"Strategic interests seem to be replacing commercial interests for the host country with regard to Cam Ranh Bay." Amplify.
Expand on the statement with evidence: show Cam Ranh Bay's past and planned commercial uses, then explain how South China Sea tensions are making its strategic value paramount for Vietnam.
Common trap: Weak answers describe the bay's geography only. Amplify means build the argument: Cam Ranh's history as a US and then Soviet base, Vietnam's 2010 plan to open it to foreign navies on a commercial basis, and the 2011 South China Sea incidents that turn a ship-repair business into a strategic lever balancing China — with India's stake noted.
SyllabusOld-pattern GS Paper II (2006–12): India and the World — international affairs in the Asia-Pacific; India's Look East Policy
Model answer
12 marks · 150-word limitCam Ranh Bay on Vietnam's south-central coast is one of Asia's finest deep-water harbours. It was a major US base in the Vietnam War and was leased to the Soviet Union and then Russia from 1979 until Russia left in 2002; Vietnam then looked to it mainly for commercial uses.
- 1960s–1972US naval and air base
- 1979–2002Soviet, then Russian, naval base
- 2000sCommercial port and airport plans
- Oct 2010Opened to foreign navies for repairs
- 2011South China Sea incidents with China
The commercial phase
- Business uses: After 2002 Vietnam planned ship-repair yards, a civilian airport, tourism and logistics at Cam Ranh to earn revenue.
- Open to all navies: In October 2010 Prime Minister Nguyen Tan Dung said Cam Ranh would offer repair and supply services to foreign naval ships, presented as a commercial service.
Why strategy is now dominant
- South China Sea disputes: China and Vietnam contest the Paracels (seized by China in 1974) and the Spratlys; in 2011 Chinese vessels cut the survey cables of a PetroVietnam ship.
- Balancing China: Access for the US, Russian, Indian and other navies helps Vietnam deter China without a formal alliance; the US welcomed the move, and Vietnam had ordered six Kilo-class submarines from Russia in 2009.
- India's stake: ONGC Videsh explores Vietnamese offshore blocks that China disputes, and INS Airavat was warned by radio off Vietnam in July 2011, adding India to the strategic picture.
Cam Ranh is a case of a port's commercial plan becoming a tool of deterrence. Vietnam's interest is to offer access to many navies, staying non-aligned while drawing powers into its security. (Later: Vietnam opened the Cam Ranh International Port in 2016.)
Read more — sources
- BookBill Hayton, The South China Sea: The Struggle for Power in Asia (2014)
- OfficialMinistry of External Affairs — India–Vietnam Joint Declaration on Strategic Partnership (2007) and Annual Report 2011–12
- ReportInternational Crisis Group, Stirring up the South China Sea (I) and (II), Asia Reports 223 and 229 (2012)
More from GS Paper II (old) 2011
Model answer by the EdiShorts editorial team. It is one well-argued treatment of the question, written to the official word limit — not an official UPSC answer key.