To what extent has the withdrawal of al-Shabab from Mogadishu given peace a real chance in Somalia? Assess.
Weigh the gains from al-Shabab's August 2011 pull-out from Mogadishu against the factors still blocking peace, and judge how real the chance of peace is.
Common trap: Do not treat the withdrawal as victory. A good assessment notes that al-Shabab called it a 'tactical' move, kept most of south-central Somalia and turned to suicide bombings, while the weak Transitional Federal Government, the famine and clan politics remained — and links the issue to piracy that affects Indian shipping and seafarers.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international affairs; conflicts in Africa and the role of the UN and regional organisations
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitOn 6 August 2011 al-Shabab, the al-Qaeda-linked Islamist militia, announced a 'tactical withdrawal' from most of Mogadishu after sustained fighting with the African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM) — mainly Ugandan and Burundian troops — and forces of the Transitional Federal Government (TFG).
- Capital under TFG and AMISOM
- Aid can reach famine victims
- Kampala Accord and Roadmap
- Militia weakened by famine, defections
- Still holds south and centre
- Turns to suicide bombings
- Weak, corrupt TFG
- Clan rivalry, piracy, famine
Why a chance has opened
- Control of the capital: For the first time in years the TFG and AMISOM held most of Mogadishu, allowing markets and aid agencies to return.
- Political roadmap: The Kampala Accord (June 2011) and the Roadmap agreed in September 2011 set tasks for ending the transition by August 2012.
- Pressure on al-Shabab: Famine, its ban on Western food aid and Kenya's military operation in the south from October 2011 weakened it.
Why peace is far from assured
- Militia intact: Al-Shabab still ruled much of south-central Somalia; its truck bomb in Mogadishu in October 2011 killed scores of people.
- Weak state: The TFG lacked revenue, an army and legitimacy, and clan rivalries and regional entities such as Puntland pulled in different directions.
- Humanitarian crisis: The UN declared famine in parts of southern Somalia in July 2011; piracy off the coast continued to threaten shipping, including Indian sailors.
The withdrawal gave peace a chance, not a guarantee: military gains must be matched by a legitimate government, jobs for the young and steady AU funding. (Later: a Federal Government replaced the TFG in 2012, though al-Shabab remained a potent threat.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialUN Security Council Resolution 1744 (2007) authorising AMISOM, and later resolutions on Somalia
- ReportReports of the UN Secretary-General on Somalia (2011)
- ReportInternational Crisis Group, Somalia: The Transitional Government on Life Support, Africa Report 170 (2011)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.