EdiShorts
UPSC Mains 2011GS Paper II (old)Q1(c) · 20 marksIRModel answer

"Compared to the South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA), the Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multisectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation Free Trade Area (BIMSTEC FTA) seems to be more promising." Critically evaluate.

DirectiveCritically evaluate
Marks20
Word limit250
PaperGS Paper II (old)
What the examiner wants

Compare SAFTA and the proposed BIMSTEC FTA on membership, design and performance, test the claim that BIMSTEC is 'more promising', note where the claim is weak, and give a clear verdict.

Common trap: A common error is to praise BIMSTEC without noting that its FTA was still only a framework under negotiation in 2011. The top answer contrasts structure (Pakistan factor, ASEAN bridge, services and investment coverage) with the hard facts — SAFTA is in force but hollowed by sensitive lists, while the BIMSTEC FTA has not been concluded.

SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — regional groupings and India's trade relations with its neighbourhood

Model answer

20 marks · 250-word limit

SAFTA was signed at the Islamabad SAARC summit in January 2004 and came into force on 1 January 2006, binding the eight SAARC states to cut tariffs in phases. The Framework Agreement for a BIMSTEC FTA, among Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Myanmar, Nepal, Sri Lanka and Thailand, was also signed in 2004, but in 2011 it was still being negotiated.

SAFTA
  • In force since 2006
  • Hostage to India–Pakistan ties
  • Long sensitive lists
  • Goods only
vs
BIMSTEC FTA
  • Framework signed 2004, not concluded
  • No Pakistan veto
  • Links South and Southeast Asia
  • Covers goods, services, investment
SAFTA versus BIMSTEC FTA (position in 2011)

Why SAFTA has disappointed

  • Political hostage: India–Pakistan hostility has blocked deeper liberalisation; Pakistan traded with India on a short positive list and had not granted India MFN status.
  • Sensitive lists: Each member excluded hundreds of tariff lines, often the products the region actually trades, so preferential trade under SAFTA stayed small.
  • Non-tariff barriers: Poor border infrastructure, standards and customs delays keep intra-regional trade at around five per cent of South Asia's total trade.

Why BIMSTEC looks more promising

  • Fewer political vetoes: Without Pakistan, the members have no comparable bilateral conflict, and decisions are easier.
  • Bridge to ASEAN: Thailand and Myanmar connect the grouping to Southeast Asia, fitting India's Look East Policy and the India–ASEAN goods agreement in force from January 2010.
  • Wider scope: The framework covers goods, services and investment, and BIMSTEC also works on energy, transport, tourism and counter-terrorism.
  • Natural complementarities: The Bay of Bengal economies — India's Northeast, Bangladesh, Myanmar — have obvious links in gas, hydropower and transit.

The critical view

  • Still on paper: Negotiations on goods stalled over negative lists and rules of origin; a framework is not a functioning FTA.
  • Overlapping deals: India already has bilateral FTAs with Sri Lanka (in force 2000) and Thailand (early-harvest, 2004) and the ASEAN agreement, which lowers BIMSTEC's added value.
  • Same asymmetry fears: Smaller members fear Indian dominance, and Myanmar's isolation and poor connectivity limit gains.
  • Weak institutions: BIMSTEC had no permanent secretariat in 2011 and its summits were infrequent.

BIMSTEC is structurally more promising because it avoids the India–Pakistan deadlock and links South Asia to ASEAN, but promise is not performance: until the FTA is concluded, SAFTA remains the only working regional trade regime. India should pursue both, using connectivity projects to give either one substance. (Later: a BIMSTEC secretariat opened at Dhaka in 2014 and the BIMSTEC Charter was adopted in 2022.)

Answer length. This model answer runs to about 352 words so that every relevant angle is covered. In the exam, write to the 250-word limit: keep the opening, the strongest one or two points under each heading, the diagram and the conclusion.

Read more — sources

  • OfficialSAARC Secretariat — Agreement on South Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA), Islamabad, 2004
  • OfficialBIMSTEC — Framework Agreement on the BIMSTEC Free Trade Area (2004)
  • ReportWorld Bank, South Asia regional integration studies (intra-regional trade in South Asia)
  • NCERTContemporary World Politics (Class XII) — Ch. 5, Contemporary South Asia (SAARC and SAFTA)

More from GS Paper II (old) 2011

Q1(a)·20 marks·250 words·IR
List the Central Asian Republics and identify those of particular strategic and economic importance to India. Examine the opportunities and bottlenecks in enhancing relations with these countries.
The five Central Asian Republics (CARs) — Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan — became independent when the Soviet Union dissolved in 1991.…
Read the model answer →
Q1(b)·20 marks·250 words·IR
Critically examine the security and strategic implications of the so-called 'string of pearls' theory for India.
'String of pearls' is a label, coined in a 2005 Booz Allen Hamilton study for the US Department of Defense, for China's growing network of port projects and facilities…
Read the model answer →
Q2(a)·12 marks·150 words·IR
Subsequent to the Nuclear Suppliers' Group (NSG) waiver in 2008, what are the agreements on nuclear energy that India has signed with different countries?
On 6 September 2008 the 45-member Nuclear Suppliers Group exempted India from its full-scope safeguards rule, ending three decades of nuclear isolation after the 1974…
Read the model answer →
Q2(b)·12 marks·150 words·IR
Trace the progress of India's efforts for a joint counter-terrorism strategy with China. What are the likely implications of the recent Xinjiang violence on these efforts?
India and China both face cross-border terrorism — India from Pakistan-based groups, China from Uighur militants of the East Turkestan Islamic Movement (ETIM) in…
Read the model answer →
Q2(c)·12 marks·150 words·Economy, IR
Bring out the importance of the 'Small and Medium Enterprises Expo and Conference' held in Dubai last year for Indian business.
The Small and Medium Enterprises (SME) Expo and Conference held in Dubai in 2010 brought together small firms, bankers, trade bodies and officials from India, the UAE…
Read the model answer →

Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.