionality ladder — aim, connection, necessity, balancing — with an example measure tested at each rung.
Close with: Balance is not a midpoint between two goods but a discipline: the least rights-restrictive measure that achieves a legitimate security aim, subject to review.
Read more — sources
- termProportionality · Side-constraints · Due process · Sunset clause
- thinkerRobert Nozick — rights as side-constraints; Isaiah Berlin — negative liberty
- EdiShorts appMains GS-4 — Ethics: Rights & the State
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2026
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.