"The causes and implications of the Jasmine Revolution and its spread are as much economic in nature as they are political." Critically evaluate.
Test the claim that the Jasmine Revolution and the wider Arab uprisings had economic as much as political causes and effects: give evidence for both, show where one weighed more, and reach a balanced verdict.
Common trap: Many answers narrate events country by country. 'Critically evaluate' needs two balance sheets — causes and implications — each split into economic and political strands, plus the evidence that the wealthy Gulf monarchies largely escaped, which shows how economics conditioned politics.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international affairs; developments in West Asia and North Africa and their impact on India
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitThe Jasmine Revolution began when Mohamed Bouazizi, a vegetable seller harassed by officials, set himself on fire in Sidi Bouzid on 17 December 2010; within four weeks President Ben Ali fled Tunisia (14 January 2011). The protests spread to Egypt, Libya, Yemen, Bahrain and Syria, and both their roots and their consequences were economic as well as political.
- Joblessness, food prices, corruption
- Bouazizi's self-immolation, Dec 2010
- Ben Ali flees, Jan 2011
- Mubarak resigns, Feb 2011
- Libya war; UN Resolution 1973
- Unrest in Yemen, Bahrain, Syria
Economic causes
- Youth unemployment: The Arab world had among the highest youth unemployment rates in the world; educated young people had no jobs.
- Food inflation: Global food prices hit record levels in early 2011; bread and staples became costly in import-dependent Egypt and Tunisia.
- Crony capitalism: Reforms enriched ruling families and their associates, as with the Trabelsi clan in Tunisia, widening inequality.
Political causes
- Long-ruling regimes: Ben Ali ruled 23 years, Mubarak nearly 30 under an Emergency law in force since 1981, and Gaddafi over 40.
- Dignity and repression: Police brutality and the denial of voice made 'dignity' and 'freedom' the main slogans.
- New media: Facebook, Twitter, Al Jazeera and the WikiLeaks cables on elite corruption helped protesters mobilise.
Implications
- Economic: Oil prices rose above 100 dollars a barrel, tourism and investment collapsed, and Gulf states paid for subsidies and jobs to buy social peace.
- Political: Regimes fell in Tunisia, Egypt and Libya; Islamist parties such as Ennahda won Tunisia's October 2011 elections; NATO intervened in Libya; Syria slid into conflict.
- For India: Higher oil bills, risk to remittances, and Operation Safe Homecoming to evacuate about 15,000 Indians from Libya.
Evaluation
- Economics as a trigger: Rich Gulf monarchies largely escaped by spending, which shows the economic element in the uprisings.
- Politics as the core: Bahrain's unrest despite high incomes, and the demand for elections and accountability, show the political core.
Economic grievances lit the fuse, but the explosion was political — a demand for dignity and accountability from ageing autocracies. Lasting stability will need both jobs and legitimate institutions, which is why the outcome remained uncertain in 2011. (Later: Egypt's elected government fell in 2013, while Tunisia adopted a new constitution in 2014.)
Read more — sources
- ReportUNDP, Arab Human Development Report 2009: Challenges to Human Security in the Arab Countries
- ReportFAO Food Price Index, 2010–11 (record food prices)
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs — Annual Report 2011–12 (Operation Safe Homecoming, Libya)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.