Some moral philosophers argue that spending some of your resources — without significantly affecting your financial stability — to help other people who badly suffer is our moral duty and not merely a matter of charity. Justify this claim by explaining the distinction between duty and charity.
150 words, 10 marks. Define the concept precisely, then apply it to the situation — Ethics rewards the application, not the definition.
Common trap: 'Justify this claim' means argue for it. Present counter-arguments to show range, but conclude in favour — a neutral answer has not done what the directive asked.
Model answer
154 words · 150-word limitThe claim is Peter Singer's, and its force rests on one distinction: a duty is owed and its omission is a wrong, whereas charity is optional and its omission is merely a missed good.
Charity is supererogatory — praiseworthy but beyond requirement. Kant occupies the middle ground with imperfect duties: beneficence is obligatory in principle, though occasion and degree are left to judgement.
Singer reclassifies low-cost assistance as duty. If we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought to do it. His drowning-child analogy makes it vivid, and distance changes feelings, not obligations.
The counter-arguments are real: the demandingness objection, special obligations to family, and the structural nature of poverty.
Indian tradition reaches the same place, treating daan as obligation and trusteeship as surplus held for society. Once the cost is trivial and the benefit prevents serious suffering, calling it charity mainly serves to keep it optional.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide
Open with: The claim is Peter Singer's, and its force lies in a single distinction: a duty is owed and its omission is a wrong, whereas charity is optional and its omission is merely a missed good.
The distinction
- Duty (perfect obligation) — binding, owed to specific or general others, enforceable in blame; failure is culpable
- Charity (supererogation) — praiseworthy but optional; going beyond what is required, so omission attracts no blame
- Kant's imperfect duties — beneficence is obligatory in principle though the occasion and degree are left to judgement
Singer's argument for reclassifying it
- If we can prevent something very bad without sacrificing anything of comparable moral importance, we ought to do it
- The drowning child analogy — no one thinks rescuing a drowning child at the cost of muddy clothes is optional
- Physical and national distance are morally arbitrary; proximity changes feeling, not obligation
- Since the sacrifice is stipulated as not significantly affecting stability, the cost is not of comparable moral importance
Counter-arguments
- Demandingness objection — the principle may require giving until marginal sacrifice becomes severe, leaving no space for personal projects
- Special obligations to family and community have independent moral weight
- Institutional objection — poverty is a structural problem requiring taxation and state provision, not private transfers; individual giving may relieve conscience while leaving causes intact
- Kant's imperfect duty allows latitude in whom and how much to help, resisting Singer's strictness
Indian resonance
- Daan and dana as duty rather than favour; Gandhi's trusteeship treats surplus as held for society
- Article 51A(j) and the Directive Principles frame social responsibility as a shared obligation
Draw: A line diagram from 'no obligation' through 'imperfect duty' to 'perfect duty', with the stipulated low-cost case plotted towards the duty end.
Close with: Once the cost is stipulated as trivial and the benefit as preventing serious suffering, calling it charity is a way of keeping it optional — the claim is justified.
Read more — sources
- termDuty vs supererogation · Perfect and imperfect duties · Demandingness objection
- thinkerPeter Singer, Famine, Affluence and Morality (1972); Kant, Groundwork; Gandhi on trusteeship
- EdiShorts appMains GS-4 — Ethics: Moral Philosophy
Related questions from earlier years
More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2026
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.