EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2026GS Paper 4 (Ethics)Q7 · 20 marksCase StudyModel answer

Lata and Dr. Mansi — consent for hysterectomy taken from the sister-in-law while the patient was under anaesthesia.

DirectiveCase Study
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper 4 (Ethics)
What the examiner wants

250 words across both parts, 20 marks. Identify stakeholders and the conflicting values, weigh the options, then commit to one course with safeguards. There is no single correct answer — there is a defensible one.

Common trap: The commonest error is treating Sujatha's written consent as if it cured the defect. It did not — for a competent adult, no relative can consent. Say so explicitly in part (a).

The case

Lata, a mother of two children, was admitted to a hospital for acute abdominal pain. Her sister-in-law, Sujatha, accompanied her. Dr. Mansi examined Lata and recommended a diagnostic laparoscopy. Lata's consent was taken to conduct the medical procedure under general anaesthesia.

During the laparoscopy, Dr. Mansi's team discovered a tumor in Lata's uterus. A closer examination suggested that the tumor could be malignant.

One option before Dr. Mansi was to extract a sample for biopsy. In that case, if the tumor was malignant, Lata would have to undergo another surgery for removal of the uterus. An alternative was to remove the uterus immediately. Dr. Mansi had to take a quick decision.

As Lata was under general anaesthesia, Dr. Mansi explained the situation to Sujatha. Sujatha agreed with Dr. Mansi's recommendations for a hysterectomy, wherein Lata's uterus would be removed to avoid the risk and pain of undergoing another surgery. Dr. Mansi removed Lata's uterus after receiving Sujatha's consent in writing. Lata was informed of this the next day. She was very upset and felt betrayed as she had not consented to the removal of her uterus.

Lata complained to the police who tried to convince her that Dr. Mansi had acted with good intention to help a patient. Sujatha was of the same opinion, however Lata was not convinced and decided to approach the court.

(a) Discuss the ethical issues involved in this case.
(b) Discuss the moral conduct of the doctor in this situation.

Model answer

20 marks · 250 words
The core dilemma

Beneficence — sparing Lata a second surgery — set against autonomy, where the only person entitled to consent was unconscious and the person who did consent had no authority to do so.

Stakeholders
LataBodily autonomy and reproductive capacity, irreversibly removed without her consent; her trust in the medical system
Dr. MansiProfessional duty to act in the patient's interest; her own liability and reputation
SujathaActed in good faith but exceeded any authority she held; now positioned against Lata
The hospitalInstitutional consent protocol and vicarious liability
Women patients generallyPrecedent for family-mediated consent that displaces women's own decisions
Ethical issues
  • Informed consent — consent for a diagnostic laparoscopy cannot extend to a therapeutic hysterectomy; scope of consent was exceeded
  • Autonomy — a competent adult's family cannot consent on her behalf; Sujatha's written consent had no legal or moral standing
  • Beneficence versus paternalism — a genuine intention to spare pain does not authorise an irreversible decision
  • Non-maleficence — the tumour was only suspected malignant; a biopsy would have established the fact before an irreversible step
  • Gender dimension — routing consent through the family disproportionately strips women of medical decision-making
  • Institutional failure — no protocol for intra-operative discoveries, and no attempt to await her recovery
  • Truthfulness — she was informed only the next day, after the fact
Options available
1. Extract a biopsy sample, close, and seek Lata's own informed consent on recovery
MeritsRespects autonomy fully; establishes malignancy as fact rather than suspicion; reversible at every step
CostsRequires a second surgery with additional anaesthetic risk, cost and delay if malignant
2. Remove the uterus immediately on Sujatha's consent (the course actually taken)
MeritsAvoids a second surgery; addresses a suspected malignancy at once
CostsIrreversible act without valid consent; consent taken from a person with no authority; violates autonomy and exceeds the scope consented to
3. Await Lata's recovery from anaesthesia and obtain her decision, with the family informed
MeritsPreserves autonomy while allowing an urgent decision within hours
CostsOnly viable if the delay is clinically safe; may still require re-operation
Recommended course

Course of action. Dr. Mansi should have taken a biopsy sample and closed, then disclosed the finding to Lata herself and obtained her informed consent for any hysterectomy.

Why. Emergency treatment without consent is justified only where delay threatens life or limb and the patient cannot decide. A suspected — not confirmed — malignancy in a stable, anaesthetised patient does not meet that threshold. Lata was temporarily unable to consent, not permanently incapable, so waiting was possible. Sujatha's written consent was procedurally meaningless: for a competent adult, family consent has no standing in Indian medical law or in the ethical principle of autonomy.

Safeguards. Hospitals should carry a written intra-operative discovery protocol, take extended consent before surgery covering foreseeable findings with the patient's own stated preferences, document all intra-operative decisions contemporaneously, and refer non-emergency intra-operative dilemmas to a second opinion.

Verdict. Dr. Mansi's motive was benevolent and her conduct was ethically wrong. Good intention mitigates culpability; it does not convert an unauthorised irreversible act into a permissible one. Lata's recourse to the court is legitimate, and the institution shares responsibility for the absent protocol.

informed consentscope of consentautonomybeneficencepaternalismemergency exceptioncompetent adultintra-operative discovery

More from GS Paper 4 (Ethics) 2026

Q1(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Owing to paucity of time, a university professor generates a Ph.D. evaluation report using Artificial Intelligence and submits it with some modifications. Discuss this from the perspective of accountability and integrity.
The fault is not the use of Artificial Intelligence but the concealment of authorship in a judgement the professor alone was entrusted to make.
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
A business house is working on a project that could displace a forest community from their habitat. As the administrative officer of that district, what ethical challenges are you likely to face?
As district officer I would stand where a development objective, a statutory right and a community's survival collide, and none can simply be set aside.
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
An endangered tribe has developed a severe skeletal deformity. A university research has identified a mineral supplement as a possible remedy, though clinical trials are yet to be conducted. Should the District Magistrate (DM) use this research on the tribe?…
No — not as proposed. Administering an untested supplement to an endangered, poorly informed population is precisely what research ethics exists to prevent.
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Discuss how national security can be balanced with concerns of human rights.
The two are usually posed as a trade-off, but security exists in order to protect rights — so a practice that destroys rights has defeated its own purpose.
Read the model answer →
Q3(a)·10 marks·150 words·Ethics
Dr. B. R. Ambedkar had cautioned that employing civil disobedience within a constitutional democracy equates to endorsing 'anarchy'. How should modern democracies navigate the ethical dilemmas posed by civil disobedience movements that aim to promote social…
Ambedkar's warning to the Constituent Assembly was conditional. He condemned the 'grammar of anarchy' precisely because constitutional methods of redress had become…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.