Case study: Sneha is a Senior Manager working for a big reputed hospital chain in a mid-sized city.
Identify the stakeholders and the ethical issues, weigh the realistic options, and defend one course with concrete steps; each printed sub-part (a), (b), (c) must be answered on its own.
Common trap: Many answers either hand the contract to the brother or bar him outright. Top answers use the case's own premise (no lowest-bid rule, full management trust) to show why disclosure, recusal and pre-fixed criteria matter more, and tie part (c) to patients, not just procurement.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; corporate governance.)
The case
Sneha is a Senior Manager working for a big reputed hospital chain in a mid-sized city. She has been made in-charge of the new super speciality center that the hospital is building with state-of-the art equipment and world class medical facilities. The building has been reconstructed and she is starting the process of procurement for various equipment and machines. As the head of the committee responsible for procurement, she has invited bids from all the interested reputed vendors dealing in medical equipment. She notices that her brother, who is a well-known supplier in this domain, has also sent his expression of interest. Since the hospital is privately owned, it is not mandatory for her to select only the lower bidder. Also, she is aware that her brother’s company has been facing some financial difficulties and a big supply order will help him recover. At the same time, allocating the contract to her brother might bring charges of favouritism against her and tarnish her image. The hospital management trusts her fully and would support any decision of hers. (a) What should be Sneha’s course of action? (b) How would she justify what she chooses to do? (c) In this case, how is medical ethics compromised with vested personal interest?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitSneha faces a potential conflict of interest in its purest form: because the hospital is private, no lowest-bid rule binds her, and management will back whatever she decides. With external checks absent, the only safeguard left is her own integrity, which Plato's Ring of Gyges test captures: what would she do if no one could ever find out?
- Brother's expression of interest arrives
- Sneha discloses the relationship in writing
- Recuses from evaluating and awarding this contract
- Committee fixes quality-cum-cost criteria beforehand
- Merit-based award, reasons recorded
(a) Sneha's course of action
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Award the order to her brother | Helps him recover from his financial difficulties | Favouritism; abuse of the trust management has placed in her |
| Reject her brother outright | Removes any suspicion | Unfair to a well-known supplier; reverse bias |
| Disclose, recuse and let a neutral committee decide on merit | Fair to all vendors; protects her image and the hospital | She gives up control of a key part of her own project |
- Disclose at once: Inform management in writing that a bidder is her brother, before any bid is evaluated.
- Recuse: Step away from evaluation, negotiation and award of the contracts he bids for; ask management to nominate another senior officer to lead those decisions.
- Fix criteria first: Since lowest price is not mandatory, the committee should lock in weighted criteria (quality, specifications, after-sales service, price) before bids are opened, and record reasons for the final choice.
- No contact: Avoid discussing the procurement with her brother until the award is made.
(b) How she would justify her choice
- Trust is a duty, not a licence: The management's full trust makes her a fiduciary of the hospital; unchecked discretion demands more care, not less.
- Fairness to all: Recusal lets her brother compete on equal terms instead of being excluded or favoured, so other reputed vendors also get a level field.
- Kant's universalisability test: A rule that every manager may steer contracts to relatives could not be accepted by anyone, including her.
- Protecting reputation: It averts the charge of favouritism she rightly fears, and any order her brother wins on merit stays above question.
(c) How medical ethics is compromised by vested interest
- Patient welfare (beneficence and non-maleficence): Choosing machines to rescue a relative's firm rather than for reliability puts patients of a super-speciality centre at risk.
- Justice: Overpriced equipment raises the cost of treatment that patients ultimately pay.
- Trust in the institution: Patients assume that every decision in a hospital, down to equipment, is made in their interest; favouritism breaks that unspoken promise.
- Institutional culture: One favour from the top signals that commercial ties can override care, and others soon follow.
Private ownership removes the lowest-bid rule, not the duty of fairness. By disclosing and recusing, Sneha honours both her family and her profession: her brother gets a fair chance rather than a favour, and patients get equipment chosen solely for their care. That is integrity when no one is checking.
Read more — sources
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report — Ethics in Governance (2007)
- BookTom L. Beauchamp and James F. Childress, Principles of Biomedical Ethics
- BookPlato, The Republic, Book II (the Ring of Gyges)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2024
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.