Case study: With the summer heat being exceptionally severe this year, the district has been facing severe water shortage.
Identify the stakeholders and the ethical issues, weigh the realistic options, and defend one course with concrete steps; each printed sub-part (a), (b), (c) must be answered on its own.
Common trap: The case rules out closing the industry, so answers built around closure miss the point. Examiners reward priority-based rationing that covers industry as well, joint verification that answers the bribery charge, and separate treatment of options, compatible actions and dilemmas.
SyllabusCase Studies on above issues. (Public/Civil service values and Ethics in Public administration: ethical concerns and dilemmas in government and private institutions; laws, rules, regulations and conscience as sources of ethical guidance; accountability and ethical governance; corporate governance.)
The case
With the summer heat being exceptionally severe this year, the district has been facing severe water shortage. The District Collector has been mobilizing his subordinate officials to conserve the remaining water reserves for preventing the district from plunging into acute drinking water crisis. Along with an awareness campaign for conserving water, strict measures have been taken for stopping the over-exploitation of ground-water. Vigilance teams have been deployed to tour the villages and find the farmers who are drawing water from deep borewells or from the river reservoir for irrigation. The farmers are agitated by such action. A delegation of farmers meets the District Collector with their issues and complains that while they are not being allowed to irrigate their crops, big industries located near the river are drawing huge amounts of water through deep borewells for their industrial processes. The farmers allege that their administration is anti-farmer and corrupt, being bribed by the industry. The district needs to placate the farmers as they are threatening to go on a prolonged protest. At the same time, the District Collector has to deal with the water crisis. The industry cannot be closed as this would result in a large number of workers being unemployed. (a) Discuss all options available to the District Collector as a District Magistrate. (b) What suitable actions can be taken in view of mutually compatible interests of the stakeholders? (c) What are the potential administrative and ethical dilemmas for the District Collector?
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitIn a drought summer the District Collector is trustee of a shared resource: drinking water comes first, yet farmers, industry and workers all have legitimate claims. Restrictions enforced only on farmers while industries keep pumping deep borewells are unfair and lend weight to the charge of corruption.
- Drinking water for all residents
- Farmers' standing crops
- Industries near the river
- Industrial workers' jobs
- Groundwater for future seasons
- Credibility of the administration
(a) Options available to the Collector as District Magistrate
| Option | Merits | Demerits |
|---|---|---|
| Continue curbs on farmers alone | Quick saving of groundwater and reservoir water | Discriminatory; fuels the protest and the bribery allegation |
| Accept farmers' demand and lift curbs | Ends the agitation | Reservoir and aquifers may fail before drinking needs are met |
| Uniform, priority-based rationing covering industry too | Lawful, equitable, saves water | Needs metering, monitoring and resolve against powerful units |
| Prohibitory orders to handle the protest | Maintains public order | Treats a just grievance as a law-and-order problem |
- Legal tools: Orders under Section 163 of the BNSS, 2023 (formerly Section 144 CrPC) against unauthorised extraction, emergency measures through the District Disaster Management Authority he chairs under the Disaster Management Act, 2005, and checks of industries' groundwater permissions.
(b) Actions serving mutually compatible interests
- Drinking water first: Publicly notify the order of priority: drinking water, then limited irrigation for standing crops, then industrial use.
- Audit the industries: Joint teams with farmer representatives verify industrial borewells, permissions and meters; cap drawals, enforce recycling and seal unauthorised wells.
- Regulated irrigation: Time-slotted releases from the reservoir for standing crops, with promotion of drip irrigation and less water-intensive crops.
- Keep industry running: Since closure would cost many jobs, impose graded cuts and require water reuse instead of shutting units.
- Inquiry and dialogue: Order an impartial inquiry into the bribery allegation and hold weekly meetings with farmers, industry and workers, publishing extraction data.
(c) Administrative and ethical dilemmas
- Livelihood against livelihood: Farmers' crops compete with workers' jobs; neither can be sacrificed.
- Equality before law: Applying curbs to farmers but not industry offends the equality guaranteed by Article 14 and the duty of impartiality.
- Loyalty versus accountability: Probing corruption among his own officials may demoralise the team, but ignoring it destroys public trust.
- Firmness versus compassion: Enforcing restrictions on distressed farmers without appearing anti-farmer.
- Present versus future: Relief now versus protecting aquifers for coming summers.
The Collector's authority rests on even-handedness: one rule for every user, applied openly and verified jointly. Priority-based rationing, audited industrial use and an honest inquiry can secure drinking water, save standing crops and keep factories running, turning a confrontation into shared stewardship of the district's water.
Read more — sources
- OfficialBharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 — Section 163; Disaster Management Act, 2005
- OfficialCentral Ground Water Authority — Guidelines to regulate and control ground water extraction in India (2020)
- OfficialMinistry of Agriculture and Farmers Welfare — Manual for Drought Management (2016)
- ReportSecond Administrative Reforms Commission, 4th Report — Ethics in Governance (2007)
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2024
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.