In the context of the 'Euro-zone' debt crisis, examine the proposed 'six-pack' solution. Do you think that this has a better chance of success than the earlier Stability and Growth Pact?
Explain the euro-zone debt crisis briefly, set out what the six-pack's six measures change, and then judge — with reasons on both sides — whether it is likelier to work than the original Stability and Growth Pact.
Common trap: A weak answer says 'six-pack means six laws for discipline'. A strong answer names what is new — the debt criterion, the expenditure benchmark, reverse qualified majority voting for sanctions and the macroeconomic imbalance procedure — and judges it against the SGP's record (France and Germany's breach in 2003, the 2005 relaxation) and against problems it does not solve, such as the lack of a fiscal union and the bank–sovereign loop.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international economic issues and institutions (the euro-zone crisis)
Model answer
20 marks · 250-word limitThe euro-zone crisis began when Greece revealed in late 2009 that its deficit was far higher than reported; Ireland and Portugal then needed bailouts, and by 2011 the pressure had reached Italy and Spain. Because the 1997 Stability and Growth Pact (SGP) had failed to enforce discipline, the EU adopted the 'six-pack' — five regulations and one directive — which entered into force on 13 December 2011.
- 3% deficit, 60% debt ceilings
- Deficit rule enforced, debt ignored
- Sanctions need a majority to act
- No check on imbalances
- Debt rule: cut excess by 1/20 a year
- Expenditure benchmark
- Reverse majority: sanctions near-automatic
- Macroeconomic imbalance procedure
What the six-pack contains
- Preventive arm: Countries must move towards a medium-term budget objective, checked by an expenditure benchmark that keeps spending growth below potential growth.
- Corrective arm: The Excessive Deficit Procedure can now be opened for debt too: debt above 60 per cent of GDP must fall by one-twentieth of the excess each year.
- Sanctions: Interest-bearing deposits and fines of up to 0.2 per cent of GDP, proposed by the Commission, apply unless a qualified majority of finance ministers rejects them (reverse qualified majority voting).
- Imbalances: A Macroeconomic Imbalance Procedure uses a scoreboard of indicators such as current-account balances and house prices, with fines up to 0.1 per cent of GDP for euro states.
- National frameworks: A directive sets minimum standards for national budget rules, statistics and forecasts, tied to the European Semester begun in 2011.
Why it has a better chance
- Less political bargaining: Under the SGP, France and Germany escaped sanctions in 2003 and the Pact was relaxed in 2005; reverse voting makes such escapes harder.
- Wider net: Spain and Ireland had low deficits before 2008 but suffered from property bubbles and private debt, which the imbalance procedure can now flag.
- Earlier action: The European Semester reviews budgets before national parliaments adopt them.
Why doubts remain
- Fines on the weak: Fining a country already in crisis worsens its position and is politically hard to impose.
- No fiscal union: There is no common treasury, Eurobonds or full lender of last resort, so markets may still attack weaker states.
- Austerity bias: Simultaneous cuts in a recession can deepen downturns and make debt targets harder to meet.
- Bank–sovereign loop: Weak banks holding government bonds were the core of the crisis, which fiscal rules alone cannot break.
The six-pack is stronger than the SGP because it tracks debt and imbalances and makes sanctions near-automatic, but it addresses the symptoms of fiscal indiscipline, not the design flaws of a monetary union without fiscal and banking union. (Later: the Fiscal Compact of 2012, the 'two-pack' of 2013, the European Stability Mechanism and the ECB's 2012 pledge to do 'whatever it takes' filled some of these gaps.)
Read more — sources
- OfficialRegulations (EU) No 1173/2011 to 1177/2011 and Council Directive 2011/85/EU (the 'six-pack'), Official Journal of the EU, November 2011
- OfficialEuropean Commission, DG ECFIN — 'EU Economic Governance: the six-pack' (2011)
- OfficialResolution of the European Council on the Stability and Growth Pact (Amsterdam, 1997)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.