UPSC Prelims 2022 CSAT Q34 · Comprehension
With steady economic growth, higher literacy and increasing skill levels, the number of Indian middle-class families has gone up exponentially. Direct results of the affluence have been changes in dietary patterns and energy consumption levels. People have moved to a higher protein-based diet like milk products, fish and meat, all of which need significantly more water to produce than cereal-based diets. Increasing use of electronic and electric machines/gadgets and motor vehicles needs more and more energy and generation of energy needs water.
Which one of the following statements best reflects the crux of the passage?
- aPeople should be persuaded to continue with the mainly Indian traditional cereal-based diets.
- bIndia needs to focus on developing agricultural productivity and capacity for more energy generation in the coming years.
- cModern technological developments result in the change of cultural and social behaviour of the people.
- dWater management practices in India need to change dramatically in the coming years.
Show answer & explanationHide answer
The passage highlights how both changing dietary habits and rising energy demands lead directly to exponential increases in water consumption, making water management the central requirement.
Statement-by-statement analysis
- The passage neutrally describes the shift toward high-protein diets without advocating a forced return to traditional cereal-based diets.
- Recommending behavioral persuasion goes beyond the core implication of the text.
- Focusing merely on expanding agricultural productivity and energy capacity ignores the fundamental constraint mentioned in the passage, which is water.
- Expanding these without managing water would exacerbate the water crisis highlighted by the author.
- While technology influences lifestyle, this option is an overly broad sociological generalization.
- It ignores the explicit environmental and resource constraint of water consumption central to the author's argument.
- Both high-protein diets and energy generation consume vast amounts of water.
- Since affluence drives both dietary changes and energy use, water management emerges as the primary critical requirement for the future.
Concept to know
- Identify the common underlying factor or unifying thread connecting all major points in the passage.
- Distinguish between a cause, a symptom, and the central implication or takeaway.
- Avoid options that offer practical policy recommendations not backed by the author's primary focus.
- Beware of broad sociological or generic statements that sound true in reality but miss the central argument of the passage.
- The crux of a passage represents the central thesis without which the author's main argument falls apart.
Related facts for revision
- Main Idea versus Supporting Detail questions where options focus on a single premise rather than the whole argument.
- Practical Implication questions that require identifying the logical necessity arising from resource constraints.
- Extreme Tone traps where options suggest dictatorial or unrealistic behavioral changes.
- Broad Generalization traps where an option makes a generic claim not focused on the text.
Ability to synthesize multiple strands of an argument to find the central unifying constraint.
Trap: Option (b) is a common trap because candidates focus on economic growth outputs rather than the underlying scarce input resource.
More Comprehension PYQs
Answer from the official UPSC answer key. Explanation by the EdiShorts editorial team.