EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2026GS Paper 4 (Ethics)Q4(a) · 10 marksEthicsModel answer

Citing the serious adverse effects of long-term medication, a doctor convinces the family of a female patient for surgery. This led the patient to reluctantly consent for the surgery, though her original choice was to opt for medication. Explain the concepts of paternalism and beneficence by analysing the doctor's action.

DirectiveTheory
Marks10
Word limit150
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

150 words, 10 marks. Define the concept precisely, then apply it to the situation — Ethics rewards the application, not the definition.

Common trap: The question asks you to explain two concepts through the case. Define each precisely, then apply — an answer that only judges the doctor without defining paternalism and beneficence loses half the marks.

Model answer

164 words · 150-word limit
Introduction

The doctor's conduct is beneficent in motive and paternalistic in method. The difficulty is that he routed persuasion through the family rather than the patient, whose choice alone counted.

Body

Beneficence is the duty to act positively for the patient's welfare. Here it is genuine, since long-term medication carries documented adverse effects — but it justifies recommending strongly, not securing agreement by pressure.

Paternalism is overriding a competent person's preference for their own good. Soft paternalism, where consent is impaired, is often defensible; hard paternalism, overriding an informed competent choice, is not, because it denies moral agency. This sits closer to the second.

The method is the fault. Valid consent must be informed, voluntary and given by the patient herself; the family of a competent adult has no authority to consent. That she consented reluctantly signals a will overborne — consent in form, coercion in substance.

Conclusion

Good motive does not convert an overridden choice into consent: beneficence is legitimate only through autonomy, never around it.

+
Value addition: A two-axis grid of motive against method, with the doctor plotted in the benevolent-but-overriding quadrant, defines both concepts and delivers the verdict at once.
Answer plan — how to structure itShowHide

Open with: The doctor's conduct is beneficent in motive and paternalistic in method — and the ethical difficulty is that he routed persuasion through the family rather than the patient, whose choice was the only one that counted.

Beneficence

  • The duty to act for the patient's welfare, actively promoting good and not merely avoiding harm
  • Here genuine: long-term medication carries documented adverse effects, so surgery may objectively serve her interest
  • Beneficence justifies recommending strongly; it does not justify securing agreement by pressure

Paternalism

  • Overriding a competent person's preference for their own good
  • Soft paternalism — intervening where consent is uninformed or impaired — is often defensible
  • Hard paternalism — overriding an informed, competent choice — is not, because it denies moral agency
  • This is closer to hard paternalism, and is aggravated by the route taken

Why the method is the fault

  • Autonomy requires that consent be informed, voluntary and by the patient herself; a competent adult's family has no authority to consent for her
  • 'Reluctantly consent' signals the will was overborne — consent in form, coercion in substance
  • Gendered dimension: routing decisions through the family disproportionately displaces women's medical autonomy
  • Erodes trust, the doctor's core professional asset, and exposes him to liability

What he should have done

  • Full disclosure of risks and benefits of both options directly to her, in her language
  • Offer a second opinion and time to decide; document the discussion
  • Accept her informed refusal if it persists — a competent patient may choose the option the doctor thinks worse

Draw: A two-axis grid — motive (benevolent/self-serving) against method (respecting/overriding autonomy) — with the doctor plotted in the benevolent-but-overriding quadrant.

Close with: Good motive does not convert an overridden choice into consent; beneficence is legitimate only when exercised through the patient's autonomy, never around it.

beneficencepaternalismsoft and hard paternalismautonomyinformed consentcompetent adultvoluntariness

Read more — sources

  • termBeneficence · Non-maleficence · Autonomy · Soft vs hard paternalism
  • thinkerJ.S. Mill, On Liberty — the harm principle and the limits of paternalism; Beauchamp and Childress
  • EdiShorts appMains GS-4 — Applied Ethics: Medical

Related questions from earlier years

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2026

Q1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Owing to paucity of time, a university professor generates a Ph.D. evaluation report using Artificial Intelligence and submits it with some modifications. Discuss this from the perspective of accountability and integrity.
The fault is not the use of Artificial Intelligence but the concealment of authorship in a judgement the professor alone was entrusted to make.
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
A business house is working on a project that could displace a forest community from their habitat. As the administrative officer of that district, what ethical challenges are you likely to face?
As district officer I would stand where a development objective, a statutory right and a community's survival collide, and none can simply be set aside.
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
An endangered tribe has developed a severe skeletal deformity. A university research has identified a mineral supplement as a possible remedy, though clinical trials are yet to be conducted. Should the District Magistrate (DM) use this research on the tribe?…
No — not as proposed. Administering an untested supplement to an endangered, poorly informed population is precisely what research ethics exists to prevent.
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss how national security can be balanced with concerns of human rights.
The two are usually posed as a trade-off, but security exists in order to protect rights — so a practice that destroys rights has defeated its own purpose.
Read the model answer →
Q3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Dr. B. R. Ambedkar had cautioned that employing civil disobedience within a constitutional democracy equates to endorsing 'anarchy'. How should modern democracies navigate the ethical dilemmas posed by civil disobedience movements that aim to promote social…
Ambedkar's warning to the Constituent Assembly was conditional. He condemned the 'grammar of anarchy' precisely because constitutional methods of redress had become…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.