EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2026GS Paper 4 (Ethics)Q10 · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Vikas, DC Nainipura — biometric authentication in PDS failing children, labourers and the elderly.

DirectiveCase Study
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

250 words across both parts, 20 marks. Identify stakeholders and the conflicting values, weigh the options, then commit to one course with safeguards. There is no single correct answer — there is a defensible one.

Common trap: Part (b) is a distinct conceptual question worth real marks — do not let it collapse into part (a). The asymmetry between exclusion and inclusion errors is the argument that carries both halves.

The case

Vikas is a government officer with over a decade of service in public administration. He has recently moved as the District Collector (DC) of Nainipura, a remote hilly district bordering a forest. Due to Nainipura's low levels of economic development, one of his major duties is to ensure proper functioning of the public distribution system (PDS) amongst the economically weaker sections (EWS).

During his on-site visits, Vikas was apprised of a typical administrative challenge in operating its PDS. To prevent leakages, all distributors were required to carry out real-time biometric identification of the beneficiaries, whose fingerprints were tallied with identity card records. This was creating problems as the operating system sometimes rejected fingerprint matching in the cases of growing children, manual labourers and senior citizens. The problem was further compounded in periods of low WiFi connectivity. The distributors, in such cases, resorted to personal discretion when they could identify the recipient.

Vikas had to address this problem on priority. Strictly adhering to government regulations would ensure fiscal probity but would greatly trouble the proposed beneficiary, i.e., EWS. It may even impinge on their fundamental right to life as per Article 21 of the Constitution. Conversely, leaving the resolution solely to the discretion of the distributors could lead to misuse and leakages.

(a) What are the options open to Vikas? How should he balance fiscal probity with empathy towards the designated beneficiaries?
(b) Discuss the ethics of using technology as a gatekeeper for welfare schemes.

Model answer

20 marks · 250 words
The core dilemma

An anti-leakage control that excludes precisely the people it was built to serve — where relaxing it invites diversion and enforcing it denies food to those entitled to it.

Stakeholders
EWS beneficiariesFood security and the right to life under Article 21; excluded by a technical failure not of their making
Manual labourers, children, the elderlyWorn or changing fingerprints make them structurally more likely to be denied
Fair price shop distributorsCarrying unauthorised discretion and personal risk either way
Vikas and the StateFiscal probity, leakage control, and accountability for exclusion errors
TaxpayersLegitimate interest in preventing diversion of subsidised grain
Ethical issues
  • Exclusion error versus inclusion error — the two are not morally equivalent: wrongly denying food to the entitled is graver than wrongly including some ineligible
  • Article 21 and the NFSA, 2013 create an entitlement; a verification method cannot lawfully extinguish it
  • Technology as gatekeeper — authentication designed for the median user systematically fails outliers, and the outliers here are the poorest
  • Displacement of accountability onto distributors, who exercise unauthorised discretion without protection or record
  • Dignity — repeated public failure at the ration shop is humiliating, not merely inconvenient
  • Means-ends inversion — leakage control was the means and food security the end; strict enforcement reverses them
  • Distributive justice — the burden of an infrastructure failure falls on those least able to bear it
Options available
1. Enforce biometric authentication strictly with no exceptions
MeritsMaximum leakage control; complete auditability; no discretion to misuse
CostsDenies food to genuinely entitled beneficiaries; likely violates Article 21 and NFSA entitlement; punishes people for worn fingerprints and poor connectivity
2. Leave resolution to distributor discretion as at present
MeritsBeneficiaries get grain; pragmatic and already operating
CostsUnrecorded, unaccountable discretion; open to diversion and to demanding favours; leaves the distributor personally exposed; no audit trail
3. Establish a layered, documented exception protocol with offline capability
MeritsPreserves the entitlement and the audit trail together; removes unauthorised discretion by replacing it with authorised, recorded procedure; fixes the infrastructure cause
CostsRequires investment in offline devices, alternative authentication and monitoring; some residual leakage risk
Recommended course

Course of action. Institute a layered authentication protocol — biometric first, then documented alternatives — with offline transaction capability, so no entitled beneficiary is turned away and every exception is recorded.

Why. The choice is not between probity and empathy but between unrecorded discretion and recorded procedure. The present arrangement already grants exceptions; it simply grants them invisibly, which is the worst of both worlds — the leakage risk remains and the beneficiary has no protection. Formalising the exception converts an unaccountable favour into an auditable entitlement. On the underlying moral question, exclusion and inclusion errors are not symmetric: wrongly denying grain to a hungry family is a graver wrong than wrongly including someone ineligible, because the first is irreversible harm to a right-holder and the second is a recoverable fiscal loss.

Safeguards. Enable offline authentication with later synchronisation so connectivity failure never denies grain. Permit documented alternatives — OTP to a registered mobile, iris scan, nominee authentication, or attestation by a designated local authority — each recorded with reason. Cap and monitor the exception rate per shop, investigating outliers rather than blocking transactions. Publish beneficiary lists locally for social audit. Provide a grievance number displayed at every shop and a same-day escalation route. Report the systemic device and connectivity failure upward with data, since the fix ultimately lies above the district.

Verdict. On part (b): technology used as a gatekeeper transfers the burden of state failure onto the citizen, and does so most heavily on those with the least capacity to contest it. It is ethically defensible only when it is one route among several, never the sole gate — an entitlement conferred by statute cannot be conditioned on a fingerprint reader working.

exclusion vs inclusion errorArticle 21NFSA, 2013layered authenticationrecorded discretionsocial auditmeans-ends inversiondignity

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2026

Q1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Owing to paucity of time, a university professor generates a Ph.D. evaluation report using Artificial Intelligence and submits it with some modifications. Discuss this from the perspective of accountability and integrity.
The fault is not the use of Artificial Intelligence but the concealment of authorship in a judgement the professor alone was entrusted to make.
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
A business house is working on a project that could displace a forest community from their habitat. As the administrative officer of that district, what ethical challenges are you likely to face?
As district officer I would stand where a development objective, a statutory right and a community's survival collide, and none can simply be set aside.
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
An endangered tribe has developed a severe skeletal deformity. A university research has identified a mineral supplement as a possible remedy, though clinical trials are yet to be conducted. Should the District Magistrate (DM) use this research on the tribe?…
No — not as proposed. Administering an untested supplement to an endangered, poorly informed population is precisely what research ethics exists to prevent.
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss how national security can be balanced with concerns of human rights.
The two are usually posed as a trade-off, but security exists in order to protect rights — so a practice that destroys rights has defeated its own purpose.
Read the model answer →
Q3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Dr. B. R. Ambedkar had cautioned that employing civil disobedience within a constitutional democracy equates to endorsing 'anarchy'. How should modern democracies navigate the ethical dilemmas posed by civil disobedience movements that aim to promote social…
Ambedkar's warning to the Constituent Assembly was conditional. He condemned the 'grammar of anarchy' precisely because constitutional methods of redress had become…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.