EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2024GS Paper 4 (Ethics)Q16 · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Case study: With multipronged strategy of the Central and State Governments specially in the last few years, the naxalite problem has been resolved to a large…

DirectiveCase study
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

List Rohit's options with merits and demerits, name the competing values, defend one course with reasons, and give specific precautions for women protesters; all four sub-parts must be answered.

Common trap: Answers often jump to release or to firing. A top answer rejects both extremes, combines securing the captives with de-escalation, and gives accurate legal safeguards for women under the BNSS rather than generic advice.

SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance.)

The case

With multipronged strategy of the Central and State Governments specially in the last few years, the naxalite problem has been resolved to a large extent in the affected states of the country. However, there are a few pockets in certain states where naxalite problem still persists, mainly due to involvement of foreign countries. Rohit is posted as SP (Special Operations) for the last one year, in one of the districts which is still affected by the naxalite problem. The district administration has taken a lot of developmental works in the recent past in the naxalite affected areas to win the hearts and minds of the people. Over a period of time, Rohit has established an excellent intelligence network to get the real time information regarding the movement of naxalite cadre. To instill confidence in the public and have moral ascendancy over the naxalites, a number of cordons and search operations are being conducted by the police. Rohit, who himself was leading one of the contingents got a message though his intelligence source that about ten hard core naxalites were hiding in a particular village with sophisticated weapons. Without wasting any time, Rohit reached the target village with his team and laid out a foolproof cordon and started carrying out a systematic search. During the search, his team managed to overpower all the naxalites along with their automatic weapons. However, in the meantime, more than five hundred tribal women surrounded the village and started marching towards the target house. They were shouting and demanding the immediate release of insurgents since they are their protectors and saviours. The situation on the ground was becoming very critical as the tribal women were extremely agitated and aggressive. Rohit tried to contact his superior officer, IG (Special Operations) of the state on the radio set and on mobile phone, but failed to do so due to poor connectivity. Rohit was in great dilemma since out of the naxalites apprehended, two were not only hard core top insurgents with prize money of ₹ ten lakhs on their heads, but were also involved in a recent ambush on the security forces. However, if he did not release the naxalites, the situation could get out of control since the tribal women were aggressively charging towards them. In that case, to control the situation Rohit might have to resort to firing which may lead to valuable loss of lives of civilians and would further complicate the situation. (a) What are the options available with Rohit to cope with the situation? (b) What are the ethical dilemmas being faced by Rohit? (c) Which of the options, do you think, would be more appropriate for Rohit to adopt and why? (d) In the present situation, what are the extra precautionary measures to be taken by the police in dealing with women protesters?

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

Rohit's cordon has succeeded; its worth now depends on handling over five hundred agitated tribal women. The UN Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (1990) permit lethal force only when strictly unavoidable to protect life.

Enforcing the law
  • Ten hard-core naxalites and automatic weapons seized
  • Two top insurgents linked to a recent ambush
  • Release would demoralise the force
  • Mob pressure must not override law
vs
Protecting life and trust
  • Over 500 agitated tribal women
  • Firing risks civilian casualties
  • Women see the captives as protectors
  • Hearts-and-minds development work at stake
The two duties pulling at Rohit

(a) Options available with Rohit

OptionMeritsDemerits
1. Release the naxalitesEnds the stand-off at onceSurrenders law to a crowd; frees ambush accused; demoralises the force
2. Open fire to disperse the crowdRetains the captivesCivilian deaths; a propaganda gift to the naxalites
3. Hold the captives securely and de-escalate through dialogue and restraintKeeps both the arrests and livesSlow; risky if the crowd turns violent
4. Move the captives out by the safest route while part of the team engages the crowdAvoids direct confrontationRisk of ambush or snatching in transit

(b) Ethical dilemmas faced by Rohit

  • Rule of law versus right to life: Releasing the captives defeats justice; firing on protesting women violates the sanctity of life.
  • Duty to colleagues versus compassion: He owes justice to the forces hit in the ambush, yet the women are citizens, not enemies.
  • Means versus ends: Gandhi held that means and ends are as inseparable as seed and tree; an arrest bought with civilian blood would be a moral failure.
  • Initiative versus hierarchy: Having failed to reach the IG (Special Operations) by both radio and mobile, he must decide alone and own the outcome.

(c) Most appropriate option and why

  • Combine options 3 and 4: Secure the two top insurgents first, keep trying to reach other contingents, and move the captives out under escort when feasible.
  • De-escalate: Speak to the women through women personnel, village elders or local representatives, explaining that the arrested will be produced before a magistrate within 24 hours under Article 22(2).
  • Graduated force only: Warnings and barricades first; firearms only if lives face imminent danger.
  • Why: It upholds law and life, respects proportionality and avoids casualties that would undo the development effort.

(d) Extra precautions with women protesters

  • Women personnel: Use women police for any physical handling; a woman may be searched only by a woman, with strict regard to decency, under Section 49(2) of the BNSS, 2023.
  • Arrest safeguards: Under Section 43 of the BNSS, a male officer shall not touch a woman to arrest her unless circumstances require, and save in exceptional circumstances, with a Judicial Magistrate's prior permission, no woman is arrested between sunset and sunrise.
  • Record and follow up: Videograph the operation, keep medical aid ready, and take up the women's grievances through the district administration.

Where naxalism persists, the battle is for legitimacy as much as territory. By keeping both his captives and his restraint, Rohit shows a firm yet humane state, the surest way to wean tribal communities away from those they now call protectors and saviours.

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 446 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialUN Basic Principles on the Use of Force and Firearms by Law Enforcement Officials (1990)
  • OfficialConstitution of India — Article 22; Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (Sections 43 and 49; earlier CrPC Sections 46 and 51)
  • ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 5th Report — Public Order (2007)

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2024

Q1·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Q1(a) The application of Artificial Intelligence as a dependable source of input for administrative rational decision-making is a debatable issue. Critically examine the statement from the ethical point of view.
Herbert Simon showed that administrators work under bounded rationality, with limited information, time and attention. AI promises to widen those limits, but raises an…
Read the model answer →
Q2·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Q1(b) “Ethics encompasses several key dimensions that are crucial in guiding individuals and organizations towards morally responsible behaviour.” Explain the key dimensions of ethics that influence human actions. Discuss how these dimensions shape ethical…
Ethics is the study of right conduct and good character. It is not a single rule but a set of dimensions, from the intention behind an act and its consequences to the…
Read the model answer →
Q3·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Q2(a) “It is not enough to talk about peace, one must believe in it; and it is not enough to believe in it, one must act upon it.” In the present context, the major weapon industries of the developed nations are adversely influencing continuation of number…
The line, usually attributed to Eleanor Roosevelt, says peace needs talk, belief and action together. Today the states that speak most of peace also sell most weapons.…
Read the model answer →
Q4·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Q2(b) Global warming and climate change are the outcomes of human greed in the name of development, indicating the direction in which extinction of organisms including human beings is heading towards loss of life on Earth. How do you put an end to this to…
The IPCC's Sixth Assessment (2023) found that human activity has already warmed the planet by about 1.1°C over pre-industrial levels, and the IPBES (2019) warned that…
Read the model answer →
Q5·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Q3(a) Given below are three quotations of great thinkers. What do each of these quotations convey to you in the present context? “Learn everything that is good from others, but bring it in, and in your own way absorb it, do not become others.” — Swami…
Swami Vivekananda, who carried Vedanta to the West at the Chicago Parliament of Religions in 1893, was an advocate of openness without imitation. The quotation asks us…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.