"As regards the increasing rates of melting of Arctic Sea ice, the interests of the Arctic Council nations may not coincide with those of the wider world." Explain.
Make clear why the eight Arctic states may see opportunity in melting sea ice while the rest of the world sees mainly risk, using the specific interests on each side.
Common trap: Students often write only about global warming. The point of the question is the divergence of interests: Arctic states gain shipping routes, hydrocarbons and seabed claims, while the world bears sea-level rise, climate feedbacks and monsoon disruption — and has little say in an eight-member Council.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international institutions and global environmental issues (the Arctic)
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitThe Arctic Council, set up by the Ottawa Declaration of 1996, has eight members — Canada, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Russia, Sweden and the USA. Summer Arctic sea ice shrank to a record low in 2007, and the faster it melts, the more the region's states stand to gain economically even as the wider world faces the costs.
- Northern Sea Route, Northwest Passage
- Oil, gas and minerals
- Seabed claims under UNCLOS
- New fisheries and tourism
- Sea-level rise for coasts, islands
- Faster warming via albedo loss
- Methane from thawing permafrost
- Weather and monsoon disruption
Interests of the Arctic states
- Shipping: Ice-free summers open the Northern Sea Route along Russia and the Northwest Passage through Canada, which shorten Europe–Asia voyages and earn transit fees.
- Resources: The US Geological Survey (2008) estimated that the Arctic holds a large share of the world's undiscovered oil and gas.
- Sovereignty: Russia planted a flag on the North Pole seabed in 2007, and the five coastal states asserted their primacy in the Ilulissat Declaration of 2008.
Interests of the wider world
- Climate feedback: Dark open water absorbs more heat than ice, so melting accelerates global warming.
- Distant impacts: Sea-level rise from Greenland's ice and changed circulation threaten low-lying states such as Bangladesh and the Maldives, and may affect the Indian monsoon.
- Governance gap: The Council is a forum of the eight states; outsiders, including India, which runs the Himadri research station at Svalbard (2008), have no vote, and the Arctic is not a treaty-protected commons like Antarctica.
The Arctic risks being treated as a resource frontier by a few rather than a climate regulator for all. A wider say for observers and strict environmental rules on shipping and drilling are needed. (Later: India became an Arctic Council observer in 2013 and released an Arctic Policy in 2022.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialOttawa Declaration on the Establishment of the Arctic Council (1996) and the Ilulissat Declaration (2008)
- ReportIPCC Fourth Assessment Report (2007), Working Group I — polar regions and sea ice
- ReportUS Geological Survey, Circum-Arctic Resource Appraisal (2008)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.