Case study: There is a technological company named ABC Incorporated which is the second largest worldwide, situated in the Third World.
Answer all four sub-parts in order: an immediate response, a discussion of the ethical issues from several angles, a reasoned case for the penalty, and concrete measures that balance innovation with the environment.
Common trap: Many answers argue against the penalty or treat it as a public-relations problem. A top answer reads part (c) as accepting accountability, uses polluter pays and fairness arguments, and names the CEO's own conflict of interest as majority shareholder.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; accountability and ethical governance; corporate governance.)
The case
There is a technological company named ABC Incorporated which is the second largest worldwide, situated in the Third World. You are the Chief Executive Officer and the majority shareholder of this company. The fast technological improvements have raised worries among environmental activists, regulatory authorities, and the general public over the sustainability of this scenario. You confront substantial issues about the business’s environmental footprint. In 2023, your organization had a significant increase of 48% in greenhouse gas emissions compared to the levels recorded in 2019. The significant rise in energy consumption is mainly due to the surging energy requirements of your data centers, fuelled by the exponential expansion of Artificial Intelligence (AI). AI-powered services need much more computational resources and electrical energy compared to conventional online activities, notwithstanding their notable gains. The technology’s proliferation has led to a growing concern over the environmental repercussions, resulting in an increase in warnings. AI models, especially those used in extensive machine learning and data processing, exhibit much greater energy consumption than conventional computer tasks, with an exponential increase. Although there is already a commitment and goal to achieve net zero emissions by 2030, the challenge of lowering emissions seems overwhelming as the integration of AI continues to increase. To achieve this goal, substantial investments in renewable energy use would be necessary. The difficulty is exacerbated by the competitive environment of the technology sector, where rapid innovation is essential for preserving market standing and shareholders’ worth. To achieve a balance between innovation, profitability and sustainability, a strategic move is necessary that is in line with both, business objectives and ethical obligations. (a) What is your immediate response to the challenges posed in the above case? (b) Discuss the ethical issues involved in the above case. (c) Your company has been identified to be penalized by technological giants. What logical and ethical arguments will you put forth to convince about its necessity? (d) Being a conscience being, what measures would you adopt to maintain balance between AI innovation and environmental footprint?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitThe Brundtland Report (1987) defined sustainable development as meeting present needs without compromising those of future generations. A 48% rise in ABC's emissions between 2019 and 2023, against a net-zero pledge for 2030, shows its AI-led growth is borrowing against that future.
- Exponential expansion of AI services
- Far more compute per task than conventional computing
- Surging data-centre energy demand
- 48% rise in emissions, 2019 to 2023
- Net-zero 2030 pledge and public trust at risk
(a) Immediate response
- Own the problem: Publicly acknowledge the 48% rise, and restate the 2030 commitment with a dated, independently verified roadmap.
- Board-level oversight: Set up a sustainability committee of the board that must clear the energy and emissions cost of every major AI launch.
- Quick wins: Order an energy audit of all data centres and shift flexible AI training loads to hours and regions with cleaner power.
- Engage and disclose: Meet activists and regulators, and report Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions annually under the GHG Protocol.
(b) Ethical issues involved
- Profit versus planet: Milton Friedman's 1970 view that a firm's social responsibility is to increase its profits clashes with R. Edward Freeman's stakeholder theory, which counts communities and the environment as stakeholders.
- Integrity of commitments: A net-zero pledge that quietly drifts becomes greenwashing; the gap between word and deed erodes trust.
- Conflict of interest: As majority shareholder, I gain personally from rapid growth, which can bias me against costly emission cuts.
- Intergenerational and global justice: Hans Jonas's ethic of responsibility asks us to weigh effects on future generations; climate harm also falls hardest on the poorer Third World societies where ABC is based.
(c) Arguments for the necessity of the penalty
- Polluter pays: Emissions impose costs on others; a penalty internalises that externality, the principle the Supreme Court of India accepted in Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum (1996).
- Level playing field: If the second largest firm escapes, rivals will race to the bottom; a uniform rule rewards efficient players and makes clean investment rational.
- Long-term value: Pressure to shift to renewables cuts future energy costs and regulatory risk, which protects shareholders' worth.
- Universalisability and fairness: By Kant's test, a rule exempting big emitters cannot be willed for all; by Rawls's difference principle, shifting climate costs onto the least advantaged is unjust.
(d) Balancing AI innovation and environmental footprint
- Efficient by design: Prefer smaller, task-specific and compressed models, and track energy per query as a key metric alongside accuracy.
- Clean power and cooling: Sign long-term renewable power purchase agreements with storage, site new data centres near clean supply, and set targets for power usage effectiveness and water use.
- Internal carbon price: Apply a shadow price on carbon to every new AI project and link executive pay, including mine, to verified emission targets.
Innovation that consumes the future cannot be called progress. As CEO and majority owner, I have both the power and the duty to prove that AI leadership and net zero can coexist, turning a penalty into a turning point and a pledge into practice.
Read more — sources
- ReportWorld Commission on Environment and Development, Our Common Future (Brundtland Report), 1987
- BookWRI and WBCSD, The Greenhouse Gas Protocol: A Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard
- OfficialVellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India, Supreme Court of India (1996)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2024
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.