UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q46 · Numeracy
A man started from home at 14:30 hours and drove to village, arriving there when the village clock indicated 15:15 hours. After staying for 25 minutes, he drove back by a different route of length 1·25 times the first route at a rate twice as fast reaching home at 16:00 hours. As compared to the clock at home, the village clock is
- a10 minutes slow
- b5 minutes slow
- c10 minutes fast
- d5 minutes fast
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The actual travel time to the village is 40 minutes, making the true arrival time 15:10, whereas the village clock showed 15:15, which means it is 5 minutes fast.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- Calculates incorrect travel time or misinterprets the fast and slow direction.
- If the village clock shows 15:15 when real time is 15:10, it is ahead of actual time, not behind.
- Reverses the direction of clock error by assuming 15:15 means the clock is behind actual time.
- Since the actual arrival time is 15:10, a reading of 15:15 means the clock is fast, not slow.
- Arrives at a 10-minute discrepancy due to miscalculating the return journey time ratio or ignoring the stay duration.
- Subtracting 25 minutes from 90 total elapsed minutes leaves 65 minutes of driving time, yielding T1 = 40 minutes, not 35 or 45 minutes.
- Total time elapsed from home departure at 14:30 to return at 16:00 is 90 minutes.
- Excluding the 25-minute stay at the village gives total driving time of 65 minutes.
- Ratio of return time T2 to forward time T1 is 1.25 / 2 = 0.625, making total driving time T1 + 0.625 T1 = 1.625 T1 = 65 minutes.
- Solving 1.625 T1 = 65 gives T1 = 40 minutes, so true arrival time at village is 14:30 + 40 minutes = 15:10.
- Since the village clock indicated 15:15 when true home time was 15:10, the village clock is 5 minutes fast.
Concept to know
- Time equals Distance divided by Speed: If distance becomes D2 = 1.25 D1 and speed becomes S2 = 2 S1, then return time T2 = (1.25 / 2) T1 = 0.625 T1.
- Total Elapsed Time breakdown: Total elapsed time equals Forward travel time plus Stay duration plus Return travel time.
- Calculating actual arrival time: Home departure time plus Forward travel time equals True arrival time at destination.
- Comparing clocks: If Village Clock Time is greater than True Time, the village clock is fast. If Village Clock Time is less than True Time, it is slow.
Related facts for revision
- Clock gain and loss problems involving incorrect timepieces.
- Average speed and ratio-based speed-distance-time problems.
- Travel problems involving intermediate stoppage time.
Ability to formulate algebraic equations combining Speed-Distance-Time ratios with clock error comparisons.
Trap: Confusing fast versus slow or forgetting to subtract the intermediate stay duration from total elapsed time.
More Numeracy PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.